
Europe in Crisis with Lyn Alden
What this covers
This conversation between host Peter McCormack and macroeconomist Lynn Alden starts from the market turmoil that followed the UK government's proposed tax cuts. It then widens into a survey of the developed world's debt position. Alden separates the proximate cause of the UK scare from the deeper one. The proximate cause was pension funds using derivative-based leverage, which required them to post collateral as gilt prices fell and so forced them to sell into a falling market. The deeper cause is that debt above 100 percent of GDP makes it hard to find enough balance sheet space to absorb the issuance. The Bank of England ended up intervening with quantitative easing (QE)) despite high inflation.
The middle of the discussion looks abroad. Alden treats Japan as the country that has stretched a similar situation furthest, crediting slow broad money growth, corporate deleveraging and the absence of acute commodity shortages. She argues that under yield curve control the pressure moves from the bond market to the currency, and that the Bank of Japan accepts a weaker yen provided it does not fall in a disorderly way. She also explains why a surging dollar tends to coincide with foreign selling of treasuries. She adds that developed-country default on debt in its own currency is a choice, and she contrasts today with Weimar Germany.
The later sections are more contested. Alden warns that US banks, already heavy in treasuries, could face UK-style duration risk if the Fed loosens the supplementary leverage ratio. She describes a thin, illiquid treasury market and argues that the dollar's strength may not be its end state. The last stretch turns to energy: underinvestment, cautious oil producers, Europe's exposure, and the slow work of rebuilding grids and import infrastructure. McCormack cites a Luke Gromen argument that the debt system depends on cheap oil. The closing question is whether holding dollars remains attractive once the Fed can no longer keep tightening.
The UK and developed world are caught in a structural debt trap where central banks must print money into high inflation to prevent sovereign bond market collapse, a situation resembling the 1940s that cannot be resolved without major energy supply increases and will likely end in currency devaluation and financial repression.
- High debt combined with high inflation creates a 'checkmate scenario' for central banks where tightening risks bond market collapse and default
- The UK pension system's leverage on government bonds created a cascade failure requiring Bank of England QE despite 10% inflation
- Energy shortages are the fundamental constraint preventing normal monetary policy solutions and will persist for years
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
When the dollar rises sharply, countries typically sell foreign treasuries to get dollars for debt servicing or to defend their currencies, opposite the intuitive belief that dollar strength means foreigners want dollars; historically, treasury buying happens when the dollar is weak.
“you can think of of treasuries as like acorns a squirrel you know they gather acorns in the summer so they can eat them in the winter uh and so when the dollar is weak and when things are going well a lot of countries will will print currency and go and buy foreign reserves they'll buy you know treasuries they'll buy other other you know assets outside of their own currency system and to store those up and then if you have a the opposite if you have a period where the dollar is rising very sharply uh they can they can then sell some of those treasuries uh and so often people think you know intuitively when adults growing up it must be and a lot of foreigners want to buy treasuries and U.S assets but in many it usually means the exact opposite which is the dollar is going up and so you know these these countries either stop buying treasuries or slow their purchases of treasuries or outright sell treasuries uh either to get dollars to service dollar examinated debts or to defend the value of their currency”
When bond prices fall due to rising yields, pension funds holding bonds as collateral face potential liquidation if collateral values drop below required ratios, which creates forced selling pressure that worsens prices and triggers more forced selling in a vicious cycle.
“when the value of your collateral goes down when yields go up it means the bond price is going down and if you hold all the way to maturity it doesn't matter too much I mean inflation above yields still matters but if you're posting them is collateral and you need to maintain certain ratios if that if that value of the collateral goes down you know you might get liquidated you might have to sell those bonds”
Acute energy shortages hurt the least resourceful members of society the most—those with least ability to pay for energy—which explains why we'll see periods of inflation until energy systems are fixed.
“as you point out it hurts the the you know the the least uh resourceful members in society the ones with the least the least ability to pay for that are the ones that are most impacted uh and so uh the way I've been describing it is that we're going to get periods of inflation until we fix the Energy System”
Default by developed countries on sovereign debt denominated in their own currency is technically a choice rather than a necessity, and has been extremely rare historically, with Russia in the 1990s being the main example.
