
The new space race: Sen. Mark Kelly on China's bold ambitions, America's policy & Russian threat
What this covers
This GZERO World conversation pairs host Ian Bremer with Senator Mark Kelly, a former Navy pilot and astronaut who now sits on the armed services and intelligence committees. It begins with Kelly's firsthand view of the Space Shuttle. He calls it the best spaceship ever built and also the worst airplane he has flown, since it glided "like a rock or a Coke machine" with a single landing option. From there it moves to the International Space Station, which the shuttle made possible. The station is already past its planned lifespan, and NASA will eventually have to choose between maintaining it and funding lunar and Mars exploration. When it is retired, it must be guided through a controlled deorbit to a Pacific "spaceship graveyard" rather than left to decay.
The middle of the conversation is about competition. Kelly says the contest is now more China-focused than the Soviet rivalry of the 1960s, and that Russia and China are both militarizing space. He cites China's far-side lunar sample return and its crewed-landing ambitions, but argues the U.S. remains "way ahead." He also recalls China's 2008 anti-satellite weapon test, whose debris later forced Space Shuttle Discovery to maneuver. He is skeptical that the 1967 Outer Space Treaty would restrain either country, and he stresses that deterring conflict means making China understand it cannot win.
The most contested thread concerns private companies. Kelly says U.S. firms should weigh patriotic alignment alongside shareholder interests. Bremer presses on Starlink in Ukraine, where operability decisions rested with SpaceX headquarters. Kelly describes talking with Elon Musk about keeping Russian forces off the network. The discussion also covers the 2023 Chinese surveillance balloon and the cost of missiles used against such targets, partnerships with Canada, Japan and Europe, UAP testimony from Navy pilots, and, briefly, Arizona politics after the Dobbs decision.
Senator Mark Kelly argues that U.S. space leadership depends on maintaining technological superiority over China, managing commercial sector alignment with national security interests, and investing in both exploration and defense capabilities while recognizing limited budget constraints.
- China's space achievements (moon sample return, space station) demonstrate capability requiring sustained U.S. technological advantage
- Commercial space companies like SpaceX must balance shareholder interests with patriotic alignment to U.S. strategic goals
- Space infrastructure decisions (ISS retirement, anti-satellite debris) require balancing exploration ambitions with security threats and resource limitations
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Without the Space Shuttle, the International Space Station—which is the size of a football field, weighs a million pounds, and serves as a National Laboratory—could not have been built, making the shuttle's development a critical investment despite high costs.
“without the space shuttle we would not have been able to build the International Space Station which is the size of a football field weighs a million pounds uh now a National Laboratory and has provided great I think a great return on the investment”
The Space Shuttle is the best spaceship ever built by any country due to its capability to carry seven crew members, large payload bay, robotic arm, external airlock allowing extravehicular repairs, and advanced communication systems, though it was expensive to design, build, and operate.
“the space shuttle is by far the best spaceship ever built by any country it is really remarkable...it can carry seven crew members uh in one Mission it carried eight has a large payload Bay has a pretty decent capacity to low earth orbit has a robotic arm has a great communication system has a air lock that's external to the crew compartment uh so you can send people outside to do repairs”
Commercial cargo and crew programs over the last decade have reduced the cost of reaching low earth orbit and higher altitudes dramatically, saving billions of dollars for American taxpayers compared to the Space Shuttle era.
“what we've done over the last decade or so since I left NASA was we've transitioned to a commercial cargo and Commercial crew program that has brought the cost down dramatically saving billions and billions of dollar for the American taxpayer and giving us a uh the ability to get to not only low earth orbit but higher at a much reduced cost”
The International Space Station is already operating beyond its original planned lifespan; it requires increasing crew time for maintenance over time, and NASA must eventually choose between maintaining it continuously versus dedicating resources to lunar and Mars exploration.
