
What this covers
This is a conversation between Rick Rule of Rule Investment Media and host Andy Millette. It starts with a reframing of investor anxiety: concern about a thesis is normal for a good investor, and the real danger is acting out of fear. Rule links this to time horizon, saying that after investing since 1971 he has moved from impatience to patience. From there the talk moves through the dollar, gold producers and juniors, and then oil and gas, ending with a pointer to his education platforms.
The macro case rests on entitlement arithmetic. Rule cites a Congressional Budget Office figure of more than $120 trillion in obligations against roughly $5 trillion of federal income. He argues this rules out an honest default and makes an inflationary one inevitable. He also calls the 1975 drop, when gold fell about 50% and gold equities more than 60% inside a secular bull market, a warning about being shaken out. His answer is the point of no concern: sell 25-30% of junior holdings to recover all invested capital. He contrasts this with a "point of no return." He also notes that gold is only about 0.5% of US savings, against a long-run mean he puts at 2%.
On equities, he describes the quality progression from bullion to the best producers and down toward speculative juniors. He says roughly 2,500 of about 3,000 juniors are valueless. For producers he looks at free cash flow per share, using Agnico Eagle as the example, and contrasts today's discipline with 2000-2010, when gold rose six- to sevenfold while per-share cash flow fell.
The most contested section is energy. Rule says oil stocks trade near half of intrinsic value. He claims global underinvestment in sustaining capital of about $2 billion a day, with a supply squeeze possible by 2028. He also rejects peak-demand forecasts for the early 2030s, arguing the peak is 35-40 years away.
Rick Rule argues that despite near-term frothiness in junior gold stocks, gold equities remain fundamentally sound long-term investments due to dollar debasement, while disciplined risk management through capital recovery strategies is essential for retail investors to avoid being shaken out during inevitable cyclical corrections.
- The US dollar will lose 75% of purchasing power over 10 years, creating 3-4x nominal gold price appreciation over the decade
- Selling 25-30% of junior holdings to recover all invested capital lets investors play on 'house money' and avoid capitulation during drawdowns
- Oil stocks now occupy the same opportunity as gold did 7 years ago, selling at half fundamental value with a 'double bump' upside from both sector revaluation and price appreciation
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Oil companies globally (including state-owned enterprises) are underinvesting in sustaining capital by approximately $2 billion per day ($700 billion annually), which will impair production capacity 3-4 years forward when deferred capex effects compound.
“I read a stat the other day, the other day, three three months ago maybe from the International Energy Agency, by the way, no friend of the oil and gas business, uh, which estimates that oil oil companies on a global basis, including paristatals, uh, are underinvesting in sustaining capital to the extent of about $2 billion a day. A day. Think about that. $700 billion a year. When you defer sustaining capital investments, what you do is you impair your ability to produce. Yeah. Three years and four years out.”
In the middle of the 1970s bull market (1975), gold fell by 50% and gold equities fell by more than 60%, illustrating that significant cyclical declines can occur within a secular bull market, shaking out undisciplined investors.
“In the middle of that run in 1975, the gold price fell by half and the gold equities fell by more than 60%. You can have a 50% decline in a secular bull market. Uh a cyclical decline in a secular bull market. There were a lot of people who went into 1975, real hardcore gold bugs, who had their faith shaken and got shaken out.”
In the decade 2000-2010, gold prices increased 6-7 fold while free cash flow per share in mining companies declined, demonstrating that rising commodity prices do not automatically translate to investor returns if management quality is poor.
“in the decade 2000 to 2010, if my memory serves me correctly, the gold price uh increased six or sevenfold and the free cash flow per share in the mining industry declined. It took real skill to screw up a circumstance where the selling price of your product increased sevenfold.”
Among approximately 3,000 junior resource stocks listed worldwide, roughly 2,500 are valueless, though they may appreciate in price short-term due to speculation; stock selection, discipline, and volatility tolerance are critical for junior portfolio success.
“Amongst the juniors, there's probably, I don't know, 3,000 junior resource stocks listed worldwide. I'm going to suggest that 2500 of them are valueless. It doesn't mean that they won't go up in price. That's a different circumstance. Price in the near term is a beauty contest. Uh but they're valueless.”