“it's always technically a possibility but it would be a choice right so if the liabilities are denominator in your own currency it's always a choice not to default right and the only the only instance I'm aware of of a country defaulting in its own currency was Russia in the 1990s uh during the Asian financial crisis they actually just nominally defaulted on on some Cur on some debts that were in their own currency”
Weimar hyperinflation occurred because Germany had liabilities in gold (war reparations) it couldn't print, had a damaged industrial base creating supply constraints, and lost a war, creating conditions fundamentally different from developed market situations today.
“when you look at ymr they had War reparations they owed you know reparations in Gold they you know their industrial base was damaged by the war so they had serious Supply uh uh you know constraints”
Banks in 2008 had very low treasuries and cash as a percentage of assets, meaning most assets consisted of loans and riskier securities subject to nominal default risk, whereas now banks are highly allocated to cash and treasuries with lower default risk.
“in 2008 Banks had very low uh treasuries and cash as a percentage of their assets which meant that the you know the vast majority of their assets consisted of loans and riskier securities uh and so those that's the portion that's subject to nominal default risk whereas the the cash and supposed to the treasures are not whereas now they're very highly allocated to cash and treasuries uh and so they have you know and so they have more of a basically they would have to have worse defaults on the risky side of their book in order to have a similar event of what happened in 2008 right”
SLR adjustments increase risk for commercial banks by concentrating their portfolios in long-duration treasuries, potentially putting them in a position similar to UK pensions if rates continue rising.
“if they did the SLR adjustment it does that increase risk for the commercial Banks uh so in some ways yes because it gives them more exposure to long duration treasuries which which could potentially put them in a similar situation as UK pensions”
Europe is particularly vulnerable to energy shocks because the energy sector has been starved of investment, making energy sovereignty a critical issue that highlights the importance of energy independence.
“and that I think it's going to take years and therefore it's a particularly bad problem for most of Europe because uh the energy sector is Black from investment in I mean particularly in the UK it highlights the issue that energy sovereignty is important”
When central banks face high debt combined with high inflation, they encounter a 'checkmate scenario' where they have only bad options—they can delay things but ultimately run into an inability to control the system as they would like.
“that's the closest thing that a central bank has to a Checkmate scenario where there's there's only bad options uh and that they can they can pick between some bad options they can delay things but they they basically run into an inability to control uh you know the system as they'd like to”
The deeper issue causing the UK crisis is that debt levels over 100 percent of GDP make it extremely difficult to find balance sheet space to absorb all that debt, but the more proximate issue was the UK pension system's leverage through derivative schemes requiring collateral posting.
“the deeper issues too much debt anytime a country gets over a 100 debt the GDP it's really hard to find the balance sheet space to shove all that debt into uh so that's the deeper issue but the more proximate issue the you know the issue that's closer to the actual problem this instance was the pension system”
When bond yields can't rise because central banks are preventing it through yield curve control, holders of those bonds in other currencies simply sell the bonds and take the loss, shifting the pressure to the currency instead.
“when when the bond market can't set prices the way it thinks it should they instead just get out of the bonds and that hurt the currency right so so the release valve ends up being the currency”
Japan has explicitly accepted a weaker yen as a tool and is happy with yield curve control because they're fine with a weaker currency, but they don't want it to fall disorderly, making the speed of devaluation a key factor.
“Japan has specifically used uh you know currency division devaluation as a tool that's one reason why they're happy to yield curve control is they're saying you know we're fine with a weaker currency uh because we get some benefits from it um but they just don't want it disorderly uh fall in the end uh and so it's about the speed sometimes uh that matters”
The Fed could change the supplementary leverage ratio (SLR) to allow banks to buy more treasuries by making treasuries not count toward capital ratio calculations, effectively allowing banks to leverage more but only on treasuries.
