
The Astronomical Rise of Gold (w/ Frank Giustra and Grant Williams)
What this covers
This is a conversation between Grant Williams and Frank Giustra, who founded Gold Corp and has since built a range of mining, metals, and oil and gas companies. It follows two threads. One is how he selects deals and what signals he watches for. The other is his reading of the monetary backdrop that makes those deals attractive. He points to his own record, having argued for a new gold bull market in papers from 2001 and 2003, when gold traded around $250 and few agreed with him.
The macro section covers a lot of ground. He describes a global currency war of debasement in which every government weakens its money at once, so relative values stay put while purchasing power erodes everywhere. He says the Federal Reserve cannot normalize rates on roughly $20 trillion of federal debt, putting the cost at $800-900 billion a year, and that recessions have become politically unacceptable. He calls the period since 2008 the greatest wealth transfer in history, and links it to public anger and radical politics. Several of these claims are contested, including his attack on financial media as promoting Wall Street's narratives. He also says portfolio theory has lost touch with reality. He cannot name where or when a crisis will begin (the US, Europe, or China), so he recommends geographic and asset-class diversification.
The sector discussion is more practical. Giustra explains why paper gold moved into physical metal during the 2011-2016 bear market, with much of it going to China. He notes that China produces the most gold, exports none, and still imports more. He credits miners with real cost discipline, tracked through all-in sustaining costs (AISC)), and stresses reserve replacement. He prefers projects with defined economics over greenfield exploration, which he calls "one in a thousand shots." He notes that junior explorers were starved of capital, and he weighs political risk by jurisdiction, treating Africa as too varied to judge as a single market. He also expects miners to avoid heavy hedging in the next bull market, because gold investors read hedging as a lack of conviction.
Giustra argues that global monetary systems are in an irreversible debt trap with zero interest rates, making gold the essential hedge as a collapse—financial or political—becomes inevitable when authorities can no longer contain the consequences of structural dysfunction.
- Central banks cannot raise rates because federal debt service would become unsustainable; the system is trapped in zero rates globally
- The greatest wealth transfer in history is occurring unnoticed, creating political instability and rage that will manifest in radical politics or financial collapse
- Gold ownership signals lack of confidence in the system and is therefore suppressed by policymakers, making it undervalued despite being the only rational hedge in an era of currency debasement
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The best investors can do to protect themselves is maintain geographic and asset class diversification, as the timing and specific form of collapse cannot be predicted but its occurrence is certain.
“so i think investors need to be cognizant of that and just plan accordingly and to plan accordingly you should be diversified geographically you should be diversified across all asset classes and that's all you can do and the rest you just you know you just pray and hope for the best because you'll never know the timing and you'll never know the event um it's and it will affect different asset classes in different ways for different periods of time but at the end of the day you know um just you know you just got to be diversified”
The period from 2008 onward represents the greatest transfer of wealth in the history of the world, which has gone largely unnoticed by the general population, manifesting only as a feeling of impoverishment and growing anger that fuels radical political movements.
“what you're witnessing now when you've been witnessing the last number of years is the greatest transfer of wealth in the history of the world and no one's even noticed no one's noticed how it's happened all they're noticing are the effects they're feeling poorer the population and what you're seeing in terms of politics in europe and in the us today that's a manifestation of that anger that people feel something's wrong i feel a lot poorer or i'm out of a job and all these rich people are getting richer and richer the wealth gap is growing like crazy”
Investors typically cannot identify absolute market tops and bottoms because markets become 'frothier' at tops and 'worse' at bottoms than most expect, leading to systematic errors in timing entries and exits.
“i think one of the mistakes most investors make is that they can't see the absolute tops and they can't see the absolute bottoms because things get a lot frothier than you ever expect and they become a lot worse than you ever expect”
A large liquidation of paper gold into physical gold occurred during the 2011-2016 bear market as investors de-risked from commodity exposure and rotated into equities; this physical gold primarily flowed to China.
“there was a huge liquidation of paper gold into physical gold and guess where that went yeah to china and so i watched all this happen”
China is the world's largest gold producer, does not export any gold, and imports additional gold—a behavior pattern that reveals Chinese policymakers do not trust fiat currency and prefer accumulating physical gold as an alternative monetary store of value.
“even if you look at china which has been the biggest buyer i mean they're not very transparent no you don't really know how much gold they're buying all i do know is that they're the world's number one producer and they don't export any gold and they import gold it's got to tell you something yeah okay and they have been influenced and they have been several years you know and these are very conservative very industrious people you know and i think they're a lot smarter than you know the rest of the more advanced you know societies you know right now we're i think i'm being completely foolish now we're betting on paper that the world is run by paper and this paper is becoming worthless and we're making it more worthless every day and we still have faith in all this paper industry i think the chinese are looking at and going on i don't trust this paper i want to own the physical stuff that is a currency”
Zero interest rates and negative interest rates globally have created perverse incentives that promote bad behavior and debt accumulation, as governments and corporations have no penalty for leverage and can borrow indefinitely at zero cost.