“we've had crew members on board since 1998...we weren't planning to operate this continuously forever and it's beyond its original [design life] and it takes today it takes more crew time to maintain it than it used to that number is only going to increase and if we want to do things Beyond low earth orbit like go back to the moon and go on to Mars one day we need we need the money...we have limited resources so we can't do both we can't operate the space station continuously and go back to the moon and go on to Mars”
The competition in space is now more China-focused than it was in the 1960s during the Soviet competition; Russia has militarized space and China is doing the same, creating a major national security concern about how the space domain will be used in future conflicts.
“I would say our our competition is now more China focused than it was in the 1960s with the Soviet Union you know Russia has spent a lot of time and effort in the in the militarization of space China is doing the same thing...a big concern of mine is you know how is the space domain going to be used in any future conflict”
Sidewinder air-to-air missiles cost approximately $400,000 and AMRAAM missiles cost over $1 million, making the practice of shooting down every balloon detected over the U.S. economically prohibitive.
“a Sidewinder you know cost $400,000 an amram is over a million this can get very expensive very quickly”
In 2008, China tested an anti-satellite weapon by shooting down one of its own satellites, creating a significant debris field; this test created debris that later forced Space Shuttle Discovery to maneuver away from a piece of Chinese space junk that could have destroyed the shuttle.
“when I was the uh commander of Space Shuttle Discovery in 2008 the Chinese had shot down one of their own Satellites with an anti satellite capability that they had developed...it created a big debris field then later when I was in orbit at the space station we had a maneuver to get out of the the way of a piece of Chinese space junk from that test and that could have blown up the ship could have destroyed the space shuttle”
The ISS, weighing over a million pounds, cannot be allowed to decay uncontrolled in orbit; instead it must be guided to a designated 'spaceship graveyard' in the Pacific Ocean through a controlled deorbit vehicle, similar to preventing another Skylab scenario.
“you can't you just don't want to let the orbit Decay over time want this to be Sky lab yeah it would it would come in uncontrolled it weighs over a million pounds big pieces would hit the ground we need to make sure that it safely goes to the spaceship graveyard that we have in a certain part of the Pacific Ocean”
The Space Shuttle is the worst airplane Kelly has ever flown in due to poor flying quality, gliding like 'a rock or a Coke machine,' requiring re-entry from halfway around the planet and having only one landing option at Kennedy Space Center.
“it's also happens to be the worst airplane I've ever flown in my life because just as lousy flying quality as I'm a former Navy test pilot it's hard to fly uh and it's a glider and this thing Glides from halfway around the planet starting over the Indian Ocean where you do the deorbit burn problem is it Glides like a rock or a Coke machine”
China's space program goals include putting astronauts on the lunar surface; while China has achieved notable milestones like returning samples from the far side of the moon—something no other nation has done—the U.S. is 'way ahead' in overall space capability and should maintain that lead.
“China's uh engagement in space they now have a small space station they've got crew members uh in orbit now uh they're just returned a sample from uh the back side of which no one's done before...we are certainly capable of doing it uh but it's challenging and you got to give them credit...we're way ahead of China in in any space Endeavor uh we need to make sure we stay ahead”
U.S.-Russian cooperation on the International Space Station in the 1990s and through the present, including joint crew missions and shared research, was successful in improving relations between the two countries, though this cooperation was undermined by Russia's invasion of Ukraine.
“we did that with the Russians right starting in the 1990s...with the International Space Station in the 1990s every space flight I went on all four of them were up to the space station...there were always Russians on board the space station every flight and that cooperation worked really well we got along in space teams got along on the ground this tried to help you know further a good relationship between our two countries unfortunately what Putin did in Ukraine”
Partnerships with Canada, Japan, and Europe on space programs have been successful in helping these nations become space-capable while allowing cost-sharing of burdens, demonstrating mutual benefit beyond purely competitive metrics.
“with our European partners with Canada with Japan having them as partners in this endeavor has been a a a huge success for us uh they can share some of the the burden of the cost we can you know we can help them become space fairing Nations that part has been a really big success”
Starlink has provided a tremendous increase in communications capability for Ukraine in its war against Russia, giving Ukraine a significant military advantage; without Starlink, Ukraine would be in a different strategic position.
