What this covers

Bill Kristol interviews Doug Sosnik, a former political director for Bill Clinton, about a memo Sosnik wrote on the road to a political realignment. The publisher's chapter markers point to the classified documents indictment and the question of further indictments, but the conversation is mostly about how voting patterns have been rearranged. Sosnik treats the education fault line as the central sorting mechanism. He says a district's education profile predicts its vote far better than race once did. Kristol adds that the split is cultural as well as economic, tied to comfort with diversity, and that it explains the "red dots in blue states" pattern.

The range is wide. Sosnik gives an economic history: shareholder capitalism and offshoring from the 1980s, and a delinking after the early 1970s in which productivity rose while wages and employment stayed flat. He and Kristol trace the coalition shifts that followed, from George H.W. Bush carrying upscale suburbs to the Tea Party takeover of the Republican Party. They also take up the Democratic idea that demography is destiny and why it has not delivered the Sun Belt. Young voters, in Sosnik's account, split by education too, and they define themselves against Republicans more than for Democrats.

The more contentious claims concern incentives and tone. Sosnik argues that all politics is national), that primary challenges reward extreme behavior, and that a handful of swing states decide the presidency. He says Democrats lose ground when voters feel looked down on, and that the 75 million Trump voters are not all "idiots," though some are beyond reach. He treats abortion referendums in red states as a sign of that issue's strength. He ends on a forecast that the country will leave this polarized period only well into the decade, and only if reforms such as gerrymandering changes and rank-choice voting alter what politicians are rewarded for.

Sharpest takeaway

Sosnik argues that American politics is undergoing a once-in-a-lifetime realignment driven by educational attainment and economic transition, wherein voting has shifted from local to national, creating a polarized system where politicians face incentives toward extremism and the presidency is now determined by a handful of swing states rather than broader coalitions.

  • 45 of 50 states voted for same presidential candidate in 2016 and 2020; 95 of 100 senators are same party as their state's presidential candidate
  • Educational attainment (diploma divide) now predicts voting patterns with 85-90% accuracy, replacing race as primary political cleavage
  • Eight swing states representing only 19% of US population now determine presidential elections, making geographic sorting and partisan clustering the dominant political reality

The claims · ranked77 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.75

If you know the education profile of a district, city, or state, you can predict how they're going to vote with about 85 or 90% accuracy, whereas in the past race was a good indicator and other indices, but now it is education.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Doug Sosnik

“if you tell me uh uh the education profile of a district or a city or a state, I can tell you how they're going to vote. Now, it's not 100% right but it's about 85 or 90% right. And whereas in the past uh race was a good indicator uh and other indices, it it it it is education.”

0.75

The split between educated and non-educated voters is not an accident but is partly driven by values, comfort with multicultural and multiracial societies, and diversity—it's both an economic divide and a sociological and cultural divide, which is new.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bill Kristol

“In addition to sort of just pure let's say economic opportunity, so much of it is also values and and and comfort comfort with a multicultural society and with you know multi racial society and so forth and and diversity as they say as as the it's not an accident that turns become so big, right? On the one hand and wokeness and identity politics so so much a term of hostility on the other.”

0.75

People like Joe Manchin who are moderate conservative southern Democrats are 'grandfathered in' as long-time incumbents but once they leave, the laws of political gravity will resettle those districts as Republican.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Doug Sosnik

“So you take a guy like Joe Manchin um in a sense the people who are defying the laws of political gravity are essentially grandfathered. But once they leave gravity will take its course. So you had a much of of white moderate conservative southern Democrats uh who were long time incumbents in the house in the 80s and early 90s who were going to stay there as long as they chose to. But once they left uh it was inevitable that the laws of political gravity are going to resettle and those are all going to become Republican districts.”

0.75

Young voters are more Democratic, but young voters also split on education, so young turnout is not unambiguously good for Democrats—millennials and Gen Z grew up believing institutions are either broken or corrupt, so they identify against the Republican Party rather than for the Democratic Party.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Doug Sosnik

“if you know, it's let me talk broadly and then let me talk more narrowly to young people. So broadly, there was a poll that came out in Gallup recently which shows a increasing conservatism in America on social issues... young people uh it's really a gaining issue... even if and make no mistake about it, young people do not identify with Democrats. They identify our political system our parties as broken just like everything else in our country.”

0.75

Politics is a lagging indicator of what's going on in America. It is sort of the last place that you will see what has actually been happening.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Doug Sosnik

“politics is a lagging indicator of what's going on in America. It is sort of the last place that you will see what has actually been happening.”

0.73

People increasingly self-select where they live and who they associate with based on political preferences, creating echo chambers that reinforce their views rather than exposing them to diverse perspectives.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Doug Sosnik

“There there there are a variety of but but but the bottom line is people are are self-selecting where they live, who they associate with. And increasingly in our evenly narrowly narrowly and evenly and profoundly divided country, people are are largely now self-selecting to be around people just like themselves. So, it does have that reinforcing kind of mechanism, an echo chamber. Uh where I can remember in 2016 uh where I was quite surprised that Trump won. Talk about 2020 where I was less surprised by how well he did. Uh but I only had a handful of people I knew who were voting for Trump. So, all my data points uh reinforced my preconceived notion uh how the election was going to come out”

0.71

The White House should be like a duck—above the water very calm and presidential, but beneath the surface frenetic partisan activity—this should extend until the Republican nominee physically captures enough delegates to be official.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Doug Sosnik

“The analogy I always used and this is what I would use in the Biden White House is a duck. If you think about a duck, above the water very placid and below it very very, you know, paddling frenetic activity. So Biden should be the White House should be a duck, which is above the water very calm, very presidential and uh, and not political. Beneath the surface should be frenetic activity as partisan and political as possible without getting caught.”

