YouTube39m· Nov 2019· cataloged

How ETFs Will Make the Next Financial Crisis Even Bigger (w/ Grant Williams and Steve Bregman)


What this covers

This is the third and final part of a longer interview in which Grant Williams questions Steve Bregman, filmed in New York in June 2017. Bregman starts from what ETF buyers believe they own versus what they hold. He gives the example of a country fund whose top ten holdings make up 70% of its weight and earn most of their revenue outside the named country. From there he describes the ETF Vortex: when everyone holds the basket, nobody sells a single name, so fundamentals stop moving prices and value investors can be right about a company with no way to realize it. He also argues that active management declined because managers became asset gatherers.

The middle of the conversation is a roadmap out. Bregman says proper diversification now means fewer securities, but ones that are truly idiosyncratic. He points to specialized mutual funds and closed-end funds run by veterans such as Chuck Royce and Mario Gabelli, and to owner-operated companies, including a Japanese diaper maker and an owner-operated index that he says beat both Japan and the US. He is candid about limits. Small caps are only 4.5% of US equity value, so indexed capital cannot move there en masse. He also sees indexation as entrenched, and says Jack Bogle's advice suits savers with roughly $24,000 put away, while his own clients are a different audience. He links this to a yield problem: 2.1% on ten-year Treasuries does not support a retiree.

The last stretch is the most contested. Bregman treats Bitcoin as a new asset class, citing its fixed supply and the long history of currency debasement, and as a hedge against coordinated central-bank policy rather than a hot stock. He proposes a token allocation of 25 basis points as prudent fiduciary behavior. Along the way he discusses why bearish critics such as Jeremy Grantham and Jim Grant sound like hysterics even if they are right, and he concludes that every route out of the vortex requires active decisions and personal responsibility.

Sharpest takeaway

Bregman argues that passive index investing creates systemic risks and hidden misalignments between what investors think they own and what they actually own, and proposes active management, non-indexed securities, and cryptocurrency as diversification strategies to escape what he calls the 'ETF Vortex.'

  • ETF holdings are concentrated and misrepresented (e.g., Spain ETF is 70% in 10 companies with 74% revenues outside Spain), creating false diversification
  • Index-dependent valuations have become decoupled from fundamentals, trapping value investors in underperformance until mass reallocation occurs
  • Bitcoin represents a new asset class offering genuine systemic diversification and currency protection unavailable in traditional markets

The claims · ranked36 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.80

Critics like Jeremy Grantham and Jim Grant who argue that the market is irrationally priced and predict S&P 500 declines sound like 'hysterics' because the market continues upward, but this is precisely how bubbles feel in real-time—you can only know you're wrong in retrospect, not in advance, creating a problem where bearish arguments become demonstrably wrong as irrationally priced securities become more irrationally priced.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Steve Bregman

“And we sound-- we sound like hysterics. Because look, everything's fine. Yeah. But that's the way it always feels during a bubble. And the problem is you can't prove it in advance. All you can know is that you're wrong, and you're demonstrably wrong, every single chord that goes by, while that which we say is irrationally priced gets more irrationally priced.”

0.75

Active managers historically degraded from genuine investors to 'asset gatherers' focused on collecting more capital under management, which forced them to either bid up securities already in their circle of competence or buy securities outside their expertise, both of which caused new investor returns to deteriorate.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Steve Bregman

“And one of the faults is that they, too, very often acted not as investors, but they began to degrade into asset gatherers. You want more assets. You gather more assets. There's a limited supply of what you can buy that you know. So either you buy those and you bid them up and your new investors don't do as well. Or you started buying securities outside your circle of competence, and your new investors don't do so well.”

0.74

The inefficiency that allows active managers to generate excess returns is finite and will eventually be 'bled out' as other investors discover and exploit it, which is why successful strategies must maintain secrecy or specialized knowledge to persist.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Steve Bregman

“One proviso, which is always applied in investing, is I can have a good idea. I find a certain niche, a certain inefficiency. And I can do it. And my firm can do it. And we can make good money for clients for a long time. But then other people find out about it and they start doing it. And then it will cause its own collapse. Or at least the inefficiency will be bled out of it.”