“they can do SLR they're called you know changes to the supplementary leverage ratio which is a wonkish way of basically allowing Banks to buy more treasuries uh so right now they can basically make it so the treasures don't count when they're when they're calculating what their Capital ratios are”
The current period resembles the 1940s more than the 1970s because it combines high debt with high inflation, whereas the 1970s had low debt and high inflation, giving central banks more tools to respond with higher rates and tighter monetary conditions.
“this peer looks a lot like the 1940s which is when you have a combination of high debt and high inflation uh which is not what you had in the 70s in the 70s they had low debt and high inflation which means they had a lot more tools to respond to it with higher rates uh and with tighter monetary conditions”
If bond yields reprice significantly upward due to energy shortages and higher energy prices, stock valuations will decline, and since US stock market is 200 percent of GDP with valuations closely tied to stock market moves, a market rollover impacts government tax revenues significantly.
“and so the problem is if you have a significant repricing uh in bond yields due to energy shortages and higher energy prices and higher inflation that comes with it um you know basically stock valuations are going to come down uh and then the problem is that because systems are so financialized uh for example in the United States you know we have our stock market got up to 200 percent the size of GDP uh and and if you graph tax receipts compared to the stock market uh they're very similar charts you know tax receipts stopped going up and start going down even if the if the U.S stock market rolls over”
Japan has managed to prolong its situation more than any other country in similar circumstances through a combination of slow broad money supply growth, corporate deleveraging offsetting fiscal spending, and the absence of acute commodity shortages.
“Japan is in a weird case because it's it's managed to prolong its situation more than any other country in its circumstances has done”
Energy shortages are a complex long-term problem to fix because grids are complex, energy sources can't change on a dime, import infrastructure must be changed, and new wells and reserves must be created.
“you know grids are complex energy sources can't be changed on a dime uh you know import infrastructure needs to be changed uh new new wells and new uh you know reserves have to be created to to produce more of the energy that that's being in short supply”
There have been major periods in history with huge spikes in the dollar followed by huge falls in the dollar, making current dollar strength not necessarily the end state.
“but there are major periods in history where you get a huge spike in the dollar and then you get a huge fall in the dollar”
The US has had trade deficits as a structural weakness compared to developed world, and when the Fed becomes dovish relative to the rest of the world or equally dovish, the dollar tends to fall.
“the one of the biggest weaknesses that the US has had relative to the rest of the developed world is that we run these bigger trade deficits which are normally bad for a currency and so whenever we're like more dovish compared to the rest of the world or just as dovish you have a tendency for the dollar to start falling”
Oil companies are being cash flow positive so they're being very disciplined about capital deployment, only drilling cautiously and not wanting to bring new supply at the top of the market, which feeds into supply limitation.
“fossil fuel companies like oil companies and gas companies they're being cash flow positive so they're basically being very disciplined and very careful with how they manage their Capital they're saying okay we're going to be profitable we're only gonna you know we're not gonna over drill we don't want to make the mistake of like bringing a lot of new Supply right at the top of the market and so they're playing it very cautiously”
Luke Gromen recently put out a tweet arguing that central bank circles know the world debt markets as currently configured can only be maintained with cheap and cheaper oil, and without cheap oil the entire system fails or reverts to pay-as-you-go economies.
“Luke Roman put out a tweet and you might have seen it he said in Central Bank circles it's well known the world debt markets as we know them can only be maintained with cheap and cheaper oil without cheap oil the entire system fails or reverse backs to pay as you go economies”
The situation now is arising due to high debts, populism, energy crises, and the fact that the West is aged with stressed entitlement systems as higher share of population receives benefits compared to 20-50 years ago.
“you know they're encountering it due to you know energy crises uh High debts populism um and and and this time is also because of of how aged the West is right so a lot of our entitlement systems are stressed by the fact that you know there's a much higher share of people that are receiving benefits uh you know relative to size population compared to what it looked like 20 30 40 50 years ago”
Currency diversification is always reasonable, but the caution is that when the Fed is unable to keep tightening, the rate spread narrows and the advantage of holding dollars disappears, potentially marking a structural peak in the dollar.
