
Why You Will Marry the Wrong Person
What this covers
This is a 22-minute talk by Alain de Botton, given at a Google event in London in 2017, with no other speakers. It opens with a show of hands: roughly 30 of 100 married people in the room admitted they felt, in their hearts, that they had married the wrong person. From there he works through the psychology of why this is so common. Adults are strange and hard to live with, but we rarely see it in ourselves. Friends want a pleasant evening, parents love us too much to say anything, and ex-lovers leave without naming our flaws. He also argues that technology lets us avoid time alone with ourselves, and he redefines addiction as any pattern that keeps us from our own uncomfortable thoughts.
The middle of the talk turns to childhood and attachment. Adult love is built on early experiences in which tenderness was mixed with rejection and humiliation, so we are drawn to partners who hurt us in familiar ways, and a wonderful, uncomplicated candidate can feel false. He sets out anxious attachment and avoidant attachment as two failed responses to the risk of admitting need. He draws on Søren Kierkegaard on inevitable regret, and on the idea of ambivalence as the mark of maturity: loved ones are neither heroes nor villains.
The practical argument follows. Love is a skill, not an instinct. Loving means charitable interpretation of another person's behavior, and being understood requires explaining oneself like a good teacher. Incompatibility is universal, so compatibility is something love achieves rather than something present at the start. The most contested claims come here. He says following your feelings will probably lead to a big mistake, that we should not reveal our whole character even to people we love, and that staying together for the children is a good reason. He also holds that anger at unmet expectations rests on hidden optimism, so lowering hopes reduces rage. The realistic aim is a good enough partner.
De Botton argues that most people will marry the wrong person not because they fail to find the right one, but because they operate under romantic illusions about love, compatibility, and self-knowledge that make successful partnership nearly impossible unless they fundamentally reframe what love is and how to practice it.
- People are psychologically complex and largely unaware of their own difficulties, making it impossible to find a truly 'right' partner without accepting 'good enough'
- Love is not an instinct but a learnable skill requiring vulnerability, explicit communication, and charity of interpretation rather than wordless understanding
- Maturity in love means accepting that all people are ambivalent mixtures of good and bad, and that compatibility is achieved through work, not discovered at the outset
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Modern technology and distractions enable people to avoid spending time alone with themselves and facing uncomfortable self-knowledge, which is destructive to the capacity to relate to another person because 'until you know yourself you can't properly relate to another person'.
“most of us are addicts and thanks to all sorts of Technologies and uh distractions Etc we can have a good life where we will almost certainly be guaranteed not to spend any time with ourselves um except maybe for certain kind of airlines that still don't have the gadgets to distract us but otherwise you can be guaranteed you don't have to talk to yourself and this is a disaster for your capacity to have a relationship with another person because until you know yourself you can't properly relate uh to another person”
All humans are psychologically strange and difficult to live with, though we do not recognize this in ourselves because we lack self-awareness and others refuse to tell us the truth about our flaws.
“we are very strange I'm very strange and you're very strange you don't let on and you know we're not going to do anything very dangerous but we are basically psychologically quite strange um we don't normally know very much about this strangeness it takes us a long long time before we're really on top of the way in which we are hard to live with”
Love requires vulnerable admission of need to another person ('I need you, I wouldn't survive without you'), but most people have a strong impulse to appear strong and defended, which prevents them from making this necessary vulnerability.
“one of the reasons why love is so tricky for us is that it requires us to do something we really don't want to do which is to approach another human being and say I need you I wouldn't really survive without you I am vulnerable before you and there's a very strong impulse in all of us to be strong and to be well-defended and not to reveal our vulnerability to another person”
The psychological achievement of maturity is the ability to recognize that all people are ambivalent mixtures of good and bad qualities, rather than idealized heroes or complete villains, and to accept and tolerate this ambivalence in loved ones.
“what we tend to be very bad at is recognizing that anyone that we can love is going to be a perplexing mixture of the good and the bad there's a wonderful uh psychoanalyst called Melanie Klein who was active in the 50s and 60s originally from Vienna uh active in North London studying how children learned about relationships from the parental situation and she came up with a very fascinating analysis she argued that when children are small very small they don't really realize that a parent is one character they actually do what she called split a parent into a good parent and a bad parent... it takes a long long time melan Klein thought it might be until you're four um until you actually realize that the good and the bad mother are one person and you become ambivalent in other words you become able to hate someone and really go off them and at the same time also love them”
The way people love as adults is built on top of their early childhood experiences of love, which were intertwined with suffering, rejection, and humiliation alongside tenderness and care.
