
The Reality of Plunging Office Building Values
What this covers
This is a six-minute Bloomberg Radio interview in which Scott Kelley of Aetos Capital Real Estate answers questions from Alix Steel, Paul Sweeney and Abigail Doolittle. The conversation starts with office-to-residential conversion and moves quickly to the larger question of who gains and who loses as commercial real estate (CRE)) reprices. Scott speaks from experience: he describes finishing a conversion in Washington DC through his earlier firm, PTM, and uses it to show the idea is feasible but complicated.
On conversion, he takes a contested, skeptical line. He calls it much smaller than consensus suggests, and he says it would need tax incentives, government financing and generous private-sector arrangements. The floor plate is one physical obstacle: modern buildings have oversized floors that don't divide into efficient apartment layouts, while older, narrower buildings adapt more easily. He acknowledges that Manhattan has a real pull toward conversion, since it has excess office space and too little, too expensive housing.
The rest of the interview covers the banks and the buying opportunity. Scott says JP Morgan, Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley learned from the housing crisis and carry little CRE exposure. Regional banks piled into real estate during COVID, when business loan demand dried up, and they funded deals with short-maturity floating-rate debt, which sets up a refinancing wave. Outside New York, he says, values have fallen to less than half, and some buildings barely cover their property taxes. He expects the stress to unfold over several years, not as a sudden crisis. In that period, bottom fishing pays off only for investors who pick quality assets, take control, and sit high in the capital structure, while inexperienced syndicators are wiped out. The hosts also note that Scott had warned of a regional banking problem in August.
Commercial real estate distress presents a multi-year opportunity for sophisticated investors, particularly through regional bank exposure and selective acquisitions of undervalued properties, but widespread banking losses are inevitable for less sophisticated market participants.
- Office-to-residential conversion is overblown; real opportunity lies in selective bottom-fishing of undervalued properties at steep discounts (less than 50 cents on dollar outside NYC)
- Regional and smaller banks face existential pressure from floating-rate CRE loans with short maturities that refinance into higher rates, creating systemic banking stress
- Sophisticated investors can capture value by obtaining operational control and restructuring troubled assets, while unsophisticated syndicators face wipeout
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Oversized floor plates in modern office buildings prevent efficient conversion to apartment layouts, whereas older office buildings with smaller floor plates are more adaptable.
“the floor plates on Office Buildings tend to be too big to be laid out really well for apartment interestingly the older Office Buildings which have smaller floor plates um are easier to adapt”
Successful CRE restructuring typically requires positioning investment in the senior or upper portion of the capital structure to ensure control over refinancing and debt negotiations.
“the structure needs to be I think typically up in the capital structure so either buying the real estate um if the senior lender um you know wants to go through the foreclosure and just sell the real estate or coming into a structured alternative”
Quality of real estate matters more than price alone; buying cheap property is not a sufficient criterion for investment—the property must have fundamental viability.
“we think that it's important to buy good real estate at the end of the day um you know cheap doesn't get cheap enough if you don't buy the right thing”
Investment strategy in distressed CRE requires flexibility on whether to acquire the real estate itself or the mortgage debt, depending on the specific deal structure and refinancing dynamics.
“do you prefer to buy the actual real estate itself or the mortgage behind it it it it is really um deal by I think you have to be flexible uh because you've got to deal usually with the senior lender with a refinancing um uh package”
Control over real estate operations is essential because many unsophisticated syndicators entered CRE during the boom without proper expertise and are now in severe distress, making operational expertise a competitive advantage.
“but I think importantly our perspective is that we have to be able to get control of the operations of the real estate because again particularly through this syndicator model A lot of people that really didn't know what they were doing that would never would have passed the mustard for institutional real estate Capital got into the business and they're the ones that are in the deepest trouble”
Valuations are highly regional and market-dependent, with no single national valuation metric applicable across different markets.
“The again it goes Market by market but um you know particularly for obsolute Office Buildings”
Office-to-residential conversion is widely overestimated in its potential as a solution to CRE distress and represents a much smaller opportunity than industry consensus suggests.
“and uh I think it's really um kind of overblown in terms of how big an opportunity that is”
Office-to-residential conversion is extremely difficult and has significant structural barriers that make it a more limited opportunity than commonly discussed.
“that is a very tall order it's hard to do right like you just don't like flip a switch and say byy right and and uh because light and elevators are the two big light access and elevators are the big issues”
Office-to-residential conversion will require substantial public-private cooperation including tax incentives, governmental financing support, and generous private sector arrangements to achieve viability.
“in terms of converting is it's going to take a lot of public private cooperation to make that happen um the economics in terms of uh tax tax breaks um uh help in financing uh you know governments are going to have to find a way to get these buildings viable um and it's going to mean working with the private sector in a way that might appear to some to be too generous to the private sector”
While CRE distress will not create a sudden systemic crisis, it will be disastrous for many individual market participants who will be wiped out, whether this occurs suddenly or gradually.