“I think currency diversification uh is always reasonable the the caution I would I would give is that when we do reach a point where the FED is unable to keep tightening right so so it's really that that rate of change that matters when the when the FED is tightening more aggressively than most other developed Market central banks the industry spread uh between what you get on on U.S assets compared to foreign assets is wider”
With very few foreign official pools of capital buying treasuries and US banks already stuffed full of treasuries, the US treasury market is facing extremely illiquid conditions with wider bid-ask spreads and thin markets where large traders can move the market.
“it essentially means that the U.S system is running to a similar issue that the UK ran into which is our our bond yields going up the Market's getting very illiquid uh so you know it's hard you have you know wider bid ask spreads and just kind of thin markets where a big Trader can move the market”
As energy-intensive manufacturing shuts down in Europe (aluminum refining, etc.) due to high energy costs, economic activity and tax revenue decline further, creating a vicious cycle where central banks are forced to print despite inflation because sovereign deficits widen due to falling revenues combined with already-high debt.
“if energy gets out of and then you have Europe start shutting down like aluminum uh you know refining and other types of energy intensive manufacturing uh and then therefore you have just less economic activity that's less tax revenue you already have high deficits and high debts”
The Bank of Japan explicitly stated they would not attempt to fight inflation, would keep rates at zero, and would implement yield curve control to hold bond yields down even if inflation was above their target.
“the bank of Japan as all this inflation was coming in they just said we're not even going to try we're gonna we're gonna keep keep rates at zero we're even gonna do yield curve control so even if the longer end of the bond curve tries to go up we're going to keep printing money and buying those bonds to hold the yields down uh even if inflation's above our Target right”
Japan has 1.2 trillion dollars in foreign exchange reserves, primarily US treasuries, which gives it the ability to stabilize its currency by selling reserves and buying yen back, as it recently did for the first time since the 1990s.
“Japan however does have defenses they have something like 1.2 trillion dollars worth of of treasuries of you know foreign exchange reserves and so when they're faced with a situation of they don't want to increase yields uh you know but they also don't want you know super disorderly yend evaluation they can start selling some of their reserves uh and buying Yen back uh and they you know for the first time since the 90s they they did do that recently they sold some treasuries in order to try to stabilize the the fall of the Yen”
The UK has less foreign exchange reserves than Japan both in absolute level and relative to GDP and money supply, giving it fewer options for stabilizing its currency if it is also trying to stabilize the bond market.
“in the UK's case is they have less reserves including you know both absolute level and relative to their GDP uh and their and their money supply and so the UK does not have a ton of options it when it comes to stabilizing its currency if they're also trying to stabilize the bond market at the same time you gotta kind of have to pick one or the other”
The 2008 housing crisis was driven by Fed chair Greenspan cutting rates to 1 percent, giving everyone an incentive to borrow and invest in real estate, banks securitizing mortgages to move them off balance sheets, and rating agencies stamping everything as triple-A despite subprime mortgages in the pools.
“especially you know in the United States you had real estate went up very quickly we'll Force you at first you had green span uh you know the former fed share cut rates all the way to like one percent uh and so that basically gave everyone a gigantic incentive to go out and borrow and and invest in real estate then you had Banks uh securitize it so instead of issuing a mortgage and then holding that mortgage on their balance sheet they didn't throw it into a pool of other mortgages and and sell it uh so it wasn't their problem and then you had rating agencies you know just look at that whole bunch of of things and stamp you know as Triple A”
Real estate was thought to never crash, with expectations it would only go up or have flat years of maybe 1-2 percent declines, but during the Great Depression and again during 2008, US real estate went down by double digit percentages, wiping out models and cascading failures.
“there's some subprime mortgages in there they're like well you know the thesis was that real estate never goes down you know sometimes it has like a flat year maybe it goes down one or two percent but it never never crashes it's real estate it only goes up and of course if you look back long enough in history during the Great Depression uh real estate went down uh and this was the second time in history where U.S real estate went went down by double digit percentages and that wiped out all the models”
Cost of bailing out the private sector during the 2008 crisis was that more debt was pushed to the sovereign level, so now the problem is similar but at the sovereign level instead of private sector level.