0.71

The secret to winning swing states is twofold: building as much turnout as possible among your base voters based on education (Trump did this successfully in 2020 by growing turnout of less educated people in industrial Midwest), and you can't ignore swing voters because these states are so narrowly divided.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Doug Sosnik

“the secret in these um uh states is going to be twofold. One is is to create is to build as much turnout as you can uh amongst your base voters based on education. So, that's one of the se- secrets to Trump's success uh in 2020 uh was his ability to grow the turnout of less educated people in the industrial Midwest states in particular who hadn't voted in 2016.”

0.71

Democrats will never get voters in these areas if they think Democrats are looking down on them, if they think Democrats are looking down on their choices of entertainment or their values.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Doug Sosnik

“And we as Democrats will never get the voters in these areas uh if they think we're looking down on them. If they if they think we're looking down on their choices of entertainment, if they're looking down uh frankly got to figure out Democrats have to figure out the fact”

0.69

Starting in the early 1970s, there was a 'delinking' where GDP growth, worker productivity, employment and wages used to go in tandem, but after the 1970s as productivity went up, wages and employment became flat, creating a long-term hollowing out of the middle class.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Doug Sosnik

“Andy McAfee, who's a MIT uh professor, talked about the delinking in the '70s where for the first time there's an old saying what was good for General Motors was good for America. The more cars General Motors sold General Motors sold, the more people got jobs, the more money they made. Well, the delinking that started in the '70s was as GDP growth went up and as productivity went up wages and employment became flat.”

0.69

75 million people voted for Trump and they're not all idiots or morons—if you treat them that way, there's a pretty good chance you'll never get their vote, though there are a lot of really sketchy people who voted for Trump who are ungettable.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Doug Sosnik

“I mean they're not all idiots. They're not all morons. Um if you want to treat them as idiots and treat them as morons, there's a pretty good chance you'll never get their vote. Now there are a lot of really sketchy people who voted for Trump and they're ungettable and Democrats have no shot and shouldn't shouldn't try to.”

0.69

Eight out of the last nine elections the country voted out either a president or control of the House or control of the Senate, so we're in a period where people are motivated more by voting against someone than voting for someone.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Doug Sosnik

“eight out of the nine eight out of the last nine elections the voted the country voted out either either a president uh or control the House or control the Senate. So, we're currently in a in a period where not the people aren't voting for someone, they're motivated more by voting against someone.”

0.69

Shareholder capitalism, where everything is driven around stock value, and offshoring incentives to cut costs, accelerated in the 1980s and widened the gap between CEO pay and worker pay, with the people hit hardest being those with good jobs who did not have a college degree.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Doug Sosnik

“from the Milton Friedman school and Professor Jensen from Harvard uh where they were promoting a stakeholder uh uh shareholder economy and capitalism where everything was driven around the value of the stock. And then you began in the '80s not only a shareholder capitalism where the workers no longer valued um but offshoring uh where you're incentivized to cut cost and the gap between uh there there were four lines... and starting uh uh McAfee's uh uh Andy McAfee, who's a MIT uh professor, talked about the delinking in the '70s”

0.69

Well-educated suburbs and college towns have more in common with each other regardless of geographic location, and rural areas and areas that have lost jobs have more in common with each other, which creates the red dots in blue states and blue dots in red states phenomenon.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Bill Kristol

“people in you know, in well educated suburbs or in college towns uh have more in common with each other whether they're wherever they are in the country and and and people in uh areas that have lost jobs or rural areas have more in common with each with each other. And that's why they're the red dots in blue states and the blue dots in red states”

0.68

Unlike when Bill and I grew up in politics where the saying was 'all politics is local,' now 'all politics is national'—how you vote for president is the same as how you vote for Congress, for mayor, and for state legislature.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Doug Sosnik

“unlike when Bill and I grew up in politics where there was a saying that was sort of the North Star, which is all politics is local, I think now all politics is national. And how you vote for president is the same as how you vote for Congress, it's the same as how you vote for mayor, it's how you vote for state legislature.”

0.68

The current political system rewards what Sosnik calls 'bad behavior' because elected officials are much more vulnerable to losing a primary than a general election based on the sorting around the country, so their incentives push them toward taking extreme positions to avoid primary challenges.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Doug Sosnik

“one thing that they do understand is self-preservation. And we currently have a political system that rewards what I call bad behavior. So, for the overwhelming majority of elected officials, uh they're much more vulnerable to losing a primary than they are a general election based on the sorting around the country. So, as a result of that, uh the their their incentives as they think about policy decisions and whether they're willing to cross lines, the incentive structure in our country uh is set up right now for for for both the left and the right to for members to take the extreme positions in order to avoid losing a primary.”

