
Gold, Silver, Uranium, Oil and Energy Trends-Doomberg
What this covers
This is a 32-minute interview in which Lucian of Triangle Investor questions Doomberg, the pseudonymous energy and finance writer, on commodities and the geopolitics behind them. It was recorded on November 4, 2024, and moves through the chapters roughly in order: an energy-sector overview, gold and the BRICS question, financial markets in 2025, nuclear power and AI, natural gas, uranium, oil and OPEC, then copper, silver, rare earths and a closing round of bullish and bearish calls. The tone is opinionated, and many of the claims are explicitly contested.
The gold discussion is among the sharper turns. Doomberg attributes the record prices mainly to the sanctioning of Russian reserves, which pushed central banks to ask whether Western treasuries are really neutral assets. He also reads rising gold as a measure of fiat currency losing value, and he describes the US as printing about a trillion dollars of debt every 90 days while still expecting no default. Silver is treated differently: he says it is turning into an industrial metal and cannot compete with gold as money. On the energy side he returns to the Doomberg Postulate, which holds that every molecule of fossil fuel produced gets burned somewhere. He argues that denying developing nations gasoline and diesel is neither realistic nor ethical, and that oil demand follows supply.
The nuclear and AI segment links Oracle's Malaysia data center investment to cheap stranded gas, with off-grid pods burning gas at the source as a bridge until nuclear arrives. He is bearish on natural gas in the short term. On nuclear he argues that the constraints are political and regulatory rather than technical, that small modular reactors) are useful but not essential, and that uranium mining is not the bottleneck, refining is. He adds that uranium's price barely affects plant operating costs. The last stretch covers OPEC struggling to defend $70 oil, copper never having priced in the green energy transition, and China's processing monopoly in rare earths. He also compares buying commodities to buying the VIX.
Energy markets are currently well-supplied globally with abundant oil, natural gas, and coal, making an energy crisis unlikely in the near term; long-term demand for all fossil fuels will remain strong as developing nations pursue higher living standards, while nuclear and natural gas will power the AI data center revolution.
- Current energy abundance (cheap natural gas, OPEC struggling to defend $70 oil) contradicts crisis narratives and supports recession-resistant growth
- Doomberg Postulate: every molecule of fossil fuel produced will be consumed somewhere, so supply restrictions only relocate consumption rather than eliminate it
- Data centers will consume massive natural gas via off-grid facilities at source locations, absorbing current glut while supporting long-term natural gas demand growth
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Seven billion people in the Global South would gladly consume gasoline-powered cars, jet fuel, and diesel as they ascend Maslow's hierarchy of needs; denying them this privilege is neither realistic nor ethical.
“there's seven billion people in the global South all of whom would be happy to drive gasoline powered cars and to have um you know all of the benefits that come with jet fuel and Diesel um and so we think that um we will continue to grow oil production... a great majority of the world lives a standard of living that those of us who are privileged enough to live in the west would would find unacceptable and and who are we to deny them as they try to ascend maslov's hierarchy of needs”
Oracle's $6 billion investment in Malaysia for data centers is driven by Malaysia being an energy superpower and major natural gas exporter, allowing direct interception of gas at source where it is cheap or trades negative.
“this is why we see Oracle for example investing $6 billion in Malaysia well Malaysia is a energy superpower and a big exporter of natural gas so they're just going to go and intercept that gas at the source um and where it's cheap and abundant and and use it to power U the data centers directly”
The sanctioning of Russian reserves by the US and Europe was the crucial event driving gold to all-time highs, as it forced central banks to reconsider whether Western treasuries and European debt are truly neutral reserve assets, redirecting demand to gold as a neutral reserve asset with no credit risk.