“the basically the the cost of bailing out the private sector uh back during the global financial crisis in the United States and Europe and elsewhere was that you push more debt to The Sovereign level uh and so that basically it's a similar type of problem but coming from a very different spot this time right”
The treasury market broke in March 2020 when global trade ground to a halt and all countries tried to sell treasuries simultaneously to get dollars for debt service, requiring the Fed to buy a trillion dollars worth in three weeks.
“that happened to the U.S treasury market back in March 2020 uh and so you have a kind of a similar thing playing out now but in a less fast way right so that was you know global trade ground to a halt you know basically overnight you know the they still had dollar debts at the service and so you had a very rapid selling of foreign treasuries and it basically broke the U.S treasury market the FED had to come in and buy a trillion dollars worth of treasuries in three weeks”
The speaker would be looking at yield levels and liquidity indicators including Bloomberg's government bond market liquidity index to assess proximity to a treasury market break.
“I'd be looking at liquidity indicate one is yields right so if yields keep grinding higher uh on the long end of the curve that that's an indicator uh number two I'd be looking at at liquidity conditions right so for example Bloomberg has an index of of government Market uh Government Bond Market liquidity right so there are various ways to quantify this um and so you basically you look for quantitative measures”
Production infrastructure—transportation infrastructure and LNG capacity—is a separate constraint from production volume that must also be expanded for energy supply to increase.
“so it's not just the production it's also the infrastructure the transportation infrastructure LNG capacity uh things like that”
Cheap, abundant energy allows lower inflation and therefore lower interest rates, improving asset valuations because the discount rate for bonds versus equities is lower.
“um and it also allows for Less inflation and therefore lower interest rates uh and when you do a calculation on say a stock valuation you know you're generally comparing it to like a long duration Bond you're saying I could own a 10-year treasury uh what would it take me to to own this stock instead uh and so if the 10-year treasury is one percent uh the hurdle for owning that Equity uh is a lot lower meaning that you're willing to pay a lot more than if the 10-year treasury is four percent uh then you're not willing to pay as much for that equity”
Property valuations in different countries represent different financial bubbles—sometimes property market is the bubble, sometimes stock market, sometimes both—creating systemic risk in most developed countries from high asset valuations at low interest rates.
“that's that's you know if you include property prices I mean different different countries have different bubbles right so some sometimes it's the property Market sometimes it's their stock market sometimes it's a little bit of both but generally most you know developed countries are so uh you know they had so such little interest rates and such high valuations of many of their assets uh and that's that's really not sustainable in a world of higher energy costs”
Higher interest rates cannot permanently solve developed country debt problems because they worsen fiscal deficits through two channels: (1) increased debt service costs on existing high debt, and (2) declining asset values and tax revenue from higher rates reducing growth.
“when you have uh you know a situation where interest rates are now flat or up while debt as a percentage of GDP is also going up that that's kind of that very dangerous combination of actually a higher and higher debt servicing costs including at The Sovereign level”
When a country faces currency crises, the sovereign bond market almost always wins over the currency in terms of priority because default is generally considered unthinkable, while currency depreciation is an available release valve.
“in that environment The Sovereign bond market will almost always win because you know default is is generally Unthinkable but but you say it's Unthinkable but is it a possibility”
Sovereign default would destroy financial system foundations because banks use treasuries as safe collateral for their entire system, and default would put the entire deposit base at risk by eliminating the collateral foundation.
“it doesn't really happen in these these you know these Western countries uh and so I would consider it a very low probability event that they would outright the fall because it would Ripple through everything else right so Banks use uh treasuries as you know the foundation of their safe collateral right so if you defaulted on a big enough scale to Banks uh you would then put the entire deposit base at risk”
The Bank of England was forced to abandon its planned balance sheet reduction and shift to quantitative easing despite official inflation around 10 percent, which represents a 'banana republic' type situation of printing into high inflation.