“starlink has been a tremendous increase in capability not only for the ukrainians I mean to help them in this in this war against Russia I mean it's really been a huge advantage and without it they would be in a different place than they are today”
The 2023 Chinese surveillance balloon transiting through Alaska, Canada, and the continental United States was a provocative action that the U.S. detected and shot down; this was an intelligence collection asset that provided China with intelligence it could not have obtained from satellites in low earth orbit or geostationary orbit.
“it's it's it's like any other ISR asset in this case you know much closer to to to home...and much more provocative...flying into our airspace...they should have realized we're going to figure it out...we detected and we ultimately shot it down...they did that for a reason there was some collection that they received from that balloon that they would not have been otherwise be able to to get from something in Leo or hes that's why they did it”
Navy fighter pilots, including those in leadership positions in squadrons, have provided compelling testimony about witnessing unidentified aerial phenomena that they believe are technologically impossible for the U.S. or known adversaries to produce.
“I've seen some compelling testimony you know from Navy fighter pilots you know who you know often in you know one case in a position of leadership in a squadron that's seen something very compelling...convinced is technologically not possible by the us or adversaries”
The 1967 Outer Space Treaty prohibited military use of the moon and established that no nation owns the moon, similar to Antarctica; however, Kelly expresses skepticism that Russia and China would not violate this treaty if it served their interests.
“the outer space treaty said we're not going to use the moon for military purposes and nobody owns the moon um you know I wouldn't put it past you know our adversaries to you know change their minds”
U.S. companies should make decisions aligned with U.S. national interests and values, balancing shareholder interests with patriotic alignment, because adversaries do not share equivalent ethical constraints and U.S. companies should recognize this asymmetry.
“I would hope that that us companies would be making decisions uh you know that that are in you know certainly in the best interest of the company and their shareholders but also you know leaning into the fact that these are us companies and there should be some level of patriotism there and you know aligning with us and our values our adversaries you know don't have the same you know ethical and moral compass”
During the Ukraine war, Starlink decisions on operability were made by SpaceX corporate headquarters rather than being in alignment with U.S. or Ukrainian strategic interests, raising concerns about corporate control over critical national security infrastructure.
“during the war in Ukraine as you just mentioned um that starlink decisions on starlink operability was being made uh by their corporate headquarters not necessarily in alignment with what the us or Ukraine would want”
Space shuttles and space stations maintain a minimum safe distance of about half a mile from any detected threat; objects smaller than a bolt are difficult to track with precision state vectors, making them dangerous but harder to detect and avoid.
“we don't we don't allow ourselves to get within about a half a mile of anything that can be a threat if we can detect it you know some things you get smaller than about a size of a bolt starts to get hard from to be able to get a state Vector on it to know where it is and where it's going”
The universe contains approximately two trillion galaxies with hundreds of billions of stars and planets in our own galaxy, making the existence of extraterrestrial life somewhere statistically plausible, which is why people are interested in UFO phenomena.
“our galaxy is a big place you know the universe is two trillion galaxies we've got you know hundreds of billions of stars and planets in our own and it's you know something people often think about is there life out there somewhere else what is that life like does that life visit uh you know visit here does visit Earth”
Kelly's primary goal on the armed services and intelligence committees is to prevent conflict between the U.S. and China, because such conflict would result in mutual losses for both nations, though the best way to prevent it is to ensure China understands it will not win.
“I hope one of my goals sitting on the armed services committee and the intelligence committee is to make sure that we don't get into conflict with China we we don't want that I don't think they want it uh that's going to be a situation where you know none of us win uh I think uh I also think the best way for us to stay out of a kind that kind of conflict is to make sure that the Chinese realize that they're not going to win”
In the early stages of Starlink provision to Ukraine, Russia acquired Starlink dishes and terminals through unsanctioned methods—buying private products and shipping them to Russia—requiring SpaceX to develop countermeasures to prevent Russian military use.