0.65

In the 1980s, Republican George H.W. Bush carried upscale suburbs like New Jersey and California, but by 1992 this coalition began to break apart as the education fault line became dominant.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Bill Kristol

“in '88 George H.W. Bush carries, if I'm not mistaken, New Jersey and California among other states. He carries upscale suburbs. That's the Republican world. Um uh and then that really begins to change dramatically in '92”

0.65

The old Democratic theory that 'demography is destiny' suggested the Sun Belt would inevitably become Democratic as young people and non-whites became a larger percentage of voters, but this has not happened as expected due to education levels and Republican success with Hispanic voters.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Doug Sosnik

“there was a popular saying amongst Democrats in the early part of the century, which was um demography is destiny. So, under that theory, uh as as young people, non-whites, uh uh became a bigger and bigger percentage of our politics in America, there was an inevitability that all the Sun Belt was going to move to the Democrats. Uh it hasn't quite played out that way uh because uh as I think education's part of it, uh but you know, you've seen in the last couple cycles that Republicans have done particularly well with Hispanic voters in across the country, but particularly in Florida and Texas”

0.65

The Tea Party movement in 2009-10 and Palin's vice presidential nomination in 2008 represented the takeover of the Republican Party by the anti-Rockefeller establishment wing, driven by years of accumulated resentment against establishment Republicans.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Doug Sosnik

“in Palin's uh you know vice presidential uh nomination in 2008, the um Tea Party movement in 2009 and 10 this could this this is the takeover of the Republican Party by the anti-Rockefeller establishment wing.”

0.64

45 out of 50 states voted for the same presidential candidate in 2016 and 2020, and 95 out of 100 senators are of the same party as the presidential candidate who carried their state in the last election.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Doug Sosnik

“45 out of 50 states voted for the same presidential candidate in 2016 and 2020. 95 out of 100 senators are of the same party as the presidential candidate who carried their state in the last election.”

0.64

69% of Americans believe that abortion should be legal for the first 3 months, the highest percent in the history of polling, and 26 states are controlled by Republicans with races to see who can be toughest on abortion, which will drive young voting.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Doug Sosnik

“Gallup came out with a poll today. The highest percent of people in the history of polling 69% believe that abortion should be legal for the first 3 months. 69% now, the highest on record. So as you see these states, 26 of them I think are controlled by Republicans and there's a race in a lot of these states to see who can be toughest on the issue of abortion.”

0.64

West Virginia, Kansas, and Montana, three bright red Republican states, voted down referendums on abortion that would have limited access in 2022, showing the power of the abortion issue.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Doug Sosnik

“You had three states, three bright red Republican states in 2022, West Virginia, Kansas, and Montana that voted down referendums on abortion that would have limited access.”

0.64

The districts in New York that went Republican in 2020 and especially in 2022 look like central Pennsylvania districts demographically and sociologically, showing that sorting happens within states with a lag.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Bill Kristol

“the the districts in New York that went Republican and surprising people in 2020 but especially in 22 those look like central Pennsylvania districts demographically and sociologically and they were sort of lagging because New York was more liberal in general and so people didn't quite make the move as early as they did in Kentucky or Pennsylvania”

0.61

Don't look at national polling—Biden beat Trump by over 7 million votes and Biden's margins in California and New York were greater than his margin of victory nationally, so the national polls skew what's going on because the extremes weigh in, and the only place that matters is these eight swing states.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Doug Sosnik

“don't look at the national polling. Uh Biden beat Trump by over 7 million votes. Biden's margins in in in California and New York was greater than his margin of victory nationally. So so the national polls skew what's going on because you've got the extremes weighing in, but they have nothing to do or not nothing to do, but they're not determinative of the outcome because it's it's down to these handful of states.”

0.61

There are only three things Sosnik cares about in a campaign: defining what the campaign is about, defining your candidate, and defining the opposition.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Doug Sosnik

“I like to oversimplify there are only three things I care about in a campaign. I care about defining what this campaign's about, I care about defining my candidate and I care about defining the opposition. Those are the only things I care about.”

0.61

We will get out of this realignment and polarization, but it will take well into this decade, and we need to change the reward system so politicians will change, including through gerrymandering reform, rank-choice voting, and other mechanisms that encourage cooperation.

forecasthigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Doug Sosnik

“I think we will get out of this, although I think it's going to take well into this decade. Um but we've got to change the reward system so that the politicians will change. And part of that is how we, you know, gerrymandering and uh you know, rank-choice voting and Right. uh a variety of things that that encourage, and you're seeing it happening at the state level uh now.”

0.61

The realignment represents a 'hinge moment in history' where if you have the right education and background for the new economy, your opportunity has never been greater, but if you don't have the skills and education for the new society, your chances of upward mobility have never been worse—Europe is now more likely to have upward mobility than the United States.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Doug Sosnik

“Professor Dyson from Princeton talks about hinge moments in history where the hinge is transitioning from one era to another. And we I as I say I think are in a hinge moment that's that we haven't seen since the late 1800s. So in this new hinge moment era if you're the right kind of worker with the right kind of education and background, your opportunity is never been greater in the history of our country. And if you're on the other side of this hinge moment where you don't have the skills and don't have the education for this new society, your your chances of of of of upward mobility has never been worse. So in fact we're Europe is more is is you're more likely with upper mobility now in Europe than the United States.”