“you don't have to be a paid out believer in Psychotherapy or psychoanalysis to realize that the way we love as adults sits on top of our early childhood experien and in early childhood the way that we learned about love was not just via experiences of tenderness and kindness and generosity the love that we will have tasted as children will also be bound up with experiences of being let down being humiliated maybe being with a parent who treated us very harshly who scolded us who made us feel small in some way in other words quite a lot about our early experiences of Love abound up with various kinds of suffering”
Danish philosopher Søren Kierkegaard argued that all humans will make mistakes and face regret in major life decisions, and therefore people should not berate themselves for their failures because making mistakes is simply what humans do.
“I'm going to end um with with a a quote from one of my favorite philosophers Danish 19th century very gloomy philosopher called kard and kard in his book either or had a wonderful Outburst where he basically said of course you're going to marry the wrong person and make the wrong decisions in a whole row of areas and the reason you're going to do this is that you're human therefore do not berate yourself for doing what humans do”
Following your feelings in love will almost certainly lead to a big mistake in life.
“if you keep following your feelings you will almost certainly make a big mistake uh in in your life”
The task of addressing marital dissatisfaction is to transform private rage into grief, which represents psychological progress.
“there's a lot of anger around our love lives privately held but a lot of us go around feeling quite enraged angry privately about the way that our love lives have gone my task today is to turn that anger into sadness if we if we manage to turn rage into grief we will have made psychological progress”
True love should not mean accepting the whole of someone; we shouldn't fully reveal the entirety of our characters to anyone we care about.
“true love means accepting the whole of us it doesn't no one should accept the whole of us we're appalling really want the whole of you accepted no that's not love the the full display of our characters the full articulation of who we are should not be something that we do in front of anyone that we care about”
Psychologists have identified two maladaptive attachment patterns in response to the risk of vulnerability: anxious attachment (where people become procedural and critical instead of expressing need) and avoidant attachment (where people pretend not to need anyone when they feel most vulnerable).
“psycho psychologists talk of two patterns of response that tend to crop up in people whenever there's a danger of needing to be extremely vulnerable dangerously vulnerable and exposed to another person the first response is to get what what um uh psychologists call anxiously attached this attachment Theory some of you may know so when you are anxiously attached to somebody rather than saying I need you I depend on you you start to get very procedural you say you're 10 minutes late or I think the bin bags need to be taken out or you start to get strict when actually what you want to do is to ask a very poignant question do you still care about me but we don't dare to ask that question so instead we get nasty we get stiff uh we get procedural the other other thing the other pattern of behavior which psychologists have identified and it tends to apply to people uh who are in this room in other words a types very outgoing types uh Strivers uh you become in relationships tell me if I'm wrong uh you become what is known as avoidant which means that when you when you need someone it's precisely at that moment that you pretend you don't when you feel most vulnerable you say I'm quite busy at the moment I'm fine thanks I'm well busy today”
A substantial portion of people who are married feel, in their hearts, that they have married the wrong person, as evidenced by roughly 30 people in a room of 100 raising their hands to this direct question.
“how many of you in the room do feel on balance that you have married the wrong person I mean we're among friends honest any yeah lady that couple of people... I'd say 30 people in the room”
Staying in a relationship for the children is a wonderful reason to remain committed, contrary to modern judgment that suggests this is a failure; there are good reasons to value stability and commitment for family cohesion.
“maybe we're sticking around for the children good people say oh they're only sticking around for the children that's a wonderful reason to stick around why else are you going to stick around okay so let's look a bit more benevolently at the art of uh compromise”
We are not on a quest to be happy but on a quest to suffer in ways that feel familiar, which radically undermines our capacity to find a good partner.
“so we are not merely on a quest to be happy we are on a quest to suffer in ways that feel familiar and this radically undermines our capacity to find a good partner”
Addiction should be redefined not by the substance consumed but as any behavioral pattern that prevents a person from being alone with themselves and their uncomfortable thoughts and emotions.
“I like to Define addiction not in terms of the substance you're taking in other words you know I'm heroin addict I'm a cocaine addict no addiction is basically any pattern of behavior whereby you cannot stand to be with yourself and certain of the more uncomfortable thoughts and more importantly emotions that come from being on your own and so therefore you can be addicted to almost anything so long as it keeps you away from yourself”
Incompatibility is universal; the work of love is to make gracious accommodation to each other's incompatibilities, and compatibility is an achievement of love rather than something needed at the outset.
