
What this covers
This is a single-host episode (number 94 of the Milkshakes Markets Madness series, from September 2024) that opens with some political commentary and then settles into a defense of the milkshake theory against critics who say rising gold disproves it. The host opens with the Fed's 50 basis point) cut while the Dow, S&P 500 and NASDAQ sat at or near record highs, which he calls a hard contradiction to explain, and with Jill Biden chairing a cabinet meeting, which he reads as a sign the country has no operating president.
The central argument is a recounting of what the theory originally said. The host dates its first public airing to early summer 2018, when gold was about $1,330 and the DXY) about 89. He says he always framed dollar and gold strength as measured against other currencies, never against each other. He gives figures: gold up roughly 94% and the dollar index up 133% since then. He also points to his original targets of 150 for the DXY and $5,000 for gold, which he says put gold further along its path than the dollar. He grants that the two trade inversely over short windows, but argues that over five or six years they have risen together. He links that pairing to stress abroad, such as the forced QE of 2022, and to Asian demand for gold as an exit from weaker local currencies. He also offers a lagged one-year relationship, with the dollar bottoming in 2014 and gold in late 2015.
The second half turns to positioning, and this is where the title's warning comes from. He cites an RSI near 70, stochastics at 93, sentiment at 84, and a commercial short position near its 2020 record, which he describes as roughly 330,000 contracts. The CFTC data is four days stale, so he thinks the real shorts are larger. He notes that such setups have historically favored commercials over speculators. Shorts are also guaranteed buyers if they cover. He says he plans to buy hedges if gold rises further in the short term, while keeping the long-term thesis intact. Some claims, such as the all-fiat-is-the-same framing and the 100% correlation between a rising dollar and global crises, are flagged as contested.
The dollar milkshake theory predicts dollars and gold will rise together against other fiat currencies during a global sovereign debt crisis, not that the dollar will strengthen against gold; current gold strength at all-time highs confirms rather than refutes this thesis.
- Gold rising validates the milkshake theory because it shows flight-to-safety into hard assets alongside dollar strength against other currencies
- The dollar has risen 133% since 2018 while gold rose 94%, both rising simultaneously against their fiat competitors, not inversely
- Current gold overbought signals (commercial shorts near all-time high, sentiment 84, stochastics 93) suggest near-term pullback but long-term thesis remains intact
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Gold ownership alone does not solve the practical problems of global businesses and manufacturers; a tire manufacturer in the Philippines or car manufacturer in Korea cannot simply hold reserves in gold because they need to operate in the real world with access to multiple currencies.
“if you're a tire manufacturer in the Philippines you can't hold all your reserves in Gold if you are a car manufacturer in Korea gold doesn't necessarily help you you still have to operate in the real world now if you are an individual investor and you have a lot of money and you can just buy a bunch of gold and just sit on it and you have a secondary source of liquidity to meet any bills and if gold has A1 or $200 pullback that doesn't affect you then sure perhaps you can do that”
The Federal Reserve cut interest rates by 50 basis points while stock indices (Dow, S&P 500, NASDAQ) were at or near all-time highs, and the Fed's explanation that 'everything's great but we're cutting 50 basis points' represented a difficult contradiction to explain.
“the Fed cutting rates at basically all-time highs right you've got uh gold that it's all-time high you've got the Dow it's all-time high you've got the S&P that's alltime high you've got the NASDAQ couple percent away from its all-time high and then not only did they cut rates they were it was pretty clear they were going to cut rates but not only did they cut rates they cut 50 basis points”
All fiat currencies are fundamentally the same in their structural properties, and the global implications of one fiat depreciating versus others matters significantly, even though all fiat ultimately deteriorates.
“the reality is is all Fiat is the same and you're gonna listen you've heard me say this a million times but I'm gonna say it again because it's it's really important understand in a situation where dollars and gold are both Rising versus all other Fiat currencies regardless of what it's doing against corn or wheat or soybeans or you know goods and Serv dollars and gold Rising together causes havoc in global Capital markets”
Gold and the dollar rising together on a long-term basis creates havoc in global capital markets, observable in every 25-40 year historical chart where global slowdowns, crises, or volatility show 100% correlation with rising dollars, establishing a consistent pattern.
“as the dollar Rises versus other currencies it causes havoc in the global Capital markets all you have to do is go back and look at a 25 30-year 40 40-year chart every time we've had had any kind of global slowdown or crisis or volatility it is a 100% correlation with a rising dollar that's just the way it is”
Asian countries in particular have shown much higher demand for gold than the United States in recent years, driven by their desire to exit their own fiat currencies which are in even worse condition than the dollar, pushing the gold price up dramatically.