Companies pursuing growth without per-share accretion, or growing for growth's sake rather than for shareholders' sake, are fundamentally mismanaging capital and will underperform disciplined operators over time.
“They are highly unlikely uh to dilute shareholders in a real business to pursue growth that isn't accretive on a per share basis. Other companies are growing for growth sake not for their shareholders sake or they will be growing for growth sake not for shareholders sake.”
Being concerned about investment premises and market conditions is a hallmark of good investing; the problem is not concern itself but acting from fear or paralysis rather than rational discipline based on personal financial circumstances.
“Well, first of all, let me say that concern is part of becoming a good investor. So, congratulations for being concerned. Uh, always question your premise, always question the market that you're in, always question the information that you're receiving, and always question your process.”
As an investor ages (having invested since 1971), time perspective shifts from impatience (needing quick returns) to patience (willing to wait for structural thesis to play out); older investors can accept delays in inevitable outcomes without anxiety.
“I've been investing now since 1971, I guess. Uh, and what that means is I was very impatient when I was a young guy. I had lots of time left on Earth. Now that I'm an old guy, I'm pretty patient. If you delay the outcome of an inevitability by two years, if you've been doing it for 72 years, it doesn't matter much.”
People suffering from 'trauma holding stock over a long weekend' (extreme short-term orientation) should not expect to achieve five-year triple-digit returns; only investors with extended time horizons and patience can benefit from Rule's secular bull market thesis.
“Your audience, however, doesn't live in 10-year increments or or even fiveyear increments. Many of your audience has trauma holding stock over a long weekend. And for that audience, you have an absolute right to be concerned. The gold equities are on fire.”
A 50% decline in gold prices and over 60% decline in gold equities occurred in 1975 during what was ultimately a secular bull market for gold, illustrating that investors can be shaken out of winning positions by cyclical drawdowns
“In the decade of the 1970s, the gold price ran from $35 an ounce at the beginning of the decade to $850 an ounce at the end of the decade. Pretty good run. In the middle of that run in 1975, the gold price fell by half and the gold equities fell by more than 60%. You can have a 50% decline in a secular bull market. Uh a cyclical decline in a secular bull market. There were a lot of people who went into 1975, real hardcore gold bugs, who had their faith shaken and got shaken out. Those who got shaken out missed a move uh from $100 an ounce at the bottom in 1975 to $850 an ounce.”
AISC (All-In Sustaining Cost) is a metric used by mining companies to report costs; it represents a company's full cost of production including sustaining capital but excluding development capital and corporate overhead.
“Uh they just talk about cash flow and excessive AISC. That's elusory. Uh you have to look at free cash flow uh above uh necessary development expense uh above necessary sustaining capital expense above taxes and royalties and above GNA.”
An alpha-only portfolio (speculative stocks with no market beta foundation) carries the risk that the sector moves but individual stock selection fails, resulting in firm-level losses despite sector gains.
“If you do an alpha only portfolio, your risk is that the sector moves, but you selected stocks poorly, right? And the consequence of that is that you have failure at the firm level and despite the fact that you are right about the sector, you don't get the money.”
Global oil companies, including state-owned enterprises, are underinvesting in sustaining capital to the tune of approximately $2 billion per day (about $700 billion annually), which will impair production capacity 3-4 years forward
“I read a stat the other day, the other day, three three months ago maybe from the International Energy Agency, by the way, no friend of the oil and gas business, uh, which estimates that oil oil companies on a global basis, including paristatals, uh, are underinvesting in sustaining capital to the extent of about $2 billion a day. A day. Think about that. $700 billion a year. When you defer sustaining capital investments, what you do is you impair your ability to produce. Three years and four years out.”
Mainstream predictions of peak oil demand by 2030-2032 are implausible; peak oil demand will likely occur 35-40 years out, with a huge tail of demand extending beyond current net present value modeling horizons.