“what we saw in the past couple weeks is that the bank of England you know that Domino did fall they had to join the chorus of some of the other most indebted countries in having to do quantitative easing despite the fact that they have official you know roughly 10 inflation”
Brazil raised interest rates from 2 percent to 14 percent starting in early 2021 because emerging markets have no choice but to front-run rate increases to avoid severe currency problems.
“there are some central banks uh that were you know they did all the things you'd expect uh like Brazil for example they raised rates for like two percent to like 14 starting early in 2021 a lot of our Emerging Markets really have no uh uh choice they pretty much have to front run that because they face more severe currency problems if they don't”
Devaluing a currency can make a country's exports more competitive on global markets because products become cheaper in foreign currency terms, though disorderly devaluation is not desired by any country.
“one of the one of the benefits of reducing the value of your currency uh is that in some cases the export Market can become more competitive right so UK products always being equal are now generally you know more competitive on the global market price because essentially you know UK laborers are getting paid less because even if they're getting paid the same amount those units are worth less”
QE is not necessarily money printing in all contexts—in Japan's case there is agreement that QE is not resulting in broad money supply growth because corporate deleveraging offsets the monetary expansion, whereas the interpretation differs in other contexts.
“you know this is uh basically an example like you know you've had you've had Snyder on your on your platform Jeff Snyder and he would he would quickly point out that QE is not money Printing and there are context where I agree and there are context where I don't agree in Japan uh that's that's a case where I generally agree”
All Fed policy options for supporting the treasury market are variations on money printing—either creating new currency for reserves or using leverage to achieve similar outcomes, representing a constraint on how much the Fed can tighten.
“but they're kind of variations on the theme of money printer Gober right so so when the when the Sovereign bond market breaks it basically you know you need more currency more more Reserve creation uh or or more leveraging to to buy those bonds”
Many of these structural problems aren't solvable in a workable time horizon, which means the system essentially ends with the money printer running, representing the endpoint of current system dynamics.
“and so a lot of these things just aren't solvable uh in in a in a workable time Horizon and so I think it's it essentially ends with money printer Gerber”
Once central banks engage in large-scale balance sheet expansion to stabilize markets, they typically cannot reduce their balance sheets afterward despite stated intentions, as the lack of other buyers for the assets makes reduction unfeasible.
“usually the answer with these types of things is no usually the usually the balance sheet keeps going up and might pause for a period of time it might go down you know briefly but it's hard for them to ever you know get those down because there's really a lack of balance sheet capacity to absorb the size of the flows”
Pension fund bail-out was necessary to prevent cascading failures, but the underlying cause was central bank intervention that created low rates and leverage in the system in the first place, so the bail-out is treating symptoms rather than causes—it's 'adding more poison to offset the effects of poison.'
“but on the other hand of that that you know the the way that they got so you know the way that the whole system got so levered in the first place is because of Central Bank intervention you know if you if you didn't have this kind of flexible money standard debts would have never got this High to begin with and so you know it's kind of like you know you're you're you you're at the point where it's like you need more of the poison to to not die from the effects of the poison right so it's not like you know a bailout's a good thing it's just like they put themselves in a situation where they have a few options and that's why these things normally it ends up taking it out on the currency in the long run”
Fed chair Powell is trying to be like Volcker—willing to sacrifice almost everything else in order to get inflation back down to target, but this approach will either fail or be short-lived as long as energy shortages persist.
“Powell's trying to do his best impersonation of volcker uh where you know he's trying to phrases like you know willing to sacrifice almost everything else in order to get inflation back down to the Target uh and I think you know it's either gonna fail or it's gonna be short-lived right because I think it you know I've described it like holding a beach ball underwater as as long as we have these energy shortages throughout the world”
The only way out of current crisis requires emergency response to get more energy supply, as countries must do everything in their power to get persistently more energy and incentivize companies to obtain more supply because energy shortages are a national security risk.
“really the only way out there is kind of emergency response like to to get more energy Supply basically country should be doing everything in their power to you know figure out how to get persistently more energy Supply and to incentivize companies to go out and and get more energy Supply because for some countries it is a national security risk at this point”
The ECB is engaged in a scheme to sell German bonds and buy bonds from Italy and other countries, representing a limited version of what Japan is doing with yield curve control.