“in the beginning there were some challenges I mean how do you prevent uh another country from getting access to the dishes and the terminals and you know they do it through unsanctioned you know methods I wouldn't say they're necessarily illegal they're buying a private product and they're shipping it to Russia”
Kelly has spoken with Elon Musk about preventing Russian military access to Starlink, and SpaceX has responded positively and made efforts to mitigate Russian military use, though not always successfully.
“I've talked to Elon Musk about this and and they have responded I think in a a very positive way to do what they can to prevent the Russ government the Russian military from using starlink not always successful but they're doing what they can to mitigate the the effects”
Red Sea maritime threats requiring U.S. military response are threats to international shipping, supply chains, and U.S. forces; addressing them through kinetic means has become extremely expensive but necessary.
“and by the way this stuff in the Red Sea are threats to you know international shipping you know to threats to our supply chain threats to US forces we have to shoot that stuff down uh so I've got some legislation bipartisan legislation”
The Supreme Court's Dobbs decision overturning Roe v. Wade has significantly changed Arizona politics; abortion restrictions on the ballot are expected to drive voter turnout significantly, particularly among women and men who support women's reproductive rights.
“the the do's decision you know has changed things you know uh uh significantly politically uh women especially uh but uh you know men who support women in their right to make this decision this is become a big political issue we've got choice on the ballot uh in November I expect it's going to drive voter turnout significantly”
Kelly believes the U.S. government has an obligation to investigate unidentified aerial phenomena (now called UAPs instead of UFOs) and should allocate more resources to studying them because current resource levels are insufficient to conduct credible and responsible research.
“It's Our obligation you know on the armed service something that he is convinced is technologically not possible...to to look into it and maybe and put some more resources behind studying these phenomenon we don't call them UFOs anymore we call them uaps...we haven't devoted enough resource to be credible and resp”
In low earth orbit, the private sector dominates, which is positive, but requires alignment between American government and private companies' interests, which is not always the case.
“I see there's an area where the Americans are doing an incredible job but a lot of it is dominated by the private sector yeah which is good which is good um if the American government is aligned with those companies sure um which is not always the case which is not the case”
Kelly has proposed bipartisan legislation requiring that balloons launched from the continental United States and flying over U.S. territory be equipped with transponders, allowing NORAD to easily distinguish domestic/commercial balloons from potentially hostile foreign balloons without wasting expensive missiles.
“I've got some legislation bipartisan legislation to make sure that at least the balloons that we're launching here from the continental United States uh and flying over you know US Territory has a transponder on it very simple so we could you know so NORAD could say hey we don't need to focus on that one...that's a University you know that's a you know that's a company somewhere us company we don't need to focus on that we need to focus on the ones that we really have no information on”
Kelly believes China received the message from the U.S. shooting down the spy balloon because there has been a much greater level of military-to-military communication between the U.S. and China since then, and China has not flown a high-altitude balloon over the U.S. since the incident.
“I think they did because there certainly been a much greater level of military to military communication between the US and China also you see I mean they they haven't flown a high altitude balloon over the United States since we shot that one down”
Russia's invasion of Ukraine, including targeted killing of civilians and war crimes, demonstrated that space cooperation alone cannot prevent military aggression and limits the utility of engagement as a conflict-prevention strategy.
“what Putin did in Ukraine is I'd say indicative of well did did that even matter I mean he attacked one of our allies illegally murdering you know women children old people intentionally by the way committing war crimes they are targeting civilians so yeah I'm a little I'm a little become a little skeptical”
The Biden-Harris administration has accomplished remarkable achievements including reducing healthcare costs for seniors ($35 insulin), the CHIPS and Science Act for semiconductor manufacturing, major climate change investment, and bipartisan gun safety legislation.
“the stuff that they have accomplished with us pretty remarkable brought down the cost of healthare for seniors $35 insulin uh chips and science act which I was one of the lead negotiators on and got that through bringing semiconductor manufacturing back to the United States climate change you know biggest investment in trying to fix our climate in possibly our country's history...by bipartisan gun safety legislation”
Taiwan faces strategic challenges regarding communications infrastructure and has expressed concerns about relying on Starlink due to Tesla's business relationships with mainland China, creating a tension between technological needs and political/economic alignment concerns.