“the big thinkers of the world tell you that uh oil demand will go the way of the dodo in 2030 or 2032. I would ask them uh if that happens how they will fuel all the private jets that they fly to Davos to tell us to drive less. Um I think peak oil demand doesn't occur in my life may not occur in your life. Uh I think it happens 35 or 40 years out. The importance of that is that when people do net present value curves, they leave the tail off because they don't think there's going to be a tail. I think there's going to be a huge tail.”
Peak oil demand is unlikely to occur within Rule's or Andy's lifetime and may not occur for 35-40 years, meaning there will be a massive long tail of cash flows that most DCF models exclude
“I think peak oil demand doesn't occur in my life may not occur in your life. Uh I think it happens 35 or 40 years out. The importance of that is that when people do net present value curves, they leave the tail off because they don't think there's going to be a tail. I think there's going to be a huge tail.”
The net present value of US entitlement obligations exceeds $120 trillion according to the Congressional Budget Office, while gross federal income is only $5 trillion, making an honest default politically impossible and an inflation-based (dishonest) default inevitable.
“the net present value of entitlement obligations exceeds, according to the Congressional Budget Office, $120 trillion. Gross federal income is $5 trillion. We got two choices. We could do an honest default... or you could do a dishonest default where you pay me the nominal value of my obligation as promised, but you inflate away the net present value”
The distinction between price and value is that price is 'a beauty contest' in the near term (Keynesian concept), while value is the discounted present value of future cash flows; a stock can rise in price while value falls, or vice versa.
“It doesn't mean that they won't go up in price. That's a different circumstance. Price in the near term is a beauty contest.”
The bull market in gold equities has followed a traditional progression: first the bullion, then the best-of-the-best stocks, then the best-of-the-rest, then progression down the quality trail from conservative to speculative, and this progression has occurred in record time with financing windows wide open for juniors.
“The bull market that we've seen, while it's followed a a traditional pattern, which is to say led by the bullion, then by the best of the best, then by the best of the rest, the progression down the quality trail, the con the progression from very conservative to speculative has taken place in record time. Uh the financing windows for juniors isn't open, it's wide open. uh juniors with questionable values are going out to raise $5 million and coming back with 15.”
The US dollar will lose 75% of its absolute purchasing power over the next 10 years due to unfunded entitlement obligations that cannot be honored through honest default, forcing the government to pursue inflation and nominal repayment instead
“My belief is that the US dollar loses 75% of its absolute purchasing power over the next 10 years that is concerning.”
On a net present value basis (calculating future free cash flows at current gold prices), Agnico Eagle is cheaper today than it was 18 months ago despite its share price doubling, because the free cash flow generation at $3,700 gold versus $2,200 gold is materially higher.
“if you look at the shares of the highquality gold companies, the ones that are starting to generate free cash, what you will learn is that on a net present value basis, uh if you define net present value as the future value of free cash flows at today's gold price, Agniko Eagle is cheaper today than it was 18 months ago despite the fact that the share price doubled because the amount amount of free cash that they generate at $3,700 gold relative to the amount of free cash that they generated at $2,200 gold is marketkedly more.”
The distinction between 'point of no concern' (having recovered one's entire invested capital and operating on gains) and 'point of no return' (holding through a bear market with capital at risk) is critical to investor psychology and portfolio management.
“The phrase point of no concern is to differentiate it from holding stocks into a bare market. That's called the point of no return.”
Agnico Eagle's CEO Amara Aljundi articulated the company's core competence as disciplined capital allocation and construction excellence ('blocking and tackling'), committing to acquire and build mines near existing infrastructure to leverage sunk capital rather than pursuing growth for its own sake.
“He also defined their core competence very well. He said they seek to be good, disciplined allocators of capital, but what they really are is a great construction company. They build mines well. You know, they focus like Ohio State used to on blocking and tackling. And he said in the future they aren't going to grow for growth sake, but rather they are going to acquire and build mines in the fairly immediate vicinity of where they have existing infrastructure. Mhm. So that the new deposit provides additional leverage on capital already spent.”
Gold denominated assets comprise only 0.5% (half of 1%) of total US savings and assets, compared to a 40-decade mean of 2%, suggesting that if gold reverted to its historical mean allocation, demand would quadruple.