“it's piling on debt because we have a global zero interest rate environment and negative interest rate environment in a lot of countries now and that just promotes bad behavior so they everybody keeps thinking well you know we're fine now we can keep doing what we're doing we don't have to fix anything”
Gold investors should focus on identifying mining companies with low all-in sustaining costs and strong reserve replacement capabilities, as these factors determine profitability and leverage to gold price increases.
“it depends what you believe if you believe there are certain stocks you would play if you believe gold's going a lot higher but have risk of gold goes lower because they're more highly levered to the gold price i think beric was one of those examples um and there are others that that you know are provide more safety because their costs of production are much lower and so you just have to be careful about the cost of production and the ability to replace islands”
Geographical risk is an increasingly important factor in mining investments, and investors must carefully evaluate political stability and regulatory risk in different jurisdictions.
“there are others that that you know are provide more safety because their costs of production are much lower and so you just have to be careful about the cost of production and the ability to replace islands um and those are the two main things obviously geographical yeah risk which is important in today's world really important”
Africa is too heterogeneous to evaluate as a single investment opportunity; some African countries offer excellent mining opportunities while others are completely uninvestable due to political risk and instability.
“africa is a very big place but people but people boil it down to africa i'm not i'm not touching africa they don't look at the individuals that's crazy no i i took a lot of great places in africa there are a lot of really bad places in africa you should never go near”
Junior mining companies historically drive most exploration activity and reserve discovery, but many juniors lacked capital market access during the 2011-2016 bear market, eliminating the primary source of new deposit discovery.
“traditionally that's where most of the exploration comes from is the juniors so that was gone and the majors were all cutting back on their budgets so they stopped exploring”
Giustra prefers to invest in mining projects with defined existing economics that can be improved through development, rather than pure greenfield exploration plays, because greenfield projects are 'one in a thousand shots' with poor odds.
“for me i prefer to find assets that i can get my head around in terms of the existing economics may it may require some more work to get it to feasibility or financiability as a project but at least i can define it and go okay this is the the parameters the here's the grade here the economics this is if i do this this and that i can create a goal producer with this kind of value and that's where i think you're going to find the most exciting opportunities in this next cycle because no one's been doing a lot of that for a lot of years now the expiration that the greenfield exploration stuff is always going to be interesting but those are one in a thousand shots”
Governments everywhere are engaged in a currency war of debasement, where each is trying to weaken its currency relative to others through negative rates and money printing, but this is ultimately self-defeating because everyone doing the same thing means the relative debasement is zero while absolute purchasing power erosion is universal.
“they're all on this path of debasing their currencies you know everybody's trying to it's a it's a currency war of sorts all over the world um you know negative interest rates the printing of money no fiscal no fiscal discipline no aggregate demand there's no real growth in the world right now it's not coming from anywhere”
Gold was trading at $250 in 2001 when Giustra first made his bull case for gold; he wrote papers in 2001 and 2003 calling for the next major bull market in gold when no one believed it.
“i made the call on gold and i wrote a couple of papers on the subject of gold in the us dollar and i published those papers um one in 2001 one 2003 and basically calling for the next bull market in gold and at that point gold was trading at 250 and no one believed it”
Gold mining companies have dramatically improved their cost discipline over the past 5-6 years of the bear market, with all-in sustaining costs falling to reasonable levels, creating a much more disciplined industry than existed during prior bull markets.
“the gold mining industry had to get a lot of discipline yeah because they didn't have the discipline because it was a bull market in a bear market everybody started looking at their costs and um i've seen a tremendous change in all in adjusted sustainable costs uh for for mining per ounce that have gotten down to reasonable levels now they were really high”
The combination of aggressive QE (quantitative easing) and zero interest rates created a massive bull market in equities and other risk assets, causing investors to view gold as unattractive and demand elimination of perceived risk from the system.
“there was you know there was a movement here in north america to get out of gold and get back into the markets with all that qe all that printing of money caused this huge bull market in the you know in the s p in most stocks and uh and gold was deemed to be you know unattractive you know because the good times were back we eliminated all of the risk and all of the problems that um that happened that led us to the 2008 crisis or so people thought”
The Federal Reserve cannot raise interest rates because normalizing rates on $20 trillion in federal debt would require approximately $800-900 billion per year just to service the debt, which would bankrupt the government.