“I would say it was the sanctioning of the Russian reserves um the US uh and European debt you know instruments had previously been sort of neutral Reserve assets um central banks around the world accumulated them with their accesses from trade and it was assumed that um these instruments were money good and when the West um first froze and now seems to be trying to at least partially seize Russia's foreign reserves um this caused many countries to reconsider whether treasuries and you know European debt are in fact neutral and of course they're not neutral they were rightly or wrongly whatever your view on the war the the neutrality of the of these debt instruments was no longer uh apparent to the market whereas gold is itself a neutral Reserve asset that has no credit risk”
Oil will continue to play a major role in coming decades; the notion that 'oil days are coming to an end' is nonsense because human endeavor is a constant struggle against entropy requiring energy to create living standards.
“now that's uh we think that's nonsense um the human endeavor is a constant unrelenting struggle against the forces of entropy you need energy to beat back those forces into impose order I.E to create a standard of living”
Uranium supply is abundant; the main constraint is refined uranium processing, not mining. Nuclear 'waste' is actually unburned fuel with 95% of usable energy remaining if processed through fast breeder reactors.
“they need refined uranium which is different than just uranium there's plenty of uranium in the world in fact all of our quote nuclear waste is just waiting to be recycled into fuel we barely use any of the embodied energy in a uranium fuel Rod today before we take it out um you just have to run it through a fast Bruto reactor and Presto you have 95% of the energy left in that Rod to be harnessed by by the future so we like to say there's no such thing as nuclear waste um it's just a gift to Future Engineers”
Uranium price is largely irrelevant to the cost of operating nuclear power plants; uranium could double or triple and nobody would notice, unlike natural gas which directly impacts operating costs.
“the price of uranium is kind of irrelevant to the cost of running nuclear power plant so it could double or triple from here and and nobody would really notice whereas with natural gas of course it's a direct direct feed”
The Doomberg Postulate: every molecule of fossil fuel produced will be burned by somebody somewhere, and restrictions against such activities merely relocate who gets to enjoy the privilege of consumption.
“we have this phrase that we call doomberg postulate which says that every molecule of fossil fuels produced will be burned by somebody somewhere and and restrictions uh against such activities merely relocate who gets to enjoy the privilege”
Copper prices have never adequately priced in the demand from the green energy transition, suggesting markets disbelieve the transition hype.
“Copper's interesting in that it never really priced in the so-called green energy uh agenda the green energy transition if you look at the price of copper back 20 years show me on that chart where we're going to need way more of the stuff than is currently uh planned to be mined and so it's just not there uh they never really believe the hype”
Nuclear technology development has never been constrained by technical feasibility; rather, the constraints are political and regulatory, making the underlying technology choice almost irrelevant to success.
“there's never really been a technological constraint to the development of nuclear so that the underlying technolog is almost irrelevant what what matters more is the politics and the regulatory regimes in play”
Energy markets globally are very well supplied with abundant natural gas especially in the US, plenty of oil such that OPEC has been struggling to defend the $70 price level, and coal is cheap and abundant.
“the energy markets are very well supplied um there's an abundance of natural gas especially in the US um there's plenty of oil so much so that OPEC has been struggling to defend the $70 price level”
OPEC is struggling to defend the $70 oil price level and has recently decided to push back production cuts by yet another month, maintaining current cuts rather than reducing further, suggesting the cartel's long-term viability is questionable.
“there's plenty of oil so much so that OPEC has been struggling to defend the $70 price level um I noticed with some interest that they recently decided to push back by yet another month their um production Cuts in other words maintain them for another month um and so oil is is sort of artificially High”
The US is printing roughly one trillion dollars of debt every 90 days, which is measured in short-term paper—the same type of instrument that causes emerging market debt crises—yet this unsustainable situation is largely normalized.
“we are printing uh a trillion dollars of debt every 90 days which seems unsustainable much of that debt is denominated in short-term paper which is the stuff of Emerging Market debt crisis it's really amazing that this is what's happening in the United States and we're all just sort of pretending like it's not going to matter”
The US federal government will continue printing money and will not default on debt or deny social security benefits; the $1.2 trillion annual interest payments function as stimulus benefiting debt owners (who are wealthy), which they spend back into the economy.