“the ECB is doing this the scheme to sell some German bonds and buy some Italian bonds and other countries are involved as well so they're they're kind of in a slightly more limited version of what Japan is doing”
Japan is now facing acute inflationary problems for the first time in quite a while because they need to import energy, including liquefied natural gas which is now very elevated in price, and they can't afford high interest rates due to 250 percent government debt to GDP.
“the problem now is that for the first time in quite a while they're facing pretty acute inflationary problems because just like anyone else they need to imp you know import energy uh that you know they're they're you know they're they they do export a lot uh but the raw materials they often need to import including energy and specifically including liquefied natural gas which is now very elevated in price”
Currently perfect conditions for dollar rally exist because the US is more energy sufficient, the Fed is tightening more aggressively, and dollar-denominated debts throughout the world represent demand for dollars.
“right now we've had the perfect conditions for dollar rally because you know we are more energy sufficient we uh you know that the FED is is tightening more aggressively uh um there there is all these dollar denominator debts throughout the world that basically represents demand for dollars”
Even US bonds had their worst year in modern history due to the inflation shock and rising yields, meaning pension fund assumptions about manageable losses were violated by unprecedented moves.
“looking at at just U.S Bond markets even you know it's the worst year in modern history for those bonds and so a lot of these things are calculated assuming that you know you know you can have a pretty big fall but but they weren't really expecting that the level of fall that they got they weren't expecting this much inflation from that low of a yield level uh and so basically Bonds were bubble uh and then they were you know in some cases they levered bubble”
If the Bank of England had not intervened in the pension crisis, yields would have spiked without bound and the system would have faced outright mass liquidations and literal sovereign default.
“if it was left unchecked you could have had yields just to keep spiking uh and and then you you can get outright kind of mass liquidations and a literal default uh and so that's where Bank of England steps in”
When the Bank of England stopped buying bonds and wanted to tighten, combined with yields below inflation levels and unfunded government tax cuts, the bond market had a 'freak out' because investors worried about increased sovereign bond supply with no clear buyers.
“the bond market had a free freak out they said wait a second this is gonna be inflationary this is going to be the the the supply of these Sovereign bonds is going to increase who's going to buy them all and so there started to be kind of a rapid selling pressure on those bonds”
The Federal Reserve's role in creating the current crisis is structural, not cyclical: by maintaining the zero bound for so long and allowing debt to accumulate unchecked, it eliminated the policy tool (falling rates) that had offset rising debt for four decades, creating a fiscal end-game scenario.
“on the other hand of that that you know the the way that the whole system got so levered in the first place is because of Central Bank intervention you know if you if you didn't have this kind of flexible money standard debts would have never got this High to begin with”
Most years have more volatility in emerging market currencies than developed market currencies, but 2022 has been an exception with emerging markets holding up better because they're being hawkish out of necessity while developed markets are dovish.
“generally what we're seeing is that there's nor in most years you have more volatility in Emerging Market currencies than developed Market currencies this this year has been an exception uh some of the Emerging Market currencies have actually held up pretty well because they're the ones that out of necessity or have to be hawkish”
The UN called on central banks to stop tightening citing financial instability as a reason, and official CPI in the US at 8 percent makes it difficult for the Fed to justify stopping tightening despite the risk.
“it's funny we're starting this in the United Nations of all places called on another central banks to stop tightening uh you know they they could cite uh Financial instability uh as a as a reason um you know there's things that they can do or that the treasury can do uh in order to stop the dollar from going up but all you know they generally have bad Optics when it when official CPI in the United States is eight percent uh and and you know Powell's trying to do his best impersonation of volcker”
OPEC production cuts are intentionally contributing to the energy supply limitation, creating a 'toxic combination' of policy constraints (ESG, windfall taxes), company caution, market price uncertainty, and cartel behavior that together prevent energy supply from increasing despite high prices.