“huge demand out of Asia much more so than in the US and as they are trying to get out of their Fiat currencies which are even worse than the dollar and they're buying gold that has pushed the gold price up dramatically”
In the first public discussion of the milkshake theory in 2018, the speaker explicitly stated that dollar and gold rising together would happen in relation to other currencies, never claiming the dollar was guaranteed to maintain its purchasing power, only that the strong dollar index would be measured against foreign currencies.
“I very specifically said in that very first interview I know this sounds a little confusing but it's not and the reason it's not is because when I'm talking about gold and dollars Rising together it is in relation to other currencies I never said that the dollar was guaranteed to have its purchasing power rise the strong dollar is in relation to all of its competitors which is all the other foreign currencies”
In 2014, when the rest of the world stopped buying US Treasuries and theoretically shifted to gold, the dollar bottomed (DXY around its low point), which is noteworthy because Treasury demand reduction coincided with dollar strength rather than weakness.
“a lot of times people will say you know in 2014 the rest of the world stopped buying us treasuries well that also coincided with the dollar so the black line is the dollar here uh the per the pink line is gold um the the blue circle is basically the bottom of the dollar in 2014 so it just so happens that when when it's always mentioned that the rest of the world stopped buying treasuries and started putting their savings into gold the dollar Rose pretty interesting right”
A 10-30% move in a currency is enormous, not trivial, as currencies are not meant to move 200-400%, and the dollar's rise of 13% (from initial 89 to current levels) despite decades of money printing, helicopter money, bailouts, and stimulus represents remarkable currency strength.
“the dollars only up 133% that's nothing okay at one point it was up 25% now it's up 133% but at 20 anywhere from a 10 20 30% move in a currency that is a huge move currencies are not supposed to move two or three 400% so so the fact that the dollar despite everything all the money that's been printed all the helicopter money all the bailouts all the stimulus despite all that happened the dollar has still risen versus its beers double digits at the same time over that same Peri period that that gold brose”
While dollar and gold have shown an inverse correlation over short-term periods (which makes mechanical sense as they cannot both rise against each other), when zooming out to the five-six year timeframe, both have risen together, contradicting claims that they always trade inversely.
“you can see on this chart there's actually you can see the inverse correlation between the dollar and gold and that's what people focus on they'll say no they trades opposite and yes it does over very short periods of times it typically trades opposite which makes sense they both can't rise together against each other but if you stretch out and you zoom out everybody always tells me to zoom out whenever I'm doing my analysis you know zoom out and you'll see the big picture well if you zoom out over the last five six years the dollar has risen at the same time that gold has risen”
The milkshake theory predicts that gold rising to all-time highs actually confirms the thesis rather than refutes it, because the theory is fundamentally about how markets react in a global sovereign debt crisis where both dollars and gold become flight-to-safety assets.
“everyone is saying see the milkshake is wrong but what what and they're saying that gold is now going to replace the US Treasury uh as the global Reserve asset and and here's the thing is that could happen in fact that's potentially uh a result of an overall Global sovereign debt crisis and and and if you understand what the milkshake theory is the milkshake theory is how does the world markets react in a global sovereign debt crisis”
Dollars and gold rising together causes havoc in global capital markets because a strong dollar (measured against other fiat currencies) creates distress for the rest of the world, forcing them into extraordinary monetary policy measures like QE, which was observed clearly in 2022.
“what happens then is you get into a thing where there's a flight to safety but both dollars and gold are targets for the flight to safety and that is how you get dollars and gold Rising together...when people will show me the gold price to to indicate that my thesis is wrong they don't understand that gold doing well and gold being the ultimate winner has always been part of the milkshake this is not something new it's always been there”
Gold is currently showing overbought signals: RSI at 70 (not extreme but high), stochastics at 93 (very extreme), sentiment index at 84 (approaching extreme above 90), and commercial short positions near all-time highs matching 2020 levels.
“the middle chart is the relative strength now it's at 70 which is not totally extreme but it's getting pretty high again the stochastics are at 93 you can't get any higher than 100 so it's pretty high so basically what this is saying is gold is basically overbought at these levels now this is the sentiment Index this shows gold at 84 so it's not totally extreme it kind of has to get above 90 to be totally extreme but again we're getting pretty close um and then this is the Whopper this is the commercial position short position versus gold and you can see kind of the typically the inverse relationship not always but typically but typically when the shorts get the pink is the commercial shorts uh the black is gold and you can see that right now the commercial shorts have their second biggest short position ever almost back to the all-time high um of back in the early 2020”
Since the speaker first mentioned the milkshake theory in early 2018 (when gold was $1,330 and DXY was 89), gold has appreciated 94% while the dollar index has appreciated 133%, showing both assets have risen together over the long term.