“Taiwan has had difficulties um with the idea that they would do that because of the relationship between Tesla and China and Mainland China”
Arizona has a large military footprint with mostly Army and Air Force bases and many service members, making defense and military issues particularly important to the state.
“we've got a big military footprint mostly Army and Air Force a lot of bases a lot of service members”
Kelly's opponent Ruben Gallego is a former Marine who fought in Iraq, lived in a cave with his rifle during combat, and has worked closely with Kelly on the armed services committees to accomplish shared goals for service members in Arizona.
“Ruben gyo House member Marine fought in Iraq guy lived in a cave with with his rifle on Iraq lived in a cave you know fought valiantly for this country a guy I've worked with very closely he's on the armed services Committee in the house I'm on the armed services Committee in the Senate we've worked very closely together to accomplish a lot for service members in the state of Arizona”
Kelly was elected to the U.S. Senate in 2020 in the same cycle as President Biden and Vice President Harris, giving him direct overlap with the administration during 2020-2024.
“I was elected in 2020 and that's the same year President Biden and vice president Harris were elected as well I've overlapped exactly with the administ”
Terminology changed from 'UFO' to 'UAP' (Unidentified Aerial Phenomena) to reduce stigma and focus on scientific investigation rather than extraterrestrial speculation.
“we don't call them UFOs anymore we call them uaps we Chang the name identified aerial phenomenon phenomenon okay enough so yeah it's the same thing that should make it easier UFO yeah it's B you know it's basically and as the answer we don't know at this point”
Kelly's identical twin brother Scott is also an astronaut who has flown in space four times, twice on the Space Shuttle as pilot and commander, and once as commander of a mission to the International Space Station where he spent a year in space.
“call me pretty much anything except Scott which is my twin brother's name who also has been an astronaut who was an astronaut as well we each flew in space four times I flew four times uh as the pilot or the commander of the Space Shuttle my brother flew two missions on the space shuttle once as the pilot once as the commander of the Space Shuttle this is your identical twin brother my identical twin and then he flew up to the International Space Station on the soyu the rushan rocket and spacecraft and he ultimately spent uh a year in space on the space station”
Kelly's opponent Kari Lake is still fighting the 2022 gubernatorial election and denying the results of the 2020 presidential election; she is a divisive figure who wants to take away voting rights and reproductive rights.
“Ruben's opponent Carri Lake also claiming that she is you know still the possibly the governor of Arizona you know she's still fighting the 2022 election still denying the results of the presidential election in 2020 I mean and and is just a incredibly divisive figure in in Arizona...wants to take away people's Rights Voting Rights Reproductive Rights”
There are multiple Senate races in 2024 receiving increased attention, including the Arizona race, due to disinformation and claims of election rigging.
“we got a lot of Senate races 2018 maybe even 2016 2018 2020 2022 now 2024 and this one getting a lot more attention um in part because of you know disinformation and claims of rigging”
Kelly has received many questions from the public about whether he has seen evidence of extraterrestrial life during his time in orbit, with people assuming that his space experience gives him special insight into UFO phenomena.
“I get these questions all the time people think as I've been to space like maybe I have this special Insight or maybe I've seen something um while I've uh you know spent time orbiting the earth I haven't um you know I don't know think we've got you know visitors from other places”
Kelly considers Washington politics during his three and a half years in the Senate to be never boring, with constant interesting developments.
“I've been in Washington in the United States Senate for three and a half years it does not get boring”
Former President Donald Trump wants to take the United States backward, particularly on women's reproductive rights and to the 1860s in terms of women's rights; Kelly characterizes Trump as a threat to democracy who is now a convicted criminal and a 'grifter.'
“Prior president Donald Trump wants to take us back in Arizona even back to the 1860s when you consider women's teren reproduc rights yeah wants to take us backwards is a threat to our democracy is now a convicted criminal is a grifter I mean there is you know one issue after another”