“the federal debt you got a federal debt that's closing in on 20 trillion dollars that has to be serviced and when you have zero interest rates you can service it okay you normalize rates i did the math once normalizing rates on 20 trillion dollars in debt it's it it would be about eight nine eight or nine hundred billion dollars a year just to service that it would bankrupt the government”
The period since 2008 has seen governments and central banks apply increasingly aggressive monetary interventions without fixing underlying structural problems in the economy, creating conditions worse than 2008 and guaranteeing eventual collapse.
“they haven't fixed a damn thing since 2008 they've just made it worse so they've done nothing to fix things structurally they're in a inescapable trap right now of zero interest rates which has become a global phenomenon and i don't know how you get out of it i just don't know how what how the math is ever going to work that they're going to ever unwind this”
Modern society has created a norm where recessions are politically unacceptable and not allowed to occur, forcing policymakers into permanent monetary stimulus even at the cost of structural problems.
“we've gotten into this world now where recessions are not allowed that's right forever you had recessions now you know the idea of a recession is you know it's just it's just not on”
Portfolio management theory has become disconnected from reality in the current zero-interest-rate, global-QE environment, and traditional portfolio allocations are dangerous because they assume normalization that will never occur.
“the idea that you can run a portfolio in the traditional manner is is in in this environment is ludicrous we're in an environment that's completely uncharted we've never seen what we're seeing today at a global scale it's never happens happen to individual countries we're seeing aspects today of what's happened in his throughout history in individual countries but at a global level what's happening now is unprecedented no one has ever charted these waters and and they're trying to apply traditional portfolio management theory into an environment where it doesn't make any sense”
Gold short-term prices are extremely volatile and impossible for Giustra to predict accurately, so he avoids making short-term forecasts and relies instead on longer-term structural positioning.
“i can honestly i've never ever tried to predict gold short term because the thing about gold is that it's extremely volatile yeah it will what i predict it will do this a lot of this and there will be moments in time where you think oh it's not going to happen and it's always traded this way or this way it doesn't do this and that that just doesn't happen with gold it's very volatile”
Gold was removed from traditional portfolio allocations over the past decades despite historical norms of maintaining 5-10% portfolio allocation to gold for diversification and risk management.
“it used to be standard in the old days of portfolio management that five or ten percent of your portfolio was in gold that went out the window years ago and now it's like you know gold is a relic this and that and everybody all the policy makers try to play it down that is unimportant”
A financial crisis will eventually emerge from an unexpected location (US, Europe, or China) that will surprise everyone, as the system has been set up for this eventuality but the specific trigger is unforeseeable.
“or are you going to see another collapse of some financial institution somewhere and it who knows where that's going to be the u.s europe china it can happen it can come out of nowhere and it's going to surprise everybody everybody's going to go oh my god how did that happen it's been happy like we have set ourselves up for that eventuality and it's going to happen i don't know if it's going to happen tomorrow 10 years from now but it's going to happen”
Mining companies will likely not adopt major hedging strategies during the next gold bull market because gold investors specifically do not want to see hedging, as it signals that company management lacks conviction in gold prices, and this creates an investor preference that constrains mining company options.
“and so the the managers of these companies are aware of that they know that and i've had these conversations on several boards i sit on is like you know you can't hedge because you've had you're just telling the market you don't believe in the gold price uh so they're going to be very careful not to”
Gold peaked at $1,900 after the 2008 financial crisis, then retreated to nearly $1,000, but despite this 50% pullback, all the structural reasons that drove gold to $1,900 remained and had actually worsened, making the price decline economically illogical given unchanged or deteriorated fundamentals.
“i've been saying all along that all the reasons that gold went to 1900 in the first place after the 08 crash are still there there were you know gold retreated back down to close to a thousand but i couldn't figure what the reason was for that 50 percent pullback uh because not only are all the reasons that gold went up to 1900 still there they've gotten worse they've gotten way worse”
Financial media talking heads are trained and incentivized to promote certain narratives and investment ideas in service of Wall Street's business model rather than client interests, and most investors are 'bamboozled' by their propaganda.
“a lot of us get bamboozled by all these talking heads on the likes of all these investment news channels these people that are trained like monkeys to say certain things and promote certain ideas and that's all they know or that's all they're allowed to say or whatever the situation is”
There is no mathematically viable path to unwind the current debt and monetary system without causing a depression, but governments refuse to accept this necessary restructuring and instead perpetually delay correction.