“incompatibility we are all incompatible but it is the work of love to make us graciously accommodate each other and ourselves to each other's incompatibilities uh and and therefore compatibility is an achievement of love it isn't what you need from the outset of course you're not going to be totally compatible that's not the point it is through love that you grow gradually accept the need uh uh to to be uh compatible”
When offered a wonderful partner who is good-looking, charming, and accomplished, people often reject them because they detect an absence of the particular kind of suffering they need to feel that love is real—they need a partner who can hurt them in familiar ways.
“this explains why sometimes um people will say to us look there's a wonderful person you should go and date them they're they're they're goodlooking they're Charming they're all sorts of things and we go out with them we them and we do recognize that they're really wonderful and amazing but we have to confess to our partners that to to our friends that actually we found this person often we struggle with the vocabulary we say maybe not that exciting or maybe not sexy or a bit boring but really what we mean is that we've detected in this really quite accomplished person someone who will not be able to make us suffer in the way that we need to suffer in order to feel that love is real and that's why we we reject them”
To reduce anger and suffering in love, we must diminish our expectations and hopes, because it is elevated hope that fuels rage when reality fails to match.
“if we're to get a little bit less sad uh uh and as a little less angry about our love lives we will have to diminish some of our hopes”
While it is unlikely anyone will find the 'right person,' everyone can and should expect to find a 'good enough person,' and this is a realistic definition of success in marriage.
“all of us uh will not manage to find the right person but we will probably all of us manage to find a good enough person so and that's success”
Love is not an instinct but a skill that must be learned, yet modern society treats love as something people should simply follow their feelings about rather than consciously learning how to do.
“we don't know very very much how to love we and it sounds very odd cuz imagine if somebody said to you look all of us probably in this room would probably need to go to a school of love we think what a school of love love is just an instinct no it's not it's a skill and it's a skill that needs to be learned and it's a skill that our society refuses to consider as a skill we are meant to always just follow our feelings if you keep following your feelings you will almost certainly make a big mistake uh in in your life”
Loving someone is fundamentally different from being loved; being loved is the passive experience of receiving care, while loving is the active skill of interpreting another person's behavior charitably and generously to find benevolent explanations for their actions.
“there's a distinction between love loving and being loved we all start off in life by knowing a lot about being loved being loved is the fun bit uh that's when somebody brings you something on a tray and ask you how your day at school went Etc and we grow up thinking that that is what's going to happen in an adult relationship we can be forgiven for that it's an understandable mistake but it's a very tragic mistake and it leads us not to pay attention to the other side of the equation which is to love and what does it really mean to love to love ultimately is to have the willingness to interpret someone's on the surface not not very appealing behavior in order to find more benevolent reasons why it may be unfolding in other words to love someone is to apply charity and generosity of interpretation”
If you do not explain yourself to your partner, you cannot be understood, and therefore the root to good marriage and lasting love is the ability to become a good teacher—to get ideas from one mind into another in a way that is likely to be accepted.
“if you do not explain you can never be understood the root to a good marriage and to Good Love is the ability to become a good teacher now teaching sounds like a narrow profession those guys in Tweed jackets and fussy with a with a chalkboard Etc I'm not talking about that kind of teaching all of us whatever our job aspirations whatever it is we do have to become teachers now teaching is merely the word that we give to the skill of getting an idea from one head into another in a way that is likely to be accepted”
Compromise in relationships is noble and should be recognized as such, not treated as shameful; people compromise in every area of life, and romantic partnerships are no exception.
“the other thing we should do is recognize the nobility of compromise one of the most shameful things to ever have to admit is to say this is my partner I've compromised in choosing them I've compromised oh why have you compromised well I'm not that attractive myself uh I've got lots of problems I'm a bit nutty frankly I couldn't pull anyone better but they're very nice they're okay now you would think loser it's not true compromise is Noble we compromise in every area of life there's no reason why we shouldn't compromise in our love lives”
Friends don't tell us about our flaws because they simply want a pleasant evening out; parents don't tell us because they love us too much; and ex-lovers know our flaws but won't articulate them when they leave.
“our friends don't want to tell us why would they bother they just want a pleasant evening out... our parents don't tell us very much why would they they love us too much... our ex-lovers a vital source of knowledge they know absolutely they know uh but do you remember that speech that they gave it was moving at the time when they said that they wanted a little more space and we're attracted to travel and we're interested in the culture of Southeast Asia nonsense they thought lots of things were wrong with you but they weren't going to be bothered to tell you”
Underlying most chronic anger is not pessimism or darkness but an unusual form of wild optimism and hope—people rage at unmet expectations that reveal they unconsciously believe the world should work differently than it does.