0.74

Indexation will not disappear because it remains the default destination for capital flows and there is no alternative large enough to absorb the current index fund capital base, meaning passive indexing is structurally entrenched despite its flaws.

forecasthigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Steve Bregman

“I don't think the whole market will collapse because there's no place for it to go. Doesn't mean sectors can't It might happen sooner than later that maybe there's an asset allocation away from these REIT indexes.”

0.74

Throughout recorded history, every government that controlled currency inevitably debased it through various methods (adding alloy, reducing size, changing weighting), and this occurred repeatedly until currency collapsed, with modern examples showing M2 growth in the US exceeding real GDP growth by 3%+ annually, diluting the currency at that rate even as Treasury yields fail to compensate savers for inflation.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Steve Bregman

“If you read the sequences, generation by generation, of all the different leaders and how they would debase the currency, they would put alloy into it. They would make it smaller. They would do various things. Even just change the weighting system. You can see, it's almost mind-numbingly boring after a while. It happens over and over and over again. And the commonality is they all did it until the point where it collapsed.”

0.74

Owner-operators make systematically different decisions about expansion, acquisition, costs, and risk compared to hired managers, because their personal capital is at risk and their wealth depends on long-term capital appreciation rather than compensation packages.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Steve Bregman

“Their path to true wealth is through capital appreciation over time, long term return on capital. It solves-- actually, what it does is the decision making process for them is entirely different. They become stewards of their-- yeah, exactly right. First of all, they have capital at risk. It's the most important aspect... And they make decisions that are entirely different about expansion, or acquisition, or costs, or risk.”

0.70

A Princeton undergraduate wrote a detailed guide to building a nuclear bomb (costing ~$12,000-$20,000) as a physics term paper, and the CIA/NSA investigated him but could not suppress the information—illustrating that knowledge, once public, cannot be controlled or reversed.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Steve Bregman

“I don't remember if it was in the '70s. Probably the '70s, not the '80s-- of a Princeton undergraduate, for his physics term paper, wrote a detailed, comprehensive guide to building a nuclear bomb, including costing it out. It was like $12,000 or $20,000, including the price of plutonium if you could get it. The CIA, or NSA, or whoever, was all over him, wanting to know where he got his information...Now, they permitted him to publish that paper exclusive of two critical pages. The point, you can't put the genie back in the bottle.”

0.69

Small-cap stocks (defined as under $1-2 billion market cap) represent only 4.5% of the $18 trillion US equity market value, meaning the vast majority of indexed capital cannot be reallocated to small caps en masse, which limits the number of people who can escape the index structure and justifies why Jack Bogle's passive advice cannot be universal policy.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Steve Bregman

“Small cap stocks, as defined as, I think it's under $1 billion or $2 billion, something like that, they only represent like 4 and 1/2% of the $18 trillion of US equity market value. People can't go there en masse. They just can't. So some people can.”

0.69

To escape the ETF Vortex, individuals without expertise in individual securities analysis can invest in specialized mutual funds or closed-end funds managed by experienced value investors (e.g., Chuck Royce, Mario Gabelli) who have long operating histories and maintain low overlap with broad market indices, allowing exposure to securities outside the index.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Steve Bregman

“You can find a fund or fund manager who has a particular specialty, who's got a long history of doing this. And their performance, like as not in the last 5 or 10 years, since the financial crisis, relative to the indexes, don't look great. Like the names I mentioned. They can't go by that.”

0.69

Jack Bogle, the founder of Vanguard, advocates for long-term buy-and-hold indexing in broad indices like the S&P 500, and predicts 10-year S&P 500 returns of 4-5%, which Bregman agrees with 95% of his market philosophy but targets a different clientele (average American savers with limited financial literacy) than his own consultative clients.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Steve Bregman

“Jack Bogle, the founder of Vanguard Group...is very active. And he speaks and writes daily...And I agree with 95% of what he says about the market and how to invest in the market.”

0.69

A Japanese diaper manufacturer founded by an owner who holds most of the stock would only invest capital in a new factory targeting the aging population (adult diapers) if he expected good returns, and would withdraw capital if returns deteriorated, meaning owner-operators make capital allocation decisions based on expected returns rather than other incentives.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Steve Bregman

“Let's say you have a company that's making diapers. Japan. Founder owns most of the stock. Why would this fellow put more money, more capital, into a new factory unless he thought he could get a good return on it? Yeah. He wouldn't do it. He might-- if he thinks it's getting worse, he might withdraw his capital little by little, look for something else to do. But let's say he found a new niche, the aging population, adult diapers. And he thought he could get a good return and put the capital in.”