“JP Morgan Chase said that the market share of precious metals relative to other asset classes in the United States was below 1/ half of 1%, which is to suggest that gold denominated assets comprise 1 half of 1% of the total savings and assets in the United States. The four decade mean market share was 2%. If gold reverted to mean that is to say went from one and a half from one half of 1% to 2% demand for this stuff would quadruple.”
By selling between 25 and 30% of a junior mining portfolio, an investor can recoup all the capital invested in the sector over the past 5 years, reaching what Rule calls the 'point of no concern,' allowing them to play with the house's money on remaining positions.
“What I've learned arithmetically is that by selling between 25 and 30% of my junior portfolio, I recoup all the capital that I put in the sector for 5 years. I reach what I call the point of no concern. I will then be playing on the house's money.”
In quarterly earnings calls, CEOs of top-tier gold miners (Agnico Eagle, Wheaton, Franco Nevada) emphasize growth in free cash flow per share rather than production growth per share, indicating shareholder-friendly capital discipline.
“if you look at Agniko Eagle or Wheat and Precious or Franco Nevada, in my mind, the top three gold mining companies in the world, the CEOs talk about growth uh growth in free cash flow more than they talk about growth in production on a per share basis. They are highly unlikely uh to dilute shareholders in a real business to pursue growth that isn't accretive on a per share basis.”
Newmont's acquisition of Newrest succeeded because institutional investors demanded specific synergies: reduction of general and administrative expense through workforce optimization, segregation of tier 1 vs tier 2 assets, sale of tier 2 assets to reduce debt and sustaining capital obligations, and focus on 10-12 best assets rather than managing many marginal mines.
“In the course of that acquisition, the institutional investors said yes, we'll support it. But we'll support it according to a couple of caveats. Uh one that this merger generate a lot less GNA general and administrative expense... we want less GNA over more free cash flow. The second thing you have to do is you have to segregate between your tier one assets and your tier 2 assets and you have to sell your tier 2 assets... they sold a bunch of assets hoping to raise $2.4 billion or 2.2 I guess if my name serves my memory serves me well. They've raised 4.7 with more on the way.”
By selling between 25 and 30% of a junior portfolio, an investor can recoup all capital invested in the sector over 5 years, reaching what Rule calls the 'point of no concern' where the remaining portfolio plays on 'house money'
“What I've learned arithmetically is that by selling between 25 and 30% of my junior portfolio, I recoup all the capital that I put in the sector for 5 years. I reach what I call the point of no concern. I will then be playing on the house's money.”
The circumstances that make precious metals portfolios perform well are inherently concerning (dollar debasement, fiscal dysfunction, capital controls) but occur regardless of individual investor psychology; confidence in thesis while acknowledging concern is the optimal mindset.
“Precious metals do well when people are concerned uh about the maintenance of the purchasing power of the US dollar. So the fact that you're concerned that the set of circumstances is permissive for gold and silver is right in many regards. The set of circumstances that makes that part of our portfolio do well is in fact concerning.”
When reviewing mining stocks, many commentators focus on AISC (all-in sustaining cost) or project cash flow metrics and ignore taxes, G&A expenses, sustaining capital, and development capital, creating an elusive and misleading picture of true free cash flow.
“Many people define cash flow on a project basis and don't take into account tax or general and administrative expense or sustaining capital expense. They just talk about cash flow and excessive AISC. That's elusory. Uh you have to look at free cash flow uh above uh necessary development expense uh above necessary sustaining capital expense above taxes and royalties and above GNA.”
Investors should build energy portfolios by first buying 'best of the best' and 'best of the rest' companies to capture sector beta (outperformance vs broad market), before pursuing alpha through junior or higher-risk positions, as an alpha-only strategy risks firm-level selection failures.
“I always believe that you start a portfolio with the best of the best. In other words, you buy the market beta, uh the best of the best. And as you've populated the market beta, uh market beta defined as the outperformance of that sector relative to the broad market, uh then you can become more speculative with the rest of your portfolio. You look to generate alpha. If you do an alpha only portfolio, your risk is that the sector moves, but you selected stocks poorly, right? And the consequence of that is that you have failure at the firm level and despite the fact that you are right about the sector, you don't get the money.”