“we are going to print like they're not going to deny Social Security and they're going to default on the debt and um we're we're paying 1.2 trillion in interest now um which is a form of stimulus for rich people because that's who owns debt and they get all that interest and and they turn around and spend it in in the economy”
Silver is increasingly becoming an industrial metal rather than a monetary one, evidenced by the gold-to-silver ratio exploding to historic highs.
“I think silver uh to the detriment of silver Bulls is becoming more of an industrial metal and less of a monetary one um and this explains why the gold to Silver ratio is exploding So High”
Small modular reactors (SMRs) offer some technological advantages like speed and regulatory certainty if standardized, but they are not strictly necessary; large nuclear reactors are equally viable.
“SMR is an example of a nice technology that is not really needed um big nuclear reactors are just fine too um but there's some advantages to smrs um and and if one of them is you could do it more quickly um with more speed uh with with more regulatory certainty with a few standardized designs then we would be all for it”
The world has decided that gold is the only precious metal that functions as money; silver cannot compete in this role.
“the world has decided that of the precious metals gold is basically the only money”
The overarching trend in all commodities, especially energy, is downward because oil and gas companies act as giant deflationary machines through continuous technological improvement.
“the overarching trend in all Commodities especially well energy Commodities in particular is uh down like the the the oil and gas companies are giant deflationary machines um te technology is always being developed”
Oil demand is determined by supply; if prices fall due to overproduction, people consume more oil, not less, following supply-and-demand mechanics.
“the gating function of demand is is production um the more we you know it if we overproduce and prices go down guess what people will consume it Supply demand and then um if there's a shortage of Supply there'll always be a response by the industry because they're technological superpowers”
The US is running an experiment where the global reserve currency is hyperinflating its value away, measurable by rising gold prices which represent falling fiat currency value rather than rising commodity prices.
“we are running an Amazing Experiment where the global Reserve currency is um is hyper inflating its value away if you just look at the value of gold um we measured in US Dollars well the price of gold is up one another way to say it is that the price of Fiat currencies in the west are down um because gold is really the hardest money”
Rare earth element challenge is not mining but processing pure metals from concentrates, where China holds a literal monopoly, creating serious geopolitical supply chain leverage.
“the challenge with rare Earths is not so much the mining of them but the processing of the concentrates into the pure metals which China has a a literal Monopoly on”
Buying commodities is like buying the VIX: the assets will degrade over time, periodically spike, and trying to time spikes is difficult but fading them after is usually profitable.
“like to say buying Commodities is like buying the vix you know you it'll degrade on you and degrade on you and then every once in a while there's a spike and um you know trying to time those spikes is very difficult much easier to fade them by the way because they're always followed by collapse in price”
Gold as a reserve asset has historically served the role of settling international trade imbalances, and if gold resumes this function, the price must go higher.
“to the extent that gold will reender asset for the settling of of imbalances in international trade then the price must go higher”
During wartime and bubble periods, stocks explode higher and speculation is rampant, with clearly overvalued stocks trading at crazy heights; similar dynamics are observable today.
“if you read back what happened during wear um which we have done and very fascinated by those experiences um you saw that stocks exploded higher speculation was rampant and and we see that today and as we Ken from Bubble to Bubble um Behaviour stocks you know the that that are clearly not worth a fraction of what they're Trading for get bit up uh to Crazy Heights”
Nuclear technology is ideally suited to power the AI Revolution, but natural gas will serve as a crucial bridging fuel, with data centers constructed as self-contained off-grid pods where natural gas is converted directly to electricity without grid connection.
“nuclear technology is ideally suited to our the AI Revolution and moves are being made aggressive moves are being made towards that end however um we believe as a bridging fuel the shocking abundance of natural gas in the US will have to be put to work in this regard and we think what we're going to see are sort of self-contained pods if you will giant buildings where natural gas goes in and data comes out um not connected to the grid”
Lithium and nickel prices are also signaling that the green energy revolution has passed its peak, along with copper and silver.