0.68

Recent relative underperformance of active managers compared to indices (since financial crisis) doesn't prove they won't outperform going forward—this period represents unusually favorable conditions for index investing due to extreme valuations and monetary stimulus.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Steve Bregman

“And their performance, like as not in the last 5 or 10 years, since the financial crisis, relative to the indexes, don't look great. Like the names I mentioned. They can't go by that.”

0.68

Bitcoin is a genuinely new asset class that for the first time in recorded financial history provides a mechanism to escape government or fiat currency debasement because it has a fixed supply of 21 million bitcoins with an average annualized inflation of only 0.2% per year through 2140, and cannot be counterfeited due to cryptographic authentication.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Steve Bregman

“So a cryptocurrency like Bitcoin is the first time in history we have a currency that is not dilutable, because there will only be 21 million bitcoins, 21.000 bitcoins in the year 2140. Right now there are 16.4 million. The average annualized inflation, if you will, between now and then is like 0.2% a year. But it can't go any further, number one. And number two, it solves the authentication problem. It can't be counterfeited.”

0.68

All investment solutions discussed—active management, security selection, cryptocurrency allocation—ultimately point to the necessity of active decision-making and personal responsibility, making true passive indexing inadequate for building wealth.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Steve Bregman

“I mean, it's funny, when you talk about this, and we talk about solutions, they all point to one place, which is active management. Whether it's your own responsibility for it, or it's finding those managers.”

0.64

A portfolio with $1 million invested in 10-year Treasury notes at 2.1% yields $21,000 annually, which after taxes is insufficient to live on, while high-yield bonds at 5% appear risky through an index lens, but below-the-ETF-divide securities can provide 5-11% yields with varying degrees of risk and intrinsic value, creating a genuine yield crisis that requires active securities selection.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Steve Bregman

“You have a million dollar portfolio, and you put it all into 10-year Treasury notes. You want to be safe. At 2.1%, so you have $21,000 a year, and then you pay taxes on it? You'll starve. You can't live. That's a crisis.”

0.64

A 34-year-old household head in the US has average financial savings of approximately $24,000 based on Census data, and given expected return rates from bonds and stocks and a 5.5% average savings rate, this is insufficient to meet retirement income needs, making passive index investing appropriate for this population despite its limitations.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Steve Bregman

“So based on the US Census data for the average household in the United States that has savings, because many of them don't, for such a household, with a 34-year-old head of household, do you know the average savings are, financial savings? I've looked at this. It's lows. $20,000 maybe? Yeah, $24,000-odd. And given the expected rates of return from bonds and stocks, they might not make it, given the average savings rate, which is about 5.5%.”

0.61

Bitcoin is not primarily a hot stock investment idea but rather a systemic hedge against central bank coordinated monetary policy risk—it exists outside the system of government currency control and can hedge against all currencies simultaneously.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Steve Bregman

“I'm not talking about this as a stock idea. Hey, it's a hot stock. If you want a defense against systemic risk, this exists outside the system. What the central banks are doing, for the first time in history, you have coordinated, massive, multiyear attempt to artificially bring rates to zero. In with whatever risks come from that. This exist outside that system. This is both an independent, diversifying investment. And it's also a natural hedge.”

0.59

In an index-dominant market, company fundamentals no longer matter for stock price movement because no one will sell an index holding (they cannot sell just that security, they sell the entire basket), meaning a value investor can find excellent companies at cheap valuations but has no mechanism to realize gains unless broader institutional demand emerges.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Steve Bregman

“If you think this through, A, it doesn't really matter what a company's performance is anymore. Because to your point about McDonald's, it doesn't matter if the company has a bad announcement. Who's going to sell their shares? They're not going to just sell the basket.”

0.59

By holding Bitcoin, if 3.5% additional dollars are created annually on a real basis (from currency debasement), a Bitcoin holder's wealth in real terms increases 3.5% per year simply by standing still and holding the asset, without any price appreciation relative to other assets.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Steve Bregman

“It's not accepted yet. But there are 3 and 1/2% more dollars in existence on a real basis. That means my bitcoin, by just standing still, is worth 3 and 1/2% more. So this is a kind of seminal event.”