0.60

There was a 'chemical reaction' in the 2020 Democratic primary where the party quickly coalesced behind Biden as someone other than Bernie Sanders, and this was critical because it's hard to see anyone other than Biden winning in 2020.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Doug Sosnik

“you have in primaries you have what you know, refers to as a chemical reaction. It happens at some point. You can't predict it, but it happens and it's there. And the chemical reaction in 2020 was the fact that it was either going to be Bernie Sanders as the Democratic nominee or someone else. And the party quickly coalesced behind Biden as the someone else. And by the way you know, if you look at all the mistakes that Trump did as president, all the crazy things he said, all the crazy things he did he almost won the election. I know it is. And if you go back and look at who else could have been the nominee other than Biden it's hard for me to see that anyone else other than Biden would have won in 2020.”

0.60

The 1992 presidential election was the first time the new political realignment showed up, beginning with Pat Buchanan's speech at the Republican convention and Ross Perot getting almost 20 million votes and 19% of the vote in the general election.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Doug Sosnik

“I think the 1992 presidential election was the first time this showed up uh in politics and that it began with Pat Buchanan's um speech at the Republican convention... And then in the general election Ross Perot got almost 20 million votes and 19% of the vote.”

0.60

If Biden were to advise the White House, he would recommend keeping a very controlled environment with limited spontaneity (much like Reagan's second term), focusing on Harris, and keeping Biden presidential rather than a candidate by avoiding announcing his reelection campaign.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Doug Sosnik

“for the Biden White House, I would do a lot of what they're doing all the I'd do a bit more of it. So the first thing is, um, much like Reagan, uh, this is a very controlled White House. Uh, there's very little uh, spontaneity. Uh, everything is scripted... I would keep a very controlled environment. I would spend a lot more time right now focusing on the quote unquote Harris problem.”

0.60

Gallup polling shows increasing conservatism on social issues and significant increases in anti-woke views among Americans, despite younger voters supporting more liberal social policies.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Doug Sosnik

“there was a poll that came out in Gallup recently which shows a increasing conservatism in America on social issues. A significant increase in the sort of anti-woke view amongst Americans. However, I think with young people uh it's really a gaining issue”

0.60

Biden and Harris should go to infrastructure project sites, have local people introduce them, talk about accomplishments, then pivot to future—every White House event should follow this formula to connect tangible accomplishments to voter lives.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Doug Sosnik

“And the way that I would build the White House and they do it but I'd do much more of it and I'd have her do a lot of this is every event where they go, they need to go somewhere at the scene of an accomplishment of the administration where they've made people's lives better. An infrastructure package is probably the best. I would go to that scene. I would have someone introduce Biden and Harris. I would have them talk about the fact we wouldn't be here today except for the what these people did and how it's going to impact the local community.”

0.57

Traditional metrics of job approval and right-track/wrong-track don't matter anymore—Biden is in the low 40s in job approval with 70% wrong track, but what will determine the outcome is 'who's less crazy,' which is a new dynamic in electoral politics.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Doug Sosnik

“Well, that doesn't matter anymore. And Biden is in the low 40s right now in his job approval. You got 70% of the country that thinks we're headed in the wrong direction. But that's not what's going to determine the outcome. What's going to determine the outcome is who's less crazy.”

0.56

As recently as the early 2000s, there were two Democratic senators representing North Dakota, two Democratic senators representing South Dakota, and two Democratic senators representing Nebraska, but now only 5 states have one senator from each party, compared to 26 states in this situation in 1985.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Doug Sosnik

“as recently as the early 2000s, you had two Democratic senators representing North Dakota. You had two Democratic senators representing South Dakota. And you had two Democratic senators representing Nebraska.”

0.56

There are 46 congressional districts that the Cook report considers competitive, only three of them are in rural areas, none in urban areas—all 46 are in suburban areas, and the more densely populated a suburb the more likely it's Democratic, the less densely populated and closer to rural the more likely it's Republican.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Doug Sosnik

“there are 46 congressional districts right now that the Cook report considers competitive. Um only three of them are in rural areas. None of them in urban areas. So they're all in suburban areas. Now suburban areas can be, you know, if you think about whatever community you're in as you're as you're watching this Zoom, I mean, it's true across the country the the the more densely populated a suburb is and generally probably closer to a city the more likely they are to be democratic and the less densely populated and probably more closer to rural than area is more likely they are to be Republican.”

0.56

The total collapse of split-ticket voting means that of House districts in 2020, only about 23 (5% of districts) voted for a member of Congress against their presidential candidate, compared to the Reagan era when Democrats controlled the House while Reagan won 49 states.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Bill Kristol

“The non the total collapse of split-ticket voting. I mean, again, if you're our age, you sort of remember that era, right? By definition, if Democrats control the House and Reagan wins 49 states, there's a heck of a lot of split-ticket voting going on... How many there 22 districts or something like that that were that went against the voted for a member of Congress in 2020 against their presidential candidate. 20 23 or whatever the right number is is is 5% of the congressional districts.”