“well it will be disastrous for the people to get wiped out you know I mean whether that happens overnight or over a period of a couple of years uh a lot of these people are going to get wiped out”
CRE distress represents different outcomes for different market participants: disaster for weak operators, opportunity for sophisticated investors capable of taking control.
“and um you know I think uh I think it's it disaster for some as an opportunity for others”
Major banks (JP Morgan, Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley) have learned from prior housing crisis and are not significantly exposed to commercial real estate, limiting systemic banking risk.
“the big Banks aren't that exposed to commercial real estate if you look at at JP Morgan Goldman tax Morgan Stanley we've done the analysis on those U Banks and they're I think they've learned their lessons and they're not that exposed to uh to commercial real estate”
Middle-sized banks have moderate CRE exposure, creating differentiated risk levels across the banking sector rather than uniform exposure.
“the M middle-sized Banks a little bit more so it's the smaller banks that have an inordinate concentration of commercial real estate loans”
Regional banks accumulated heavy CRE concentrations during COVID because commercial loan demand from businesses collapsed, forcing banks to deploy capital into real estate instead.
“I think part of the reason was that there was very little commercial loan demand during covid people weren't starting new businesses they weren't you know opening new restaurants and stores and the sort of bread and butter business buiness of a smaller Bank didn't really exist so they poured a lot of money uh into real estate”
Regional banks financed CRE acquisitions with floating-rate debt despite interest rate caps, and with very short maturities, creating a major refinancing wave.
“and they did so with floating rate debt although everybody's against their cap on the floating rate debt pretty much uh with very short maturities so that's the big refinancing wave that's hitting these um smaller uh and Regional Banks”
A wide variety of lenders including regional banks hold a significant concentration of real estate loans, presenting a major opportunity for distressed investment.
“today I think you find a wide variety of lenders including a lot of regional Banks um which are uh which which hold a lot a lot of these real estate loans so we think it's going to be a big opportunity”
There is a real opportunity for 'bottom fishing'—acquiring distressed properties at severe discounts—now and over the next several years as the CRE cycle unfolds.
“but I think there's a real opportunity for bottom fishing o now and over the next several years”
The speaker has successfully completed an office-to-residential conversion project in Washington DC through a prior firm (PTM), demonstrating feasibility but also demonstrating the complexity.
“but uh we did one um through PTM in in Washington DC see um it's not easy to do”
Better-quality real estate properties will continue to perform adequately despite market distress, creating a bifurcated market where quality is preserved.
“so um uh you know the better properties are going to continue to perform okay”
In Manhattan, excess office supply combined with insufficient residential supply and high residential costs creates pressure to convert office to residential use.
“particularly for obsolute Office Buildings or or you know going to be minus Office Buildings the big talk in the industry is to convert if you look at Manhattan as example too much office space too little uh residential you know it's too expensive to live here and there's too much office space”
Both office and apartment real estate represent significant opportunities in the current distressed market, not just office buildings alone.
“it's not just going to be an office um apartments are going to be a big opportunity as well”
Outside of New York City, office and property valuations have generally fallen to less than half of prior valuations, with some buildings trading at prices barely sufficient to cover property taxes.
“well I think L previous less than half and you know you you you're going to see things that go for buildings that in their current use can barely pay their property taxes so um you know you're going to see it it it values at a at a low but but again is it good value even if it appears cheap”
The CRE distress will unfold gradually over years rather than as a sudden crisis, with sophisticated investors capturing value from bottom-fishing during this extended period.
“because of people like you though that can do that homework and then step in will there not be a gigantic commercial real estate crisis it's just going to be like years of susing out this stuff and finding the right price yes I I think there will be years of but nothing disastrous”
In August, Scott predicted a potential regional banking crisis worse than anticipated, and subsequent market developments (including heavy CRE exposure at regional banks) have validated this concern.
“when you joined us in August you alluded to the idea that the regional banking that there be could be some kind of a banking crisis worse than what people were anticipating and lo and behold the second most popular uh article on the blueberg terminal today dozens of banks rapidly piled up commercial property loans”
Manhattan office buildings have traded at valuations as low as 25 cents on the dollar, indicating severe distress in flagship markets.
“last year both from the gain side and the pain side uh I think that we talked about Office Buildings here in New York going as cheap as 25 cents on the dollar”
The speaker personally only acquires real estate when mortgage rates are 3% or lower, making current market conditions unattractive for property acquisition despite distressed valuations.
“we're talking about cloes but Al there's a few properties off I only buy property when uh my mortgage rate is 3% or lower so I'm not your target audience”