0.57

Proper diversification in a world dominated by index-driven investing requires fewer securities, not more, but those securities must be truly idiosyncratic (uncorrelated to systemic risks like interest rate manipulation or institutional fund flows) rather than multiple index constituents that all move together due to shared index inclusion.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Steve Bregman

“It could well be that in the new world as it develops, that in order to be effectively, not semantically, but effectively diversified, you're going to want to have fewer, not more, securities, but securities that are truly idiosyncratic in how they'll behave. Meaning whether they do well or not, or how well they do or how well they don't, meaning it won't be a function of the systemic risk, like interest rate manipulation, or the flow of funds by institutions.”

0.52

A nominal Bitcoin position (e.g., 25 basis points in a $100,000 portfolio costing $250) is prudent fiduciary behavior because if Bitcoin achieves 1,000x returns it meaningfully improves lifetime financial outcomes, while if it goes to zero the loss is trivial and comparable to a forgotten dinner with relatives.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Steve Bregman

“So with a 1,000-fold return, what you can do is how do you game this? You game the risk by sizing it. You can buy a size that wouldn't, in any other normal circumstance, be worthwhile bothering for. So if you have $100,000 portfolio, the cost of taking your in-laws out for dinner, not even a great restaurant, $250, 25 basis points, that you forget about it. If it worked, you have that result.”

0.52

Future active managers should specialize in a narrow domain (specific security types, industries, or styles), cap their assets under management to preserve their competitive advantage, and measure performance on absolute return basis (e.g., 10% per year over 5 years) rather than relative to broad benchmarks.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Steve Bregman

“Managers for the future, active managers, they should focus on that which they do well. It might be a certain type of security. It might be a certain industry or two or three. It might be a certain style. But that's what they do well. And if they're wise, they will not continue or desire to continue collecting assets, more assets, if they do well. They're going to cap it, so they don't invite competition. And they don't dilute what they have.”

0.52

Indexation can be improved from its current market-cap-weighted, descriptive-attribute structure to include predictive attributes that signal future performance (e.g., owner-operated companies, where founders have 80-100% of their wealth in the company and therefore make long-term oriented capital allocation decisions).

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Steve Bregman

“Here's a great flaw with it. But indexation can be improved. It's just there hasn't been a motive yet for them to improve it. Overall, we've made some early attempts. So the flaw with indexation now is, first of all, the market cap weighting system. That's one problem. The other is that it is essentially a descriptive system.”

0.52

An owner-operated index applied to the Japanese market over 10 and 20 years outperformed both the Japanese market itself (which was down over the period) and the US market, suggesting that the owner-operator principle is not culturally specific but reflects a universal principle of capital allocation.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Steve Bregman

“Maybe there was something special about the US market culturally or geographically that made this, or that testing work. So we chose a market that was far away culturally and geographically as we could get, which was Japan. And over the last 10 and 20 years, we created an index for Japan. And not only was it up in a market that was down over a decade or two, it actually outperformed the US market.”

0.52

ETF investors believe they are buying diversified exposure to a country or market segment, but in many cases the top 10 holdings represent 70% of the weight, and further analysis reveals that these holdings derive 70%+ of revenues from outside the stated geographic focus, meaning investors unknowingly have concentrated, multinational exposure rather than the targeted exposure.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Steve Bregman

“If you look at-- I think it's the Spain-- the iShares Spain ETF...you buy this Spain ETF. And first of all, nobody tells you that the top 10 companies account for 70% of the weight. It's not diversified, number one. So now you're actually buying individual stock risk. OK, I'm willing to live with that. But nobody told you that six of the top 10 holdings get 74% of their revenues from outside of Spain.”

0.52

Government and institutional acceptance of Bitcoin (Japan, Australia) represents a seminal event analogous to nuclear technology—once the intellectual content is public, 'the genie cannot be put back in the bottle' and cryptocurrency development cannot be stopped regardless of future regulation.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Steve Bregman

“These are two major banks approving cryptocurrency. And I think that you can't-- this is intellectual content. You can't put the genie back in the bottle... The point, you can't put the genie back in the bottle. And this really is a different asset class.”