0.56

After Republicans failed to take the Senate back for the second cycle in a row, Mitch McConnell said they had terrible candidates and that Republican defections were one of the main reasons they lost Senate control.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Doug Sosnik

“after the Republicans failed for the second cycle in a row to take the Senate back, um the first thing Mitch McConnell said other The first thing he said was we lost cuz we had terrible candidates, but the second thing he said was uh Republican defections were one of the main reasons Republicans lost, didn't take control of the Senate.”

0.56

You couldn't look at America politically in the 1970s or 1980s and predict voting based on educational achievement the way you can now, and if anything it was slightly the opposite with the educated voting Republican, but it was more mixed overall.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Bill Kristol

“You couldn't look at America politically in the 70s or 80s and sort of do what you've just said which is sort out demographically by educational achievement and really even war if you start going down the post graduate degrees and so forth and say that's democratic, that's republican. If anything was slightly the opposite way, but it was more mixed basically”

0.56

206 counties voted for Obama in 2008 and 2012 but voted for Trump in 2016, disproportionately lower educated and lower income counties, and in 2020 Biden only carried 25 of those counties while Trump carried 84% of the counties in the country.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Doug Sosnik

“There were two 206 counties in the country that voted for Obama in 2008 and Obama in 2012 who voted for Trump in 2016. And those were all disproportionately lower educated uh lower income uh and in 2020 when Biden uh beat Trump, he only carried 25 of those counties. When Biden got elected in 2020, Trump carried 84% of the counties in this country.”

0.56

In 2022 there was meaningful ticket splitting where Republicans in gubernatorial and Senate races voted for Democrats, with double-digit margins in governors' races and between 6-10% in Senate races, and this is significant in close states.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Doug Sosnik

“there was there were in fact s- significant or I would I would I wouldn't say I would call it meaningful ticket splitting in 2022. And those were Republicans in in governors' races and in Senate races voting Democratic. Now, in governors' races, they were double digit uh and in Senate races, they were, depending on the state, between six and eight or 10%.”

0.56

There are eight swing states that matter, and they are: Michigan, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, and New Hampshire (manufacturing belt states), and North Carolina, Georgia, Arizona, and Nevada (Sun Belt states), with six of those eight having education levels dead square in the middle of the country.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Doug Sosnik

“I would say we have eight swing states, and that's that, and they're fought bitterly, and they're single-digit percentage, maybe 10% at most, swing voters in them... You have Michigan, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, and New Hampshire, which uh are much disproportionately higher percentage of people who live there are white, older, uh with the exception of New Hampshire, um are are kind of in the middle of that education level. And then you have North Carolina, uh uh Georgia, Arizona, and Nevada that are trending more Democratic, uh but they're really at at really at best 50/50”

0.56

The highest percentage of people who turned out in 2022 who self-described themselves as political independents was the highest level since 1980, with 40% of people in Arizona who voted in 2022 calling themselves political independents.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Doug Sosnik

“we had the highest percentage of people who turned out in 2022 who self-described themselves as independents, political independents. I think it's the highest level since 1980. 40% of the people in Arizona who voted in 2022 called themselves political independents.”

0.56

Despite all the mistakes Trump made as president, all the crazy things he said and did, he almost won the 2020 election.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Doug Sosnik

“By the way you know, if you look at all the mistakes that Trump did as president, all the crazy things he said, all the crazy things he did he almost won the election.”

0.55

We are going through the biggest change in American society since the late 1800s when transitioning from an agrarian society to an industrial society, and we have now transitioned from a 20th century top-down manufacturing economy to a 21st century digital global world, a 50-year transition that started with the Vietnam War.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Doug Sosnik

“I believe that we're going through the biggest change in our society since the late 1800s when we were transitioning from an agrarian society to an industrial society... I believe that we are transitioning from a 20th century top-down uh manufacturing economy to a 21st century digital global uh world.”

0.52

The Vietnam War was the first war the US ever fought where 'we were not all in this together' and people with money and power could game the system, which planted the seeds for the anger people feel toward those in power today who believe the system is rigged.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Doug Sosnik

“The Vietnam War was the first war we ever fought as a country where we were not all in this together. And people with money and power could game the system. So, I think that was the seeds for the anger that people feel towards people in power in this country. They think that the system is rigged.”

0.52

Half the country thinks the country is not changing fast enough, and the other half thinks we're changing too fast, so everything is colored by whether you feel you have a wind to your back in terms of opportunity or wind to your face.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Doug Sosnik

“the way I way I uh put the fault line is half the country thinks the country's not changing fast enough for the moment. And the other half of the country thinks we're changing too fast. Right. and so everything is colored about whether or not you feel like you have a wind to your back in terms of opportunity or wind to your face.”

0.52

About 40% of the country is 'crazy left,' 40% is 'crazy right,' and 20% are 'civilians' who think both sides are crazy, and these civilians disproportionately live in the suburbs and are the ones voting against whoever is in power.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Doug Sosnik

“I tend to oversimplify and what I'm getting ready to say is not something that a lot of Democrats agree with, but I I kind of think about 40% of the country is crazy left and 40% are crazy right and 20% are what I call civilians who think that both sides are crazy. And they disproportionately live in the suburbs by the way.”