“i can't see a way to unwind the mess that this world is in right now to unwind it in a way that doesn't cause some kind of a collapse and no one wants to see a collapse”
Japan followed the same zero interest rate policy as the Fed because it too is unable to sustain normalized rates on its massive debt load, demonstrating that monetary policy is being driven by debt servicing constraints rather than economic conditions.
“certainly japan is a similar situation that's why they've had zero interest rates forever and ever because they can't they'd bankrupt the country”
An investor buying 30-year bonds at near-zero percent interest rates is making an insane bet that interest rates will remain at zero or go negative for three decades, and this reflects the extent to which the system is distorted by central bank policy to the point of obvious irrationality.
“it's you know safe to buy you know 30-year bonds at you know almost zero percent it's it's insanity”
Despite reported economic growth, there is actually no real GDP growth occurring in the global economy and growth is purely monetary (from credit expansion) rather than genuine productivity improvement.
“no fiscal no fiscal discipline no aggregate demand there's no real growth in the world right now it's not coming from anywhere”
Policymakers deliberately downplay and suppress gold ownership because widespread gold accumulation signals a loss of confidence in the monetary system, which is fragile and cannot tolerate visible confidence collapse.
“they'll make whatever because they don't want you to own it because if you own it and you drive it up in price it tells you that you have no confidence in the system and that's in it at a time when the system is so fragile as it is now where in any accident can cause a complete collapse you don't you you got to inspire confidence”
Wall Street has no interest in promoting gold as an investment because the gold market is too small to generate the billions of dollars in profits that Wall Street makes from complex securities and traditional portfolio management.
“wall street's certainly not in that game they don't make a lot of money if if all you if you said to wall street okay you can only play gold in the commodities because everything else is going to be shipped for a while sorry but um they're you know that's this is not a big enough market they can't make the billions of dollars that they make in you know all of these fancy um securities that they create and all these investment ideas they come up with”
Goldman Sachs' aggressive 2014 call for gold to fall below $1,000 per ounce was a buy signal because when major financial institutions make such conviction-driven bearish calls on an asset, they are usually promoting a position rather than expressing genuine conviction.
“i remember what what really brought it home for me a couple years ago is when goldman sachs came out with their 850 calls no they said this the gold's going below a thousand it's gonna and they were screaming this at the top of their lungs this analyst called uh jeffrey curry and he kept saying gold's going to a thousand he gave all his reasons you know that you know all the problems had been fixed the economy was going to pick up hiring was going to start blah blah blah and i believe none of it i thought okay they're being very aggressive here it reminded me of when a few years prior to that when oil was trading 150 and they called to go to 250 a barrel and it went straight down to 75 from there and i thought you know whenever goldman sachs is that shouting you know the top of their lungs and is that convinced about something you got to be suspect they must have something going on there that they need to promote this this idea and so i i took that as my buy signal”
In March 2016, when the Fed signaled it would not raise rates that quarter, gold began a significant rally, confirming Giustra's thesis that the market's belief in the Fed's structural inability to raise rates is the critical trigger for gold's move higher.
“the real buy signal came in march and i was sitting on vacation i was on spring vacation with my children um and some were very warm and my phone rang and it's this very famous investor very well-known investor and he said to me gold's going to go for a run and i know you're the gold guy and so what do we do about it and i said well i first of all i agree with you and that day was the day that the fed decided they weren't going to raise rates and that was when the market finally started to believe it and that's when gold started this move”
Many mining company executives view gold as just another commodity with no monetary significance, rather than as a hedge asset or monetary reserve, which is a fundamental misunderstanding of gold's role and represents lost opportunities for mining companies to leverage gold's unique status.
“when i spend time at these conferences and around guys like you that really know the industry inside and out and i'm always struck when i speak to guys that run these companies sometimes to them it's just a commodity gold is another commodity it's it's not a monetary asset it's not any kind of hedge to it's just what they pull out the ground and they sell a profit”
Gold will eventually spike to a 'parabolic' level when a triggering event—such as loss of confidence in fiat currency, a financial institution collapse, or geopolitical crisis—occurs, similar to the gold spike to $850 in 1980 during the late 1970s bull market.
“one of these days some event one event will happen and i don't know what that event will be it can be loss of confidence it can be a financial disaster with an institution it can be a geopolitical event but some event is going to take gold up to some crazy number and it'll go parabolic and and that's happened before it's not like it hasn't happened happened in the late 70s in 1980”
When the Berlin Wall fell in 1989, Giustra recognized an opportunity to help governments in newly opening markets change their mining laws to attract foreign investment, which became a core business for Yorktown Securities.