If an inevitable outcome is delayed by 2 years after 53 years of investing, it makes little difference to an investor near end of life, but this math does not apply to younger investors who need different time horizons and trading styles.
“if you delay the outcome of an inevitability by two years, if you've been doing it for 72 years, it doesn't matter much. You know, you sort of hope that you're going to be alive. There's a delay. Uh, so people who are traders, people who have trauma holding stock over a long weekend probably don't want to invest like me.”
People interested in five-year triples (300% returns) in good companies are suitable candidates for Rule's investment approach of deploying long-term capital with patience, whereas traders and short-term investors are not.
“people who are interested in five-year triples with big good companies probably do need to consider investing like me.”
Oil stocks are currently where gold stocks were seven years ago, selling at approximately half their fundamental value at $65 WTI, offering a 'double bump' of upside from both price appreciation and sector revaluation.
“I think the oil stocks are where the gold stocks were seven years ago. Um, I think that the industry as a whole is selling at about half of its fundamental value and I think the value is going to increase. Uh I mean I'm talking about the fact I think it's selling at half its value at $65 WTI. Uh I think WTI is going much higher. Uh and I think the industry is selling at half its value at $65 WTI. So I think you get if you will a double bump.”
Younger institutional investors in gold mining are already pressuring company CEOs to grow faster and be more aggressive with cash, which contradicts the 2000-2010 'growth gold' philosophy but may represent excessive pressure if it leads to non-accretive acquisitions.
“I am already hearing from mining industry CEOs that younger institutional investors are saying grow for Christ's sakes grow. In other words, they're asking them to be much more aggressive with the cash. In the decade 2000 to 2010, there was a phrase growth gold. Well, that turned out to be an oxymoron.”
Oil and gas stocks are currently trading at approximately 50% of fundamental value at $65 WTI (West Texas Intermediate crude), and Rule describes them as being at the same relative valuation point that gold stocks were 7 years ago.
“I think the oil stocks are where the gold stocks were seven years ago. Um, I think that the industry as a whole is selling at about half of its fundamental value and I think the value is going to increase. Uh I mean I'm talking about the fact I think it's selling at half its value at $65 WTI.”
Participation in the gold market in the broad economy is still negligible; most financial planners would struggle to spell 'gold,' indicating the sector remains a niche community rather than mainstream adoption.
“I would point out to you that participation in the gold market in the broad economy is still nil... Most investors, I'm sure if you went to a financial planner in Atlanta or somewhere like that, the average financial planner, right, uh he or she would have a difficult difficult time spelling gold.”
Management teams that presided over poor capital allocation during 2000-2010 gold boom were largely removed by shareholders, but institutional investors are now keeping remaining companies on a tight leash to prevent repeat of past mistakes, enforcing discipline around capital deployment.
“Virtually all of the management teams who presided over that idiocy were allowed to pursue other employment opportunities, which is to say they were fired by shareholders... the big institutional investors in the gold space. My friend John Hathaway as an example uh are keeping the companies on a pretty tight leash right now. They don't want to see a repetition of the idiocy uh of that decade.”
Concern about being right is a positive sign of investor discipline; the best investors question their premises, markets, and processes while investing rationally to improve family security rather than being paralyzed by fear.
“first of all, let me say that concern is part of becoming a good investor. So, congratulations for being concerned. Uh, always question your premise, always question the market that you're in, always question the information that you're receiving, and always question your process... Your job, Andy, is to make his family more secure. And you do that uh not by being terrified, not by being so afraid that you lie in fetal position in the corner and don't do anything, but rather that you act uh rationally both in the context of the market, but also in the context of how you want the market to behave for you.”
Even after 50 years of professional mining stock market experience, Rule reaches points where sector volatility forces him to reduce leverage and take capital off the table, suggesting that less experienced or educated investors should manage risk more defensively than he does.