“since I very first time I ever mentioned it gold has gone up 194% or not it's almost doubled not 100 it's gone up 94% and the dollar has gone up 133%”
Gold's commercial short position includes approximately 330,000 contracts representing roughly $3 billion in margin posted, with total contract value around $80 billion, creating leverage-dependent guaranteed buying pressure if shorts begin covering.
“all of those shorts there's 330,000 contracts that are short that equates to about $3 billion dollar worth of of margin that has been posted and and if you if if you tally up the value of all those contracts it's about 80 billion so it's a huge huge short position and this is again this is bought on Leverage”
The current report trading CFTC data is four days late, meaning current gold short positions are likely even larger than shown in the reported data given the recent multi-day rally.
“the these reports are four days um four days late and so this doesn't include the big move up in gold on over the last three or four days so real time we're probably back to the biggest all-time short position uh that we've ever had”
Markets move in cycles and do not go in straight lines; there will be periods when gold outperforms the dollar and periods when the dollar outperforms gold, but over time the speaker expects continued simultaneous appreciation of both assets relative to other currencies.
“things don't go in a straight line the only place that things go in a straight line is in fairy tale land markets move they go up they pull back they go up they pull back I expect that to continue I expect that there be times when gold is outperforming the dollar I expect there'll be a few times when the dollar outperforms gold but I think over time you're going to continue to see dollar and gold Rise”
Historically, situations where commercials hold large short positions against elevated speculator long positions typically resolve in favor of the commercials, resulting in losses for speculators who put on new positions near recent highs.
“I can tell you if gold goes any higher in the very short term I will be buying some Hedges can't tell you what to do personally if you can hold on you know I think everybody should absolutely old gold again I'm not telling you this because I want you to run out and sell all your gold I'm telling you this because the situation the environment that we're in right now typically has not worked out well over the short term for those who have put on new position...historically this has not worked out well for the Speculator”
Gold's bottom occurred in late 2015, about a year after the dollar's 2014 low, and since then dollars and gold have moved together upward, with a lagged correlation of approximately one year between gold and the dollar.
“and then if the gold had its bottom about a year later late 2015 right but since then again gold and dollars have risen together now if you look at this what I did is I I I I ex I moved the Gold's bottom of 2015 back to equate to the low of the dollar and my point is is that gold kind of f has if you look at this the correlation is not perfect but it's kind of there you can kind of see gold and the dollar moving together and higher now it's not again it's not perfect but my point is is that gold kind of reacts to the dollar and if if if you if you lag at about a year there is a correlation here”
Extreme short positions in gold represent guaranteed buyers, but the question is whether these shorts will cover at current highs or at much lower prices, and historically such elevated leveraged short positions typically resolve with speculators losing rather than gaining.
“this chart represents guaranteed buyers it's just a matter of whether these shorts are going to cover at the highs or if they're going to cover at a much lower price now if they cover at the if they have to cover here then you're going to see a gold at 3, 3500 some kind of a crazy number higher but that is not typically what has happened typically that gets resolved with the commercials uh making out better off than the speculators so just I I one way or the other there's going to be blood in the Gold World whether it comes from the speculators or whether it comes from the commercials I don't know yet but I can tell you if gold goes any higher in the very short term I will be buying some Hedges”
The speaker initially set target prices of 150 for the DXY (up 66% from ~89 starting point) and $5,000 for gold (up 275% from ~$1,330), meaning his thesis never predicted the dollar would rise as much as gold, contrary to critics who claim he made this assertion.
“uh the very when I first started talking about this uh the dollar Index was around 89 and gold was around 1330 um the Target price for gold uh was 150 uh I'm sorry the Target price for the dxy was 150 and the Target price for gold was 5,000 so if all of my Target prices were met that would mean that the the dollar Index Rose 66% and uh the the gold rose 375% so the idea that I expected the dollar to go up the same amount as gold is is is crazy”
The speaker plans to buy hedges if gold rises further in the very short term, given the overbought conditions and extreme leveraged short positioning, warning recent buyers that 'there's going to be blood in the Gold World'.