“you have OPEC is is purposely contributing to it and so it's kind of a a toxic combo that's not going to resolve itself until more energy Supply comes online and is is encouraged to come online”
The pound was worth more than 2 dollars in 2006 and has weakened significantly, with the speaker noting that lunch prices went from 25 pounds to 30-40 pounds over the past year as the pound depreciated.
“when I first went to the US it was about 2006 I won't get the year right but I remember it specifically because I got more than two dollars of the pound uh and the pound is now quite weakened I mean I think even think of the start of the year is about 1.38 and I think we're at about what 112”
The biggest question in macro is how much the Fed can tighten before something breaks in the system that forces them to pause or pivot earlier than they would like.
“right now the biggest question in macro is how much can the FED tighten uh in their quest to reign in inflation and will something like that break and force the FED to pause or pivot earlier than they'd like to”
The only developed market central bank that held hawkish stance longer was initially the Fed, but the pressure on the Fed to pivot is building as the Treasury market deteriorates, similar to how the Bank of England was forced to reverse policy within days.
“I decided that the Fed was still holding on the bank of England was still holding Omni that they were able to tighten to some degree but that over time they would start falling like dominoes and have to print into high inflation like like Japan”
The speaker predicted that the Fed would initially hold and that the Bank of England would initially be able to tighten, but that over time both would 'fall like dominoes' and be forced to print into high inflation like Japan and the ECB.
“I decided that the Fed was still holding on the bank of England was still holding Omni that they were able to tighten to some degree but that over time they would start falling like dominoes and have to print into high inflation like like Japan and to some extent like the ECB is doing”
Hyperinflation is not a key part of Lynn's expectation for developed market currencies within any investable 3-5 year time horizon, though all fiat currencies have historically failed given long enough time horizons.
“I don't hyperinflation's not been a key part of my expectation at least in any sort of investable time Horizon right so when you look out long enough you know all Fiat currencies have historically failed um but in any sort of like three to five year time Horizon I've not had hyperinflation uh as as you know any of my calls on on developed Market currencies”
Current treasury market conditions are about as bad as they've been except for March 2020, which was worse, but not fully broken like March 2020 was, and conditions are directionally unhealthy.
“most things are showing that it's about as bad as it's it's gotten except for March 2020 that was worse it's not it's not fully broken like it did then March 2020 in the US looked like what just happened in in the UK basically right uh and so we're not there yet but it is directionally uh you know not looking healthy for the U.S treasury market”
The speaker has been holding dollars for both business and personal purposes to hedge against pound weakness, moving from just managing Bitcoin and pound balance to adding dollar diversification.
“I'm now how I'm now holding dollars so I always used to have to just manage a a balance of Bitcoin and a balance of pounds that's all I ever had to think about but with such a massive drop in the value of the pound over the last year which we you know me and Danny are experiencing now when we come in here and you know we're spending yeah 30 40 on a lunch that used to be 25 pounds it's now close to 30 40 pounds so I'm starting to hold a balance of dollars both for my business and both personally”
Lynn has been describing the current period as entering financial repression scenario for a couple years, and recent policy responses (UK pension bail-outs, yield curve control in Japan) confirm this prediction is being realized.
“uh and you had central banks buying the bonds and so that's the situation I find are I've been describing as as entering anyway for a couple year and we're starting to see that play out now”
Banks have been conservative with lending compared to prior rates both in the US and many other places, with exceptions in some European banks.
“above that kind of minimum threshold we've just not been seeing a ton of Bank lending uh compared to Prior rates Banks generally um in the U.S and many other places have been have been pretty conservative uh with with you know exceptions uh like we see in some well-known European Banks”
The euro, yen, and pound have been the biggest losers among major currencies this year, though excluding basket case currencies like the Turkish lira and Argentine peso.
“some of the biggest losers were the Euro the Yen uh and the pound and of course I'm excluding some of the the truly Basket Case currencies like you know the Turkish lira the Argentine peso”
The CEO of Shell recently said energy companies should be taxed more, which is noteworthy and seems counterintuitive.
“did you see that the CEO of shell came out recently and said that energy companies should be taxed to more I heard something along those lines but I haven't I haven't read into it too deeply”