
China: What's behind the disappearance of more and more top Chinese officials? | DW News
What this covers
This DW News segment pairs anchor Melissa Chan with Asia analyst Clifford Coonan. It starts from a rare trilateral meeting in Seoul of Japanese, Chinese and South Korean leaders, the first of its kind since 2019, and then asks about the string of senior Chinese officials who have vanished from view over the summer. Those named are Foreign Minister Qingang in June, rocket force commander Li Yuchao, and Defense Minister Li Shangfu in September. Chan notes the rocket force's role in any Taiwan scenario. She also frames the episodes as ambiguous: they could signal instability around Xi or show his power to remove anyone at will. U.S. ambassador Emmanuel Berman is cited as comparing the disappearances to an Agatha Christie novel.
Coonan's explanations lean on history and political culture. He describes the party as a classical Marxist-Leninist Communist party, a label he presents as a definition and one that is contestable. He says it behaves like the Soviet Union under Stalin, and that Xi, whose father Xi Zhongxun was purged during the Cultural Revolution, finds all this normal. He lists the functions a purge serves, from keeping subordinates in their place to removing rivals. He reads the tech crackdown on Jack Ma and Alibaba as the same impulse applied to new centers of power. He also says rumors point to more military removals, and that the cycle still has "a way to go."
The second thread is regional. Coonan says North Korea drives the Seoul meeting, with both Seoul and Tokyo hoping Beijing will rein it in. All three countries count China as their biggest trading partner, and he cites China's economic coercion against South Korea in 2017 and against Japan. He also discusses Japan's difficulty at being displaced as Asia's leading power. Diplomats, he says, read China's outreach as a response to alarm over the Camp David summit and growing U.S. closeness with Tokyo and Seoul.
Xi Jinping's recent purges of high-level officials in the military, foreign ministry, and tech sector represent a deliberate consolidation of power following the Marxist-Leninist communist party model, driven by perceived threats from U.S.-led regional realignment and economic instability rather than weakness.
- Xi's purges mirror classical communist party behavior patterns seen in Stalin's USSR, reflecting his own upbringing during China's Cultural Revolution
- The disappearances of Qingang, Li Yuchao, and Li Shangfu correspond to Xi's three simultaneous power bases: Party boss, president, and military commission head
- China's diplomatic engagement with Japan and South Korea follows the Camp David summit alarm, suggesting Xi feels pressure from U.S.-led regional containment that requires domestic power consolidation
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Xi Jinping grew up during China's Cultural Revolution, when his own father Xi Zhongxun was purged and sent away, meaning Xi was socialized into a political culture where purges are a normal and familiar mechanism of power consolidation.
“Xi Jinping grew up with these purges his own father XI jong-sun was uh was uh purged and he was also sent away during the cultural revolution he grew up in this kind of culture so for him this is a way of consolidating his power”
The Chinese Communist Party functions as a classical Marxist-Leninist communist party, not as a Western political party, and exhibits behavior patterns consistent with historical communist regimes such as the Soviet Union under Stalin, including the use of purges as a consolidation mechanism.
“we've become used to dealing with China and dealing with the Commerce party as if it's like a western political party but in fact it's a classical Marxist leninist Communist party which acts very much in the same way as communist parties have behaved uh over the last hundred years we saw it in Russia in Soviet Russia we had um with Stalin and his purges they happened in they've happened in in nearly every communist Society”
North Korea is a major factor driving the trilateral meeting, with South Korea hoping China can use its influence to moderate North Korea, and Japan also hoping for Chinese intervention regarding North Korean threats.
“North Korea is a big factor in why the three of these are meeting it will be because um South Korea will be hoping that China can use its influence there and and Japan will also be hoping that China can do something about that”
China has used economic coercion to exert political pressure on neighboring countries and major regional players including Japan and South Korea, exemplified by China's response to the U.S. installation of a missile system in South Korea in 2017 and repeated instances of economic pressure on Japan.
“a lot of the debate recently has been about economic coercion about China using economic coercion to exert political pressure on on neighboring countries and on its other major regional players including Japan and South Korea in 2017 when the U.S installed a missile system there uh China responded with with economic coercion on several occasions over the years it's done the same thing to Japan”
Each of the three countries—Japan, South Korea, and China—has China as their biggest trading partner, creating an economic interdependence that must be reconciled with political security interests.