0.52

Since Roosevelt, the country has shown that it doesn't want any party to be in power more than eight years, so the decline in GDP growth is what stopped the 1980-2016 pattern—Bush didn't win a third term and Obama didn't win a third term.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Doug Sosnik

“the country doesn't trust either political party and other than Bush who essentially ran for a Reagan third term in '88, uh, the country's shown that basically since Roosevelt, they don't want any party to be in power more than eight years. Uh, and so I think the decline the GDP the GDP growth decline, the unevenness of it, uh, uh, is is uh, what, you know, stopped it, you know, I said that, you know, McCain was only person to lose to Bush twice. He lost in 2000 and then there's no way the country was going to vote for a third Bush term in in 2008 and I don't think the country was ready to vote for a third Obama term in 2016.”

0.52

The most successful candidates in the current environment are 'beige' candidates—those without a strong record, not divisive, who make it a referendum on the other person.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Doug Sosnik

“the most successful candidates right now in this environment is to run someone who's beige uh, for any office. Not have a strong record, not be divisive, and make it a referendum on the other person.”

0.52

70% of the country worries about climate change and 70% believes we need more gun control, but these things haven't changed because the people aren't voting on those issues—they will change when younger generations take over political power.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Doug Sosnik

“people keep saying, "Well, if 70% of the country worries about climate change and 70% of the country believes we got to have more gun control. And why haven't these things changed?" The answer is because the people aren't voting on that. But, as you see the dying off generationally of the people who've been hanging on to the old system and this this emerging generation takes over political power in our country. They are now the majority by numbers of voting.”

0.52

The Democratic Party is increasingly becoming a party of educated people and minorities, which creates a 'Harris problem' if the party is seen as dominated by educated elites looking down on working-class voters in 'flyover country'.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Doug Sosnik

“Democratic Party is becoming a party of the educated uh and and blacks. Uh to some extent minorities, but that's changing with more Hispanics and Asians I think voting based on on educational levels for Republicans. But you know, one of the problems that uh Democrats have in getting voters in the country and it's just like the language the Democrats use like flyover parts of the country which is a pejorative term. And and we as Democrats will never get the voters in these areas uh if they think we're looking down on them”

0.52

The concept of 'appropriateness' (from John Sears, Reagan's strategist) suggests successful nominees are those the country judges appropriate for the times, like Reagan in 1980 when he was appropriate for the post-Vietnam, pro-growth era.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Bill Kristol

“my instinct my gut the country doesn't want a Biden-Trump rematch. And so, instinctively or whatever the right word is for that kind of temperamentally almost John Sears, who you knew, Reagan's top strategist used to have this nice term about appropriateness that somehow the country the nominee is often someone who the country judges is kind of appropriate for the times”

0.51

Biden only getting 60% of the Democratic vote in the primary with 40% going to Kennedy, Williamson, or nobody is not great and suggests potential weakness, though not having a primary challenge creates a benchmark problem.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Doug Sosnik

“Biden in the last CNN poll, Biden's only getting 60% of the Democratic vote in the primary. 40% of the vote is either going to Kennedy, Williamson or or nobody. So that's that's not great. So you got to figure out how in the Biden White House you're going to manage uh, the not having a primary but also not creating these benchmarks which demonstrate weakness.”

0.51

Demographic change as baby boomers die off and millennials and Gen Z take over will fundamentally change politics, with younger generations being much more communitarian like the Greatest Generation and not invested in either political party.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Doug Sosnik

“the demographic changes in our country when the basically the baby boomers die off and are still clinging to the last remnants of power and the millennials and Generation Z voters take over. And I'm actually quite optimistic about what our country's going to look like at that point. I think that that they're much more like the greatest generation. They're much more communitarian. They're not invested in either of these political parties.”

0.50

From 1960 to 1980, there were no successful two-term presidencies—only Nixon was reelected, and there were assassinations, riots, and a failed war in Vietnam, which led people to believe the system was broken and needs fundamental change, similar to today.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Bill Kristol

“from 60 to 80 when I was, you know, from when I was 70 years old I guess till till when I came, you know, got my PhD and all of this began teaching. American politics featured no successful two-term presidencies, uh, no full two-term presidencies. Uh, Nixon was the only one who even got reelected. It featured assassinations. It featured riots. It featured a failed war in Vietnam”

0.50

From 1980 to 2016, America had a 12-year Reagan-Bush presidency and three 8-year presidencies, suddenly won the Cold War, and the system seemed to stabilize, suggesting that political chaos can resolve suddenly and unpredictably.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Bill Kristol

“from '80 to 2016, again, whatever one thinks and there were some many problems in that era. We had basically a 12-year Reagan-Bush presidency and then three eight-year presidencies. Suddenly everyone's getting reelected. Uh, suddenly, uh, we win the Cold War. Suddenly we're, you know, it doesn't feel like there were assassination attempts earlier.”

0.50

Trump increased Republican margin among white working class voters from 18 points (Obama 53-47 Republican in 2012) to 36 points in 2016, doubling the margin, and there may be more growth potential there than Democrats should be comfortable with.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Bill Kristol

“They won by I think 18 points among white working class voters, and that's like a huge margin. Trump doubled that to 36.”