“same thing that lithium is telling us um nickel to a less extent the sort of green energy revolution has uh has has passed its peak”
The Candú reactor system is one of the most attractive nuclear designs in the world, with successful implementations in Ontario where it powers most of the provincial grid and in other countries.
“the can do reactor system is really one of the most attractive in the world... can do is one option of course the ap1000 is jockeying to be the US uh M of the nuclear Renaissance... Um Ontario runs basically their entire grid off it um other countries have successfully implemented them it's it's very beautiful setup for a variety of reasons”
An unusually warm winter is currently suppressing natural gas prices by reducing heating demand and keeping storage levels high; an average or colder winter would be bullish for natural gas prices.
“the big challenge with natural gas today in the US that ratio would be even lower were it not for the unusually warm winter that we seem to be having once again U there's just so much natural gas here in storage that um if we don't if if if we have an average winter that would be very bullish for natural gas if we have a colder than average winter then we could see that the price of natural gas go up much higher much quicker”
The US has not slipped into recession, which was something Doomberg predicted almost a year ago, and abundant energy is a big part of the reason why.
“all of that is um healthy for the global economy I think this is a big part of the reason why the US has not slipped into a recession which is something we predicted uh almost a year ago now”
The demand for gold in the Middle East, India, and China is sustained because cultures in those regions understand and value gold as wealth preservation, unlike in the West.
“the demand for gold in the Middle East and in India and China um where people cherish they they understand that gold is wealth um you know a wealthy person has excess savings and and if you have excess gold you have excess savings”
Oil production, coal production, and natural gas production will all continue to grow, reaching far higher levels by 2030 and 2040 than today, because demand is infinite at reasonable prices.
“we will continue to grow oil production we will continue to grow coal production we will continue to grow natural gas production um and uh the gating function of demand is is production um the more we you know it if we overproduce and prices go down guess what people will consume it... by 2030 I think we'll be burning way more oil than we burn today and by 2040 we'll be burning more more oil still um there's no shortage of it the demand for it is infinite that reasonable prices”
The easiest trade is to assume that any favorite commodity mooning (spiking in price) will decline at least 50% in the next 6-9 months and position accordingly.
“the easiest trade in the world is is to short you know assume that the price of your favorite commodity that is mooning will be down at least 50% in the next six to nine months and and position yourself accordingly because that almost always happens that way”
Doomberg is bearish on natural gas short-term due to abundance, but bullish medium-term and long-term as the glut gets consumed, with the oil-to-gas ratio expected to shrink from current ~30 toward the natural state of ~6.
“so if I understand correctly you are bearish on natural gas short let's say midterm shortterm um well it's hard not to be bearish shortterm because there just so much of it but we're actually bullish medium-term and long term in fact we think that the oil to gas ratio is going to continue to shrink um the natural state for that ratio is is approximately six there's six times um more energy in a barrel of oil than there is in a in a million BTUs of natural gas um it has traded for as high as 50 recently because of the glut of natural gas it's come back down now U to about 30 and we we think that number will continue to go down”
Big Tech companies (Microsoft, Google, Facebook, Nvidia) know how to execute large projects quickly and have political influence; they will drive nuclear and energy infrastructure development if needed to maintain exponential computing power growth per Moore's Law.
“big Tech knows how to do these types of projects and um one way to model the world is that we will do whatever we have to do to maintain ourselves on uh that cellan exponential growth of computing power curve that he famously wrote about in his book um almost 20 years ago now the singularity is near and um big Tech will make that happen if it if it if it does happen it'll be because of Microsoft Google uh Facebook uh you know Nvidia and so on um coming through in that way and these these companies know how to build large projects quickly so um and they also throw a lot of money at us politicians and so they will get their way”
Personal financial strategy should be: earn income in fiat currency (because the economic system operates in fiat), save by accumulating real assets like gold, and invest privately where you can impact outcomes.