“the crazy thing uh in all of this is that each of these countries including the United States their biggest trading partner is China so you have this economic angle”
The rocket force commander position oversees land-based missile and nuclear defense capabilities, was massively upgraded as a priority project by Xi Jinping in 2016, and would play a key role in any Taiwan invasion scenario.
“this Elite pla unit which oversees land-based missile defense was massively upgraded as a pet project of she himself in 2016. the rocket force would play a key role in any Taiwan Invasion scenario”
China's economic rise has resulted in Japan being pushed from its historical position as the top economic and geopolitical power in Asia into second place regionally and third place globally, creating difficulty for Japan in managing this power transition.
“China's rise has been remarkable Japan was always Top Dog in Asia Suddenly It's it's been pushed into second place in Asia into third place in the global among the global economies it's it's it's having to deal with the rising China and it's causing a lot of difficulty”
Xi Jinping has conducted multiple purges of high-level military officials beyond the recent three (Qingang, Li Yuchao, Li Shangfu), repeatedly moving generals around since assuming power in 2012 as part of a systematic effort to maintain control.
“he's done this several times since he came to power in 2012... we're seeing that it's definitely impacting on how the Army is behaving... there's a lot of issues that the Army is dealing with... quite a number of high-level military officials have been taken off their posts and disappeared”
Multiple high-level Chinese officials have disappeared from their posts during summer 2023, including Foreign Minister Qingang (June), rocket force commander Li Yuchao (unclear exact timing but after June), and Defense Minister Li Shangfu (September), representing unprecedented volatility in Chinese high-level politics.
“in June just three months after she unveiled his cabinet at the annual National people's Congress his one-time Ally foreign minister qingang suddenly disappeared... next to go was the commander of the people's Liberation Army rocket Force Lee Yu Chao... then in September another of shi's protege the defense minister Lee Xiang Fu also disappeared”
The crackdown on China's tech sector, including the removal of Jack Ma and restrictions on Alibaba, represents a form of purge within the classical communist model, demonstrating Xi's assertion of authority across all sectors of society where new power centers have emerged.
“if you look at the economy because um isn't in some ways the dealing with Jack Ma and with Alibaba a form of purge or the way the broader Crackdown on the on the tech sector these are also so kind of purges within this classical communist model because it's a way of asserting Authority and a way of showing that he's um that he's he's Top Dog in all areas of society the tech sector wasn't a big issue in the in the in the stalinist era but now it's become one of the main bedrocks of support for Xi Jinping and China”
Purges in the classical communist model are not a 20th-century phenomenon but continue in the 21st century as demonstrated by contemporary events, contrary to assumptions that purges are obsolete.
“we think of purges as something from the 20th century but uh it can't happen in the 21st century but it is right before our eyes”
For Xi Jinping, purges serve multiple functions: consolidating power, making sure subordinates know their place in the hierarchy, removing potential rivals, and possibly reflecting perceived threats to his position.
“for him this is a way of consolidating his power of um of making sure that knows their place um also maybe getting rid of Rivals and um then there's also an element which we've also known from history that maybe it is not into paranoia there maybe he's seeing threats now maybe in some ways that is a sign of weakness but as far as he's concerned and this is a way of making sure that Xi Jinping is number one and that he's at the center of power and that he's the center of decision making”
Xi's purges of military officials serve to establish his personal control over the military on a firmer footing, by keeping generals on alert, moving them around, and ensuring he remains the top decision-maker on critical military matters like Taiwan invasion preparation and naval development.
“I think what this does is it establishes power base within the Army on what he sees as more as a firmer footing he's keeping the generals on their toes he's moving them around... we're seeing that it's definitely impacting on how the Army is behaving... such as a possible invasion of Taiwan he wants to make she wants to make sure that he's the the top dog when it comes to issues like preparing for that sort of situation”
The Camp David summit between the U.S., Japan, and South Korea triggered alarm in Beijing, because Camp David has significant resonance in diplomatic history and China interpreted the meeting as a security and trade coalition aimed at addressing concerns China worries about.
“the meeting in Camp David really said alarm bells ringing in in Beijing Camp David has a huge resonance uh and Beijing studies its history this is a very important place in diplomatic history in the U.S so I think when they saw that two key Regional players like South Korea and Japan were meeting the US and uh that they were discussing security concerns and trade issues and all these kind of issues that China really worries about I think is definitely woke China up to the need that it needs to start doing stuff about its neighbors”
What appears strange to Western observers is normal and consistent with Xi's entire political socialization and experience of communist party governance.