0.50

The eight swing states represent only 19% of the US population, so 81% of the United States will have no impact on who becomes the next president.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Doug Sosnik

“these eight these eight states represent only 19% of the US population. So, 81% of the United States 81% of the population of the United States how they vote whether they vote will have no impact on who's going to be the next president of the United States.”

0.50

30-40% of Republicans identify as 'never-Trumpers' who could vote Democratic or stay home in a general election if Trump is the Republican nominee.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Doug Sosnik

“if you have 25% of Republicans or 30% of Republicans uh who are are never-Trumpers, um they can be very significant in the outcome of these states that have been close”

0.50

The architecture of American politics—the divisions and sorting—is so strong that it overrides everything, including having two nominees that 70% of the country says they don't want.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Doug Sosnik

“so, then how do you explain why we are where we are? Uh and the answer is because of the architecture of American politics, the divisions in our country and and how we have sorted ourselves out. That is what's driving at least today the probable probable horse race or choices next November of of 70% of the country is saying in polling they don't want a Biden-Trump rematch... The answer is because of the architecture of our politics is so strong that it that it that it overrides everything including having two nominees that no one wants.”

0.48

The country is fed up with the current political situation because many people don't align with either party, and when people get fed up and stop rewarding bad behavior, the system will change—the country currently has the leadership it deserves.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Doug Sosnik

“because they're not aligned with either party. So, that's going to happen. The third thing is I'm alluding to it... And it's less and until the people in this country do something about it and stop rewarding this behavior um we're going to have more of this. Now, I believe though that that the country will get fed up. Because they're not aligned with either party. So, that's going to happen. And the last thing I think most importantly uh is going to be uh the demographic changes in our country”

0.48

Donald Trump did not create the trends of anger at elites and the realignment, but he accelerated them through his 2016 campaign and presidency.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Doug Sosnik

“Donald Trump did not create what's going on in our country. He just accelerated through his 2016 campaign and his presidency these trends that have been forming long before he entered the fray”

0.48

During the Bush presidency in the 2000s, particularly among people who had been economically hardest hit, there was strong opposition to the war and resentment about squandered surpluses, tax cuts for the rich and corporations while Republicans in Congress and the White House were bigger spenders than Democrats ever were, creating enormous additional resentment within the Republican Party towards the powers that be.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Doug Sosnik

“put the Bush presidency which I think there was from these people who've been the hardest hit economically I think they were you know very much against the war and and they're the ones who fought the war and they're the ones who um you know we saw the squandered surpluses that were wasted. Tax cuts for the rich, tax cuts for corporations. The Republicans in the early part of this century controlling Congress and the and the White House were much bigger spenders than Democrats ever were and this created enormous additional resentment within the Republican Party towards the powers that be.”

0.47

Education is bigger than just education because education is a proxy for something much larger—it's a proxy for your view of the world and how you culturally view things, and if you're educated and built for today's economy, companies are now moving to places where they have employees that they want to hire rather than people moving to where jobs were.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Doug Sosnik

“education is a proxy I think for something that's much larger. Uh but if you look at any of the statistics of the gap between CEO pay and workers on the line pay and people who are at the top and how much they're making... And so, basically if you tell me uh uh the education profile of a district or a city or a state... Let me just mention one thing to show you how it's changed. Up until around 20 years ago all the way through the history of our country people moved to where jobs were. But in the last couple of decades, companies are now moving to places where they have employees that they want to hire.”

0.45

The country doesn't want a Biden-Trump rematch, and while analytically it's hard to see how either won't be the nominee, temperamentally/intuitively it seems wrong, suggesting that 'appropriateness' (a concept from John Sears) should determine nominees—but neither Biden nor Trump seem appropriate for 2024.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 1/4· Bill Kristol

“my instinct my gut the country doesn't want a Biden-Trump rematch. And so, instinctively or whatever the right word is for that kind of temperamentally almost John Sears, who you knew, Reagan's top strategist used to have this nice term about appropriateness that somehow the country the nominee is often someone who the country judges is kind of appropriate for the times... I don't feel either Biden or Trump are exactly appropriate for 2020 24, but I also analytically it's hard to see uh you know, that either won't be the nominee.”

0.43

There's never been a time in Sosnik's political life where he's seen two front runners further in front and more certain to be nominees, but he's also never seen more uncertainty about both of them and their ability to get from mid-June to the ballot box in November.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 1/4· Doug Sosnik

“there's never been a time in my political life where I've ever seen on paper two front runners that are further in front and seem to be more certain to be the nominee than we have now. And I've also never seen in that period of time more uncertainty about both of them and their ability to get from in mid-June of of 13 to the ballot box in November of 14. I've never felt more uncertain about 24 24. They're I've never felt more uncertain about their viability to get from here to there.”

0.43

If 'craziness' or 'voting against crazy' defines what 2024 is about, Democrats win regardless of who they nominate, but if Trump's economic message defines the campaign, it will be difficult for Democrats.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 1/4· Doug Sosnik

“if what defined the 2022 campaign was we're voting against crazy if that's if that's going to be the driver on defining what this campaign's about in 2024 the Democrats are going to win. I don't care man. It don't think it matters who they nominate. But it's obviously far from clear whether or not, you know, if it's Trump, if his ad from three weeks ago, that defines the campaign, that's going to be a difficult campaign for Democrats.”