“we like to earn in Fiat of course because we exist in the Fiat world we save by buying real assets gold is one of those and then we invest privately where we can impact the outcome that is our personal financial strategy”
Theoretically, there is so much natural gas in the world that one would not even need nuclear to power data centers, though nuclear would be faster and more carbon-efficient—but this is a political choice in the West.
“there's so much natural gas in the world that in theory you you wouldn't even need nuclear the only difference is it takes longer and it's more expensive to build nuclear today in the west which is a political Choice um but also um if you care about carbon emissions then nuclear is is Superior in that regard”
Gold, silver, land, and Bitcoin are hard assets useful for protection against fiat currency regime collapse, with gold being preferred due to its millennia of track record and high value density.
“gold silver land um you know anything that has value regardless of the F the Fiat currency regime that you happen to be living in of course for some people Bitcoin is is a good option as well um we don't own any Bitcoin but we certainly understand why people especially in Nations that are going through a crisis um would want to accumulate it mostly gold for us um it has worked for thousands of years and um doesn't require much in the way of Technology”
Until small modular reactors (SMRs) are turned on and operating, with real-world experience generated, it is difficult to assess their true viability despite the technology being theoretically attractive.
“until we start seeing them turned on and running and we get the experience that comes with doing that it's difficult to say again SMR is an example of a nice technology that is not really needed um big nuclear reactors are just fine too um but there's some advantages to smrs um and and if one of them is you could do it more quickly um with more speed uh with with more regulatory certainty with a few standardized designs then we would be all for it we shall see”
Doomberg does not predict an imminent energy crisis; the framing of crisis predictions results from misrepresentation via podcast thumbnails when asked counterfactual questions about conditions needed for $200 oil.
“we actually don't think we're heading for an energy crisis one of the things that happens when you go on a podcast is you have no say on how the thumbnail is produced and so you could see you know doomberg predicts $200 oil when in fact we were asked an narrow question of what would have to occur for $200 of barrel oil to manifest”
If Trump wins the election, 'drill baby drill' policy will lead to lower oil prices (bearish for oil), whereas if Harris wins, EPA restrictions will constrain supply and be bullish for oil prices.
“all things being equal we would be uh bearish oil especially if Trump wins by the way Trump wins drill baby drill means lower oil prices which is bad for the uh energy sector really even though 95% of oil industry Executives in the US will probably vote for Trump um uh if Harris wins we actually think that is bearish for supply and bullish for price um because the EPA will act as a restrictor to the industry in a way that imposes discipline on them”
Gold has historically maintained purchasing power over long periods—20 gold eagles today will buy a nice SUV, and in 20 years will still buy a nice SUV—whereas fiat currencies in the West are experiencing depreciation.
“our view is that um 20 Gold Eagles will buy you a nice SUV today and in 20 years it'll still buy you a nice SUV whereas um what happens to the US dollar or the Euro uh is a different issue altogether”
Natural gas at the Henry Hub currently trades at $2.67 per million BTU, equivalent to $15 per barrel oil, and there is such an abundance that data centers will consume it to generate electricity for AI applications.
“natural gas is $267 a million btu at the Henry Hub that is the equivalent of $15 a barrel oil um and there's like so much of it that we don't know what to do with it well what what they're going to do with it is they're going to burn it to create electricity to run data centers”
One ounce of gold is worth $2,700, making it extremely high value density compared to silver, which requires storing 100 times more weight for the same value.
“1 ounce of gold is $2,700 of um we also collect um fine watches and a bit of artwork and things of that nature things that are easy to store um and and tend to appreciate in value over time uh in those markets you have to have a bit of knowledge about what you're buying and the trends in the market and so on but gold you need no such knowledge um silver is useful in in small denominations as well um but it's its value is you know um 1% of gold roughly and so you need to store 100 times more of it for the same value”
The BRICS summit failed to deliver on currency expectations; a BRICS gold-backed currency is a long way off and will take much longer than social media hype cycles suggest.