“so what looks strange to us is pretty normal for him in terms of how he might deal with conflict it's all he's ever known”
China's economic coercion has made Japan realize how dependent it has become on the Chinese economy, creating vulnerability to political pressure.
“made Japan realize just how dependent it's become on on the economy”
The disappearance of Qingang, foreign minister with high international visibility as former ambassador to Washington, signals to the international diplomatic community that significant changes are happening in China's leadership and power structure.
“The Disappearance of qingang is very interesting because that shows how the foreign Ministry is you know how it's uh he's someone who's well known overseas um he was the ambassador to Washington um he's and I think his disappearance certainly has people scratching their heads”
The international diplomatic community interprets the purges and disappearances as signs that Xi Jinping is responding to and feeling pressure from the U.S.'s growing influence in Asia, particularly through its increasing closeness with Japan and South Korea.
“it's being read as a sign that in some ways uh he's feeling the impact of the US's growing influence in Asia as we've seen through its glowing growing closeness with with Japan and Korea”
Multiple signs of volatility in high-level Chinese politics, including official disappearances, can be read as signs of instability in Xi Jinping's leadership or alternatively as evidence of Xi's absolute power to remove officials at will.
“while the public displays speak to power such growing signs of unusual volatility in the high ranks of Chinese politics can be seen as a sign of instability in xi's leadership”
China has 14 land borders and 8 sea borders, giving it difficult relations with many neighbors, but Japan and South Korea are of key importance, prompting China to initiate diplomatic engagement with these two countries.
“it's a country with 14 land borders and eight sea borders and it has difficult relations with a lot of its neighbors but these two South Korea and Japan are key of key importance so China is starting this diplomatic process”
There are rumors that Xi Jinping will disappear more people in the military in the near future, suggesting he is not finished with consolidating control and may be preparing for more assertive actions regarding Taiwan or the South China Sea.
“there's lots of rumors at the moment that there's more to come in the army that he's going to further embed his power in the Army again suggesting that maybe something is happening on Taiwan or something is happening on the South China Sea certainly that there's going to be more assertiveness by China so I don't think he's finished yet”
According to historical patterns of communist leadership, there is still 'a way to go' in Xi's purge cycle, suggesting additional purges and consolidation are expected.
“going on the previous classical models there's still a way to go”
Senior leaders from Japan, China, and South Korea met in Seoul for a rare trilateral meeting, with the last similar meeting occurring before the pandemic in 2019.
“senior leaders from Japan China and South Korea met in Seoul for a rare trilateral the last time a similar meeting took place was before the pandemic in 2019”
U.S. ambassador to Japan Emmanuel Berman tweeted that the multiple disappearances in Xi's cabinet resemble an 'Agatha Christie novel,' demonstrating that the international diplomatic community is actively monitoring and puzzled by these events.
“we had uh Emmanuel Ram the U.S ambassador to Japan who was tweeting that saying that this is like an Agatha Christie novel that there's so many people disappearing in XI jinping's cabinet”
Xi Jinping holds three simultaneous formal positions: head of the Chinese Communist Party, President, and head of the Central Military Commission, which gives him unprecedented power concentration.
“he has three jobs he's head of the Communist Party he's the president and he's head of the Army and the central military commission”
Foreign Minister Qingang was reportedly dismissed because he had an extramarital affair and a love child with a Chinese TV journalist while serving as Beijing's ambassador to Washington, and has not been seen since his disappearance.
“he was reportedly jettisoned because he'd had an extra marital Affair and a love child with a Chinese TV journalist during his time as beijing's ambassador to Washington he's not been seen since”
Leadership positions become more paranoid as they hold onto power year after year, reflecting psychological changes in how leaders perceive threats and consolidate control.
“with these leadership things they get more paranoid as they hold on to power uh year after year”
The three countries of Japan, China, and South Korea collectively account for 20 percent of the world's population and 25 percent of global GDP.
“the three countries collectively account for 20 percent of the world's population and 25 percent of global GDP”
At the beginning of Xi Jinping's leadership, foreign affairs experts in Beijing were absolutely terrified of China, and the situation is even more serious now given economic slowdown and anti-China sentiment.
“at the beginning of XI jinping's leadership and the Foreign Affairs experts there were absolutely terrified of China they were very very worried I can only imagine that things are uh even more serious now”