0.42

Sosnik believes a one-term Biden presidency acknowledging his accomplishments and stepping aside for a new generation would have been strategically strong but carries the risk of Trump winning.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Doug Sosnik

“I mean, if any of you're sports fans and you have a team that's not winning a lot, uh, there's always the question as you sit there do we make extreme measures of change for the long term or do we take the short term and try to figure out how to get through it? What is the path? The If you look in sports, the the the the teams that are least successful are the ones that try to do both. So, as Yogi Berra would say, when you get to a fork in the road, take it. So, I actually think you're right and the Biden Whitehouse is right. What do I mean by that? I think in the short term staying the course is a better path. I think in the long term the party's probably better off taking their medicine now. Um, you know, but not if Trump not if it makes Trump president”

0.42

If you're a sports team not winning much, you face a choice between taking extreme measures for long-term change or taking the short term to get through it—teams that try to do both are least successful, so Biden staying the course is better short-term while Democrats might be better off long-term taking their medicine.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Doug Sosnik

“Well, I mean, if any of you're sports fans and you have a team that's not winning a lot, uh, there's always the question as you sit there do we make extreme measures of change for the long term or do we take the short term and try to figure out how to get through it? What is the path? The If you look in sports, the the the the teams that are least successful are the ones that try to do both. So, as Yogi Berra would say, when you get to a fork in the road, take it.”

0.40

Sosnik wrote an op-ed last year saying he didn't believe Biden, Harris, Trump, or Pence would be on the 2024 ticket, but his family persuaded him not to run it, and he now has less confidence in that outcome but still thinks it might be right.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 1/4· Doug Sosnik

“last year I wrote an op-ed that the Times was willing to wanted to run. And that op-ed said that I didn't believe in the general election in 2024 I didn't believe Biden would be on the ticket. I didn't believe Harris would be on the ticket. I didn't believe Trump would be on the ticket. I didn't believe Pence would be on the ticket. Well, ultimately my family persuaded me not to run that op-ed. And and I I still actually think that op-ed might be right.”

0.40

We're likely closer to the end now than the beginning of this phase of polarization, but it will probably last into this decade (30 years total from 1993), and a lot of damage can be done in between periods unless guardrails hold.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Doug Sosnik

“I am optimistic we're going to come out on the other side. But, I still think we're going to be in this period uh, for several more cycles... Well, if you take the sweep of history 30 years is really not a long time. Um so, we are in the middle I think we're closer to the end now than the beginning of this phase. And I am optimistic we're going to come out on the other side. But, I still think we're going to be in this period uh, for several more cycles.”

0.39

Harris helped get Biden elected in 2020 by holding her own in debate, creating energy, achieving better turnout among targeted voters, and being good on the stump, so Sosnik would have her full-time on the road in friendly audiences to build her up and give her more confidence.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Doug Sosnik

“I believe when you look at how narrowly Biden won in 2020, you could point to anything and say that made the difference. I believe Harris helped get Biden elected. I think she made a difference. I think her she held her own on the debate. She created energy out there. She got a better turnout among some of the targeted voters. She was good on the stump. And so I would have Harris full-time on the road.”

0.39

Joe Biden looks less like an educated elite Democrat and appears more as a traditional Democratic politician, which was very fortunate in his winning the nomination in 2020, as it was not obvious that would happen.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Bill Kristol

“Yeah, and Joe Biden looks less like that kind of Democrat and it was very fortunate I in my point of view that he won the nomination in 2020 and it wasn't obvious that was going to happen, right?”

0.39

The 2022 election was the most positive election since the beginning of the century because in the swing states that matter, voters voted against crazy—not a single election denier won a statewide election in the eight swing states.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Doug Sosnik

“the 2022 election and I'm speaking now as a Democrat obviously, I I thought it was and I didn't think it was going to be a very important election and I said the day after we're going to move on and no one's going to ever know what it happened. I think I was wrong about that. I I thought that was the most positive election we've had probably since the beginning of the century... Not a single election denier won a statewide election in the eight states that matter.”

0.36

Trump put out a video two or three weeks ago that was a referendum on his presidency versus Biden's using economic numbers and other data, and it was a pretty compelling narrative that Trump could present about the choice.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Doug Sosnik

“Trump put out a video about two or three weeks ago which was really a referendum on his presidency versus Biden's and he was using all kinds of economic numbers and other things. Uh, it was a pretty compelling you could see the contours of a pretty pretty damn compelling uh, narrative that Trump could put out on the choice for the American public.”

0.20

It's important for younger people to understand they are living through an incredibly historic period of time, and when they look back on it from our age, they will probably appreciate even more how historic this moment is.

normativespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Doug Sosnik

“I think particularly if you're younger I I think that you're living through an incredibly historic period of time that, uh, when you when you're our age and look back at it, you're going to probably even appreciate more then than you do now uh, how historic this moment in history is.”

0.19

Most people would say for the 2024 election that eight swing states is too generous, and most people would say it's down to three or four states.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Doug Sosnik

“absent of Nevada, which is lower on the education, and New Hampshire, which is higher on education, and by the way, most people will tell you for the 2024 election that I'm that that eight states is a too generous analysis, and most people would say it's down I think it's down to three or four states.”