“but I can tell you if gold goes any higher in the very short term I will be buying some Hedges can't tell you what to do personally if you can hold on you know I think everybody should absolutely old gold again I'm not telling you this because I want you to run out and sell all your gold I'm telling you this because the situation the environment that we're in right now typically has not worked out well over the short term for those who have put on new position so anyway with all that in mind um be careful out there there's going to be blood in the Gold World one way or the other again which side it's going to be really interesting to see”
As of the time of speaking, the DXY has risen 12% toward its 66% target (18% of the way there), while gold has risen 97% toward its 275% target (26% of the way there), showing gold is actually ahead of schedule compared to the dollar relative to their respective target paths.
“the dxy has gone up 12% Gold's gone up 97% and I'm sorry these uh these charts look a little off I'm not sure what happened when um when I uploaded this um but the dxy is 18% towards the Target that I gave and gold is 26% towards the Target that I gave”
The speaker first publicly mentioned the milkshake theory and the concept of dollars and gold rising together in early summer 2018 (after developing it starting early 2018), when gold was priced at $1,330 and the dollar index was around 89.
“the first time I ever uttered the word milkshake with regard to anything Finance related was early in 2018 and at that time gold was priced at 13 30 and the dollar Index was around 89 and over the next couple months I kind of developed the thesis a little bit for and then early summer late spring early summer I gave my first interview where I spoke about this publicly”
The last cabinet meeting for the Biden Administration was chaired by Jill Biden rather than Joe Biden, indicating the country does not have an operating president, yet this has not been covered heavily in mainstream news despite what would have been front-page treatment in any other administration.
“in one case this week uh the last cabinet meeting for the Biden Administration was not even chaired by Joe Biden it was chaired by his wife now since when was was Jill Biden elected president...it indicates we don't have an operating president and it hasn't even really been covered all that much in the news I mean I think in any other time and in any other Administration this would be all over the front page news but it's not”
Markets initially sold off Wednesday into close following the Fed announcement, but Thursday morning opened up nearly 2% on the S&P and 3% on the NASDAQ before pulling back into close, ending the week roughly where they started.
“the markets sold off initially uh but not hard sold off Wednesday into the close um and then I think when but but listen it was a very very doish meeting...Thursday morning the markets open just up gang busters you know I think the the S&P was up close to 2% at one point the NASDAQ was up close to 3% at one point point and then it kind of pulled back into the close I think they ended up you know the S&P was up one and NASDAQ was up two and then they sold off a little bit Friday morning bounced a little bit but you know we kind of ended the week kind of where we started the week”
Gold closed above $2,620, silver above $31, oil above $70 (previously trading mid to high $60s), and the VIX came down to 16, with equities near all-time highs in the week following the Fed announcement.
“gold had another great week ended above 2600 2620 um uh you know the the as as we discussed the FED cut uh silver had a good week closed above 31 oil had a little bit of a better week it closed above 7 uh you know previously been trading in kind of the mid to high 60s vix came all the way down to 16 again um but as as we mentioned you know equities are back near their all-time highs”
The speaker published a report on the macro alchemist channel about carry trades that demonstrates why differences between fiat currencies matter, even for individuals who own gold and believe gold is the ultimate winner.
“for anybody who missed the last week's episode uh we we put out a report on the macro Alchemist Channel about carry trades and this very specifically shows why differences in Fiat currencies matter so even if you own gold and even if you think that's the ultimate winner which I agree with you if you have a business that operates on the global stage if you have personal interests real estate Investments exposure whatever it is the that has exposure to things other than the dollar or actually even at exposure to the dollar this matters”
The Fed's 50 basis point rate cut was likely frontloaded due to expected volatility in September, and the speaker had anticipated more volatility in that month which made the aggressive cut less surprising than it might have otherwise been.
“I had actually thought there might be a lot more volatility in September so the 50 basis points didn't actually surprise me um because I thought there would be a lot more volatility and I thought they would perhaps kind of want to frontload the cuts and that's essentially what they've done”
There have been two separate assassination attempts on Trump within a few months of each other in 2024, making it necessary to specify which assassination attempt one is discussing when talking about Trump being shot, exemplifying the absurdity of current times.
“it was only a couple weeks ago where Trump was potentially going to be shot again and the fact that we have to say again and it was only a couple weeks ago which was only a couple months from the first time I saw a great tweet from somebody who said I was talking to somebody about uh the potential Trump assassination the other day and the fact that I had to delineate between which potential assassin I was talking about uh is just aopo for”