“Even me uh who has now 50 years experience in the mining stock market reaches the point in time where he decides that the sector is so volatile that he needs to take his capital out. Uh notice I didn't say all sell all the stocks. I'm going to repeat this. Take my capital out. If I need to take my capital out, I'm an old fat rich guy. uh people who work less hard, people who have less education in the sector need to manage their risk better than I.”
High-quality oil companies that are making sustaining capital investments will be able to produce in 2028 when peers cannot, creating a competitive advantage and justifying a focus on quality names rather than juniors in the energy sector.
“what that means is that you need to invest in high-quality companies that are in fact making the sustaining capital investments that will be able to produce in 2028 when their peers can't.”
By taking all capital off the table and operating on 'house money,' Rule becomes extraordinarily patient and emotionally able to hold through cyclical declines that would otherwise shake him out
“By taking all of my money off the table, I will not be shaken out. Uh when I'm operating on the house's money, if I believe my thesis is sound, I become extraordinarily patient.”
Almost all mining company management teams that presided over poor capital allocation in 2000-2010 were fired by shareholders, and institutional investors are now keeping companies on a tight leash to prevent repetition of that idiocy
“Virtually all of the management teams who presided over that idiocy were allowed to pursue other employment opportunities, which is to say they were fired by shareholders. Uh the big institutional investors in the gold space. My friend John Hathaway as an example uh are keeping the companies on a pretty tight leash right now. They don't want to see a repetition of the idiocy uh of that decade.”
Newmont's Barrick merger (referred to as Newmont acquiring Newrest) succeeded because institutional investors mandated specific synergy actions: cutting duplicative general and administrative expenses, segregating tier-1 and tier-2 assets, selling tier-2 assets to reduce debt and sustaining capital needs, and focusing on 10-12 best mines
“We want less GNA over more free cash flow. The second thing you have to do is you have to segregate between your tier one assets and your tier 2 assets and you have to sell your tier 2 assets to bring down aggregate debt but also to limit the sustaining capital investments you have to make to your 10 or 12 best minds and you have to focus on your 10 or 12 best minds. And the management team did that. The management team worked out synergies.”
Agnico Eagle's core competence is being a 'construction company'—a great builder of mines—and the company intends to acquire and build mines near existing infrastructure to provide additional leverage on capital already spent, representing a narrowly defined but highly disciplined vision
“He also defined their core competence very well. He said they seek to be good, disciplined allocators of capital, but what they really are is a great construction company. They build mines well. You know, they focus like Ohio State used to on blocking and tackling. And he said in the future they aren't going to grow for growth sake, but rather they are going to acquire and build mines in the fairly immediate vicinity of where they have existing infrastructure. So that the new deposit provides additional leverage on capital already spent.”
Eric Sprott (who acquired Rule's business) told Rule that his primary weakness was being 'afraid to be right'—specifically, that when micro-level circumstances around individual firms proved correct, Rule hesitated to commit fully, preventing full benefit from correct ideas.
“when uh Eric Sprat bought my business and I became part of Sprat, uh I remember having very deep conversations with Eric and I said, you know, Eric, as an investor, what would you see as the flaws in my style? He said, Rick, you're afraid to be right.”
Precious metals appreciate when people are concerned about the maintenance of US dollar purchasing power, making the interviewer's concerns about inflation and debasement economically permissive for gold and silver to perform well.
“the truth is that being right around the precious metals narrative involves concern. Precious metals do well when people are concerned uh about the maintenance of the purchasing power of the US dollar. So the fact that you're concerned that the set of circumstances is permissive for gold and silver is right in many regards.”
Most financial planners would struggle to spell 'gold,' indicating that gold is not integrated into mainstream investment advice and investor portfolios are structurally underweight precious metals
“Most investors, I'm sure if you went to a financial planner in Atlanta or somewhere like that, the average financial planner, right, uh he or she would have a difficult difficult time spelling gold.”