“what lies behind rage very often is an unusual quality because we tend to think that very angry people are sort of dark and pessimistic characters absolutely not scratch the surface of any regularly angry person and you will find a wild Optimist it is in fact hope that drives rage think of the person who screams every time they can't find their house keys or every time they get stuck in traffic these unfortunate characters are evincing a curious but Reckless faith in a world in which Keys Never Go astray the roads are mysteriously traffic free it is hope that is turbocharging their rage”
The demand for perfection in partners leads to only one outcome: loneliness; you cannot have both perfection and company.
“the good thing is that none of us are perfect and therefore we don't need Perfection and the demand for Perfection will lead you to only one thing loneliness you cannot have Perfection and Company to be in company with another person is to be negotiating imperfection every day”
Everyone needs to have charitable slack cut for them because human behavior is tricky and difficult; without charitable interpretation, no relationship could survive.
“most of us are in dire need of love because actually we need to be we need to have some slack cut for us because our behavior is often so tricky that if we don't do this uh we wouldn't get through uh any kind of relationship”
People choose partners based on following their instincts and hearts, which they believe will guide them to the right person, but this approach causes relationship mistakes because instinct reflects unconscious patterns from childhood.
“the reason why we're going to probably make some real mistakes when we choose our love Partners some of you in this room have made some stunning mistakes now why is this the reason is that we've been told that the way to find a good partner is to follow your instinct right follow your heart that's the Mantra”
People cannot think too much about their emotions; the claim that one can 'think too much' about emotions is a cultural myth that privileges impulse over analysis.
“there's no such thing as thinking too much about emotions but the problem is we live in a romantic culture that privileges impulse”
Using words to communicate is cumbersome and boring, but the failure to use words in relationships leads to catastrophic sulking—a pattern where one person silently expects the other to read their soul.
“it's very cumbersome to use words it's such a bore and when it comes to love we have this deep desire that will simply be understood wordlessly it's touching it's a beautiful romantic idea but it also leads to a catastrophic outbreak of sulking”
Most people are appalling teachers in their relationships because they teach when tired and frightened—frightened that they have married an idiot—and this fear causes them to scream and humiliate their partner, which ensures the partner will not understand anything.
“most of us are appalling teachers most of us teach when we're tired when we're frightened what are we frightened of we're frightened we've married an idiot and because we're so frightened we start screaming at them you've got to understand and the thing is that unfortunately by the time you've started to humiliate the person you want to understand something less and over you will never get anyone to understand what you want them to understand so long as you make them feel small”
People typically believe that criticism from a partner is an attack on them, but it is actually an attempt to make them a better person; reframing criticism as education rather than attack is essential for relationship success.
“because you probably believe that when somebody tries to tell you something about yourself that's a little ticklish and a little uncomfortable they are attacking you they're not they're trying to make you into a better person and we don't tend to believe that this has a role in love we tend to believe that true love means accepting the whole of us it doesn't no one should accept the whole of us we're appalling really want the whole of you accepted no that's not love”
The concept of 'good enough' is a relief from punishing perfectionism because none of us are perfect, and therefore we do not need perfection; demanding perfection leads only to loneliness.
“it's a relief from our otherwise punishing uh uh perfectionism the good thing is that none of us are perfect and therefore we don't need Perfection and the demand for Perfection will lead you to only one thing loneliness you cannot have Perfection and Company”
People cannot change their type (the kind of person they are attracted to), and these types often have qualities that will cause real problems in relationships, but this does not mean the relationship is doomed.
“we probably can't change our types right so all of us are pro many of us are have got types who are going to cause us real problems they may be too distant they may be arrogant they're going to torture Us in some way”
While one cannot change one's type, one can and should change how one characteristically responds to one's difficult type; this is a major psychological achievement because response patterns are often formed in early childhood.
“now friends casually say to us Chuck them get out the relationship Etc right no I don't you know we're realists here at Google and I'm giving you realistic advice you're not going to manage to change your type let's get that for granted what you can do and this is a big achievement is to change how you characteristically respond to your tricky type most of us have formed the way that we respond to tricky types in early childhood so we had a distant parent we've now chosen a Distant Lover when we were very young we responded to that distant parent by attention seeking we rattled and banged and now we're adults we rattle and bang in our own way and we think that's going to help it doesn't”
The task of philosophy is to let people down gently by diminishing their unrealistic hopes, particularly through critiquing industries and figures (like Walt Disney) that inflate expectations of love and happiness.
“there was wonderful quote from the German philosopher Theodore adoro who in the 1960s said that the most dangerous man in America was Walt Disney and the reason for his attack on Walt was because he believed that Walt was the Prime agent of Hope and therefore of rage and therefore of bitterness and he thought that um it was the task of philosophy to let us down uh gently”