“I thought the brick Summit was a bit of a disappointment to be honest with you and I think we're a long way from a bricks uh currency that is backed by gold these things just take much longer than the social media hype cycle would have you believe um this is the second bricks meeting in a row that has underwhelmed”
COP28 (the 2023 climate conference) marked the top of ESG and environmental policy momentum; the upcoming COP29 is expected to show a very different sentiment and direction, marking a reversal of green energy transition enthusiasm.
“I think we called cup 28 uh as the top of ESG and uh I think we're going to see a very different top 29 uh coming up here next month um and and time will tell”
Doomberg prefers the Sprott Physical Gold Trust (PHYS) over GLD ETF because it is most clearly backed by actual gold, viewing GLD as a different and less transparent instrument.
“when we you um purchase gold in our brokerage accounts we tend to use the Sprat uh physical gold trust because it is the one that is most clearly backed by by uh by gold in our view GLD is is is a different instrument altogether but we prefer Fizz and um and solid physical gold in our hand”
The market is never wrong; it is always teaching you something about the underlying conditions.
“we we we never think the market is wrong the market is just always teaching you something”
An energy crisis is unlikely; the only real potential for an energy crisis would involve catastrophic escalation in the Middle East, and there is not much people can do to prepare for that.
“we don't see a crisis on the horizon we just went through one um we went through one in Europe of course which spread to the world... I think the only real potential for an energy crisis would involve a catastrophic escalation in the Middle East and there's not much people can do to prepare for that”
Doomberg reduced gold holdings because gold had appreciated to the point where it became too large a component of their savings assets, but they remain long gold and view the current rally as sustainable though potentially prone to pullbacks rather than indefinite continuation.
“Commodities that that Spike like this grind higher day after day they they tend not to continue to do that indefinitely uh so we would be cautious gold but not so cautious that we're selling all of what we own”
Lucian serves as the host and primary interviewer throughout the conversation, introducing himself as triangle investor from social media and framing all major questions.
“I'm your host Lucian some of you know me as triangle investor from social medias today I'm joined by most famous green chicken in the in the world the author of widely followed energy subc one and only doomberg”
Trading natural gas is like trading silver—it is a 'devil's trade' that is very difficult to execute successfully.
“trading natural gas is like trading silver you know it's a devil's trade it's very difficult to trade natural gas”
Doomberg finds it difficult to time stock markets because they don't participate in them and lack the feel for market behavior, so timing predictions are not a core competency.
“it's difficult for us to to time markets um since we don't participate in them we don't have a feel for them um it's not something that we're skilled at”
Doomberg's work can be found at doomberg.com, and paid subscribers get direct responses to comments from the authors, making paid subscription the best way to receive attention.
“you can find all of our work at doomberg tocom that's the easiest way to reach out to us um whenever we publish a piece our comments are to paid subscribers only which means i' personally go in and reply to virtually every comment that is in there so that's actually the best way to get um more of our time is by simply participating in the comment section”
Doomberg owns few silver coins and none of the silver ETF (SLV) or silver mining stocks; the factors determining silver prices are supply-demand balances in the solar market, making it essentially a commodity index tied to solar deployment expectations.
“we don't own much in the way of silver a few coins here and there um in my safe but nothing to be you know get too excited about um yeah and I and we own no um SLV for example or any of the silver mining stocks um not that we would but it's just the factors that are determining the price of silver um are all about Supply demand balances in the Solar Market basically today”
Doomberg has done extensive research into historical war economies and their patterns of stock market behavior, comparing them to current market dynamics as analogies for understanding present valuations.
“if you read back what happened during wear um which we have done and very fascinated by those experiences”