Gold mining companies that are starting to generate free cash flow are cheaper on a net present value basis today than 18 months ago despite doubling in share price, because the amount of free cash generated at current $3,700 gold is markedly higher than at $2,200 gold
“If you look at the shares of the highquality gold companies, the ones that are starting to generate free cash, what you will learn is that on a net present value basis, uh if you define net present value as the future value of free cash flows at today's gold price, Agniko Eagle is cheaper today than it was 18 months ago despite the fact that the share price doubled because the amount amount of free cash that they generate at $3,700 gold relative to the amount of free cash that they generated at $2,200 gold is marketkedly more.”
The phrase 'point of no concern' differs from 'point of no return' in that it describes a position where capital is fully recovered and remaining positions are pure upside, allowing the investor to act rationally from a position of security rather than desperation.
“The phrase point of no concern is to differentiate it from holding stocks into a bare market. That's called the point of no return. Uh I have the ability by selling some of my portfolio which I'm doing now to give up between 25 and 30% of my upside in turn for reducing 100% of my downside including the capital gains tax.”
When operating on 'house money' (positions funded by recovered capital gains), an investor becomes extraordinarily patient if he believes his thesis is sound, allowing him to weather cyclical drawdowns within secular bull markets.
“By taking all of my money off the table, I will not be shaken out. Uh when I'm operating on the house's money, if I believe my thesis is sound, I become extraordinarily patient.”
Eric Sprat (Rule's former business partner/investor) once told Rule that his primary weakness was 'being afraid to be right'—hesitating to hold conviction when the micro-level facts around his investments were correct.
“when uh Eric Sprat bought my business and I became part of Sprat, uh I remember having very deep conversations with Eric and I said, you know, Eric, as an investor, what would you see as the flaws in my style? He said, Rick, you're afraid to be right. Uh when the set of circumstances uh particularly micro circumstances around the firms that you're investing in is correct go”
Even Rule, with 50 years of mining stock market experience, reaches points where sector volatility requires him to take capital off the table, implying that less-experienced investors need stronger risk management than he does
“Even me uh who has now 50 years experience in the mining stock market reaches the point in time where he decides that the sector is so volatile that he needs to take his capital out. Uh notice I didn't say all sell all the stocks. I'm going to repeat this. Take my capital out. If I need to take my capital out, I'm an old fat rich guy. uh people who work less hard, people who have less education in the sector need to manage their risk better than I.”
Among approximately 3,000 junior resource stocks listed worldwide, roughly 2,500 are essentially valueless, though price may still rise in the near term due to speculative momentum ('beauty contest')
“Amongst the juniors, there's probably, I don't know, 3,000 junior resource stocks listed worldwide. I'm going to suggest that 2500 of them are valueless. It doesn't mean that they won't go up in price. That's a different circumstance. Price in the near term is a beauty contest.”
Investors should start oil portfolios with 'best of best' companies to capture market beta (sector outperformance), then become speculative with alpha-focused positions, as alpha-only portfolios risk firm-level selection failure despite being right about the sector
“I always believe that you start a portfolio with the best of the best. In other words, you buy the market beta, uh market beta defined as the outperformance of that sector relative to the broad market, uh then you can become more speculative with the rest of your portfolio. You look to generate alpha. If you do an alpha only portfolio, your risk is that the sector moves, but you selected stocks poorly, and the consequence of that is that you have failure at the firm level and despite the fact that you are right about the sector, you don't get the money.”
The circumstances of the 1970s—when the dollar lost 75% of purchasing power—have reappeared: significant internal and external conflict, money printing, and taxation, validating the gold thesis for the current environment.
“it really gold and silver have really I think indicated that help me work through that are what are your thoughts on where we're at in dealing with what we're going into what we seem to be going into... a lot of uh internal and external conflict in the world a lot of money printing in the world a lot of uh taxation in the world everything and it really gold and silver have really I think indicated that”
Rule is moderating his addition to oil and gas positions due to mild recession concerns that could dampen near-term oil demand and postpone the inevitable oil stock boom.
“It wouldn't surprise me if we enter into a deeper recession which will moderate demand for oil and which will postpone the oil stock boom that's inevitable. Uh, so I'm moderating the way I add to my oil and gas position because I'm a little afraid of the economy.”
