What this covers

This four-minute video is a short monologue from Paul McGowan of PS Audio, prompted by a simple question: do people with big ears hear better? He answers from fifty years of working in audio, where he has made his living by listening and translating what he hears into electronic terms, and he says he tests very well on auditory tests. His case against the folk assumption is that the brain adjusts to the particular ear it has been given, so sailing ears confer no built-in advantage over small ones. That is flagged as a contested claim, and he offers it as his own experience-based view rather than a cited finding.

From there the talk moves to the acoustics of the horn. McGowan points to historical photographs from the Edison era showing hard-of-hearing people using an acoustic horn to funnel sound into the ear. He says audio designers inverted that idea: instead of narrowing sound toward the ear, a vibrating membrane at a narrow opening radiates into a wider one and comes out louder. He frames this as Bidirectional Horn Acoustics and calls it the underlying principle of high-end audio design. A practical demonstration follows. Cupping your hands behind your ears makes artificial sailing ears, which boost a narrow band of frequencies far more than normal hearing does.

The remarks are loose and conversational. He briefly says humans have taken many wrong turns as a species and gone in circles, without developing the point. The piece ends abruptly when he notices a high-frequency noise in the speaker system and says he needs to investigate it before concluding.

Sharpest takeaway

Paul McGowan argues that ear size (including large 'sailing ears') does not determine hearing ability because the brain calibrates to individual ear anatomy, and that horn-based acoustic amplification—the fundamental principle behind loudspeakers and hearing aids—works by funneling or expanding sound waves to increase perceived loudness.

  • The brain tunes itself to the specific ear anatomy each person has, equalizing hearing across different ear sizes
  • Horn acoustics work bidirectionally: hearing aids funnel sound into the ear, loudspeakers funnel sound out from a vibrating membrane
  • This horn principle has been used for centuries, from Edison-era hearing aids to modern high-end audio

The claims · ranked7 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.80

The horn principle in acoustics originated from observations of how people with hearing problems used acoustic horns (as seen in historical photographs from Edison's era) to amplify sound into their ears, and audio engineers inverted this principle to create loudspeakers by making sound come out through a vibrating membrane.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Paul McGowan

“how many years when people had hearing problems you've probably seen the old pictures of it you know they have these horns and they'll plug it into their ear and these big acoustic horns like and that was how they heard and somebody looked at that and said huh if I took that hearing aid horn turned it around and then made sound come out of it through a vibrating membrane of some kind then I could amplify sound”

0.68

The brain tunes itself to each individual's ear anatomy, so people with large 'sailing ears' do not have inherently better hearing than people with small ears because the brain has already adjusted for the acoustic properties of their specific ear shape.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Paul McGowan

“we tune our brains to our ears this whole mechanism right here my mine's different than yours but I hear the same as you hear and if I had sailing ears then my brain and ear and that whole mess would have adjusted for all of that to be the same so I don't think people with sailing ears have better hearing than people with little weeny ears”

0.66

The fundamental principle of high-end audio design is bidirectional horn acoustics: narrowing and funneling sound (as in hearing aids) amplifies it for the ear, and creating sound at a narrow opening and having it amplify outward through a wider opening (as in loudspeakers) produces louder sound.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Paul McGowan

“I'm taking sounds that exist narrowing them and funneling them down so it's louder in my ear that's this and then doing the opposite of that and creating sound at the little opening and have it amplify come on that's the whole basis of a horn that's the whole basis of everything we do in in high-end audio”

0.65

When you cup your hands behind your ears to amplify sound (creating artificial 'sailing ears'), you amplify frequencies very differently than normal, picking up a narrow band of frequencies much more prominently than you would without the hand-cupping technique.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Paul McGowan

“when you do this you you know you're amplifying frequencies very differently then you would normally have without doing the making your fake sailing ears right and and if you try it you'll notice that you're picking up this whole narrow band much greater”

0.22

McGowan has worked in audio for 50 years, making a living off his hearing ability and relating what he hears to electronic terms, and tests very well on auditory tests.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Paul McGowan

“I've listened and made a a living off of my hearing and my ability to relate What I Hear to electronic terms uh for 50 years so I don't think that is an issue”

0.17

Humans have taken many wrong turns as a species and gone in circles.

normativespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Paul McGowan

“hell yes so many wrong turns we've gone in circles”

0.13

There is some kind of high frequency noise coming through the speaker system that McGowan needs to investigate before concluding the discussion.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Paul McGowan

“there's some kind of high frequency noise coming through here anyway I was about to be done so I'll have to go investigate maybe uh I'm going to blow up here in a few seconds”