“when the berlin wall fell we recognized it was an opportunity that the world was going to open up in terms of investment investment opportunities in the mining in the mining sector and so we went out and promoted our abilities to help governments change their mining laws so that we could bring an investment and we created a great business doing that”
The resource sector bear market finally turned around approximately six months before the 2016 interview, and Giustra had been sensing since late 2015 that this reversal would occur.
“and we went into a bear market in the commodity sector and...the resource market six months ago so late last year i had the sense that this was going to happen especially only with respect to gold”
Most smart resource sector investors have intuition and gut feel for market timing that cannot be taught; this common sense allows them to see through propaganda from talking heads and perceive reality more clearly.
“whenever i speak to particularly in the resource sector successful smart investors they always have that intuition that gut feel and it's really something that you you either have you can't teach it to someone”
The film industry (Lionsgate) differs fundamentally from the mining business in its capital dynamics, with Giustra eventually choosing to transition from entertainment to mining because the mining opportunity set was better and aligned with his market timing insights about commodity cycles.
“and ran that for six years until 2003 i ran it for three years and then stayed on as chairman for another three years until 2003 but in 2001 is when i made the the call that changed my life which was the call on gold”
Giustra serves on the board of Endeavor Mining, which operates successfully across five West African countries despite challenges, demonstrating that well-managed operations can navigate African political risk.
“i'm on the board of endeavor mining endeavor mining is one of the largest producers in west africa they operate in uh uh five countries and uh have mines in five countries operating mines and um you know it's we've been at it for what eight years now you know there are challenges but you know we mine the gold we sell the gold we make money um and we haven't had any real issues that have ever affected us in an important way”
Giustra created Wheaton River in 2001 to acquire and build a gold mining company through M&A activity, which eventually became Goldcorp, a very successful deal that established his pattern of creating multiple mining companies across different metals and oil/gas during the commodity boom through the 2000s.
“the first one was wheaton river which we created in 2001 which was my idea i brought in the intel for to run it and we raised a bunch of money and went out to build a gold mining company by way of acquisition through m a activity and that became gold goldcorp um very successful deal”
Giustra made a public bet with the Global Mail newspaper that if the gold bull market was over and he was wrong, he would dress in women's underwear and sing Patsy Cline's 'I Was So Wrong' in Robson Square in Vancouver, as a statement of confidence that gold prices would continue rising.
“i was asked by the global mail newspaper whether the bull market in gold was over and i said absolutely not the guy says are you sure what would you bet on i said i'll tell you what i'll do i said if if i'm wrong and this bull market is over i will stand in robson square which is the big square here in vancouver dressed in ladies underwear and i will sing patsy clines i was so wrong and people thought you were going to make an absolute fool yourself i said but it's it's not it's never going to happen i'm never going to sing that song it's never going to happen”
After the 2011-2016 bear market proved longer and worse than expected, Giustra rebuilt his investment organization and began actively creating and building new mining companies, focusing on gold opportunities.
“and i've got my guys working full steam now um and we're and we're very busy again extreme after being quiet for five years i mean dead quite the phones weren't ringing we weren't calling anybody we weren't doing anything and now we're busy doing what we do best which is to create and build mining companies but focused on gold”
Giustra retired before age 40 at the end of 1995 after successfully growing Yorktown Securities, a boutique resource-focused institutional investment firm, and unbeknownst to him, the Bre-X scandal hit three months later, killing the resource market for 4-5 years.
“i retired before i was 40 i just decided i didn't want to do it anymore it was we've done very well i left at the top of the market and i unbeknownst to me three months later the briex scandal hit and the whole resource market died for another four or five years”
Giustra created the film company Lionsgate in 1997, ran it for six years until 2003 (three years as CEO and three years as chairman), before returning full-time to the resource sector.
“i started lionsgate the film company in 1997 and ran that for six years until 2003 i ran it for three years and then stayed on as chairman for another three years until 2003”
Giustra personally follows his own diversification advice and maintains diversified holdings across geographies and asset classes as protection against systemic risk.
“that's what i do i'm diversified like i can't predict what's going to happen”
Giustra avoids investing in Bolivia, Ecuador, and Venezuela due to political risk, while seeing Brazil as currently unattractive but remaining open to other Latin American opportunities.
“i don't like bolivia i don't like ecuador um i don't like venezuela at all right uh brazil's tough right now”
Argentina is on an improving political trajectory that makes it increasingly prospective for mining investments, with the new government implementing positive policies and reforms more quickly and effectively than prior administrations.
“i think it's i think is on the right path yeah where it wasn't sure but with this new government i think argentina is incredibly prospective and i think as long as this government stays in place for one does what they continue what they're already doing very well and very quickly i think it's going to be a fantastic place even more so than chile i think i think chile is regressing a bit and argentina's on the rise”