0.51

Starting with a 2% dividend yield and assuming corporate profit growth cannot reliably exceed 6% annually, with an ending P/E of 15, the mathematical calculation of S&P 500 10-year returns yields lower numbers than Bogle's 4-5% estimate.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Steve Bregman

“Look, you're starting with a 2% dividend yield, not 4% or 5% any more. And you can't really count on corporate profit growth being 6% anymore...And then you have to choose an ending PE. It maybe should be 15. And you run the numbers, that's what you're going to get.”

0.47

Indexation as currently practiced has a fundamental flaw in its market-cap weighting system, which is purely descriptive of current state rather than predictive of future returns.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Steve Bregman

“But indexation can be improved. It's just there hasn't been a motive yet for them to improve it... But indexation now is, first of all, the market cap weighting system. That's one problem.”

0.45

Chuck Royce's small cap and micro-cap mutual funds represent a good model for active manager selection—he has consistent, disclosed value investment standards and has demonstrated long-term outperformance, though recent returns lag the market index.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Steve Bregman

“So for instance, Chuck Royce. He has mutual funds. Buy his stuff. He's got small cap and micro-cap mutual funds. He's a value manager with very consistent standards and very disclosed approaches. And there's no reason he shouldn't do well over time. And he has done well over time, just not as well as the market lately.”

0.45

Bitcoin's probability of success shifted from roughly 50-50 (going to zero vs. 1,000x returns) a year ago to higher odds of adoption and value preservation following Japan's April 2014 recognition of Bitcoin as a medium of exchange in the Banking Act and subsequent removal of the 8% sales tax on Bitcoin purchases, along with Australia's recognition of Bitcoin as legal tender and removal of 10% surcharge.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 1/4· Steve Bregman

“A year ago, even six months ago, I would say, 50-50. Goes to zero, goes up 1,000 fold or 10,000-- and I can tell you how to calculate that at home all by yourself.”

0.45

No motive has yet emerged for index providers to improve their indices with predictive attributes because market-cap weighting remains profitable and because momentum favors existing approaches, but this could change if active management disciplines prove superior over time.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Steve Bregman

“But indexation can be improved. It's just there hasn't been a motive yet for them to improve it.”

0.41

Japan's recognition of Bitcoin in April 2014 and subsequent merchant adoption (5,000 stores) was not reported in US mainstream media (Wall Street Journal, New York Times, Washington Post, Forbes) but was covered in the Yomiuri Shimbun, the world's largest circulation newspaper with 11 million subscribers.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Steve Bregman

“Every combination of Japan, banking act, Bitcoin, cryptocurrency, Japan. Cryptocurrency websites aside, I couldn't find mention of it in the Wall Street Journal, the New York Times, The Washington Post, Forbes, nowhere. You know where I found a reasonably good article about it? In the Shomiori Shimbun.”

0.29

Advice given from a distance without understanding an individual's circumstances, education level, and risk tolerance is very dangerous, which is why Bregman cannot give universal policy recommendations like Bogle's but instead must provide nuanced guidance specific to each client's situation.

normativeestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Steve Bregman

“And the problem is, to give somebody advice from a distance is very dangerous. Oh, yeah. No, no, no. And that's not what I'm looking for.”

0.29

Value traps (cheap stocks that are cheap for a reason and continue declining) exist, but some cheap stocks represent genuine opportunities for investors with capital at risk and good incentive alignment.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Steve Bregman

“There are value traps, but there are companies that are actually growing.”

0.27

Grant Williams (host) is engaging with Bregman about the ETF Vortex problem and Bitcoin as solutions, indicating a conversational format where Bregman is guest presenting investment ideas.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Unidentified Speaker — How ETFs Will Make the Next Financial Crisis Even Bigger (w… [0JfGplGv3BA]

“Grant Williams: He offers ways to avoid getting trapped in what he calls the ETF Vortex. Steve Bregman: Jack Bogle, the founder of Vanguard Group...”

0.20

When asking 'is there an escape from the ETF Vortex for ordinary investors?' the answer is 'it's a conundrum'—there are partial solutions but they require sophistication, capital, and engagement that most investors lack, making comprehensive escape impossible for the broad population.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Steve Bregman

“Well, it's a little bit of a conundrum. Yeah. There's a short term answer, a long term answer, and there's a proviso in the middle.”