The financing windows for junior mining companies are wide open, with juniors of questionable value able to raise $15 million when targeting $5 million, indicating speculative excess and near-term market risk in the sector.
“juniors with questionable values are going out to raise $5 million and coming back with 15. That means in the near term this market is concerning to me.”
Rule believes the US dollar will lose 75% of its absolute purchasing power over the next 10 years, measured in real terms, not relative to other currencies, which would support 3-4x nominal gold price appreciation over the same period.
“My belief is that the US dollar loses 75% of its absolute purchasing power over the next 10 years”
Younger institutional investors are now pushing mining CEOs to grow aggressively, but the best companies (Agnico Eagle, Wheaton, Franco Nevada) talk about growth in free cash flow per share rather than production, and resist dilutive acquisitions
“I am already hearing from mining industry CEOs that younger institutional investors are saying grow for Christ's sakes grow. In other words, they're asking them to be much more aggressive with the cash. Uh if you look at Agniko Eagle or Wheat and Precious or Franco Nevada, in my mind, the top three gold mining companies in the world, the CEOs talk about growth uh growth in free cash flow more than they talk about growth in production on a per share basis. They are highly unlikely uh to dilute shareholders in a real business to pursue growth that isn't accretive on a per share basis.”
Gold prices rose 30-fold in the 1970s when the dollar lost 75% of purchasing power, so Rule does not expect similar gains from current levels since gold has already risen 12-13 fold since 2000, but a 3-4 fold rise in nominal terms over the next 10 years is reasonable
“It wouldn't surprise me over 10 years, to see the gold price in nominal terms, not real terms, but nominal terms, rise three or four-fold.”
The oil and gas sector is so deeply undervalued cyclically at current prices that investors can generate substantial returns by buying quality major and mid-tier names without needing to pursue junior positions.
“The oil and gas sector is so deeply undervalued cycllically that you don't need to go down into the juniors. Uh I suggest that you buy the best of the best. You buy the best of the rest and you don't worry too much about the juniors despite the fact that the juniors is where I cut my teeth.”
The oil and gas sector is so deeply undervalued cyclically that investors can focus on 'best of best' and 'best of rest' without needing to venture into junior companies
“The oil and gas sector is so deeply undervalued cycllically that you don't need to go down into the juniors. Uh I suggest that you buy the best of the best. You buy the best of the rest and you don't worry too much about the juniors despite the fact that the juniors is where I cut my teeth.”
An investor using a heuristic approach (reading newsletters, listening to podcasts, betting on intuition) has roughly a 1-in-5 chance of junior mining stock success, which are poor odds
“If your technique is to read too many newsletters and listen to too many podcasts and then on a hunch bet a bunch uh you have a one in five chance of being successful, right? Pretty lousy, right?”
Without deep knowledge of and discipline in junior mining stock selection, an investor using a heuristic approach of reading newsletters and betting on hunches has approximately a one-in-five chance (20%) of success.
“if your technique is to read too many newsletters and listen to too many podcasts and then on a hunch bet a bunch uh you have a one in five chance of being successful, right? Pretty lousy, right?”
After a long hiatus, the best gold mining companies are generating free cash flow yields comparable to or better than they were in 1978-1979, a level not seen for approximately 40 years.
“the free cash flow yields that you're seeing in the gold mining industry right now among the best of the best are as good or better as they were in 1978 or 1979. We haven't seen this level of free cash flow literally for 40 years.”
Gold has already appreciated 12-13x since 2000, so investors should not expect another 30-fold return from current levels; the historical 1970s parallel suggests 3-4x nominal returns over the next 10 years as a more realistic target.
“It's important to note that since 2000, the gold price has already run 12 or 13fold. So don't be looking for a 30 for a 30-fold return from here.”
The bull market in gold equities has followed a traditional pattern: led first by bullion, then by the best companies, then by middle-tier companies, and finally speculative juniors, and this progression has occurred in record time
“The bull market that we've seen, while it's followed a a traditional pattern, which is to say led by the bullion, then by the best of the best, then by the best of the rest, the progression down the quality trail, the con the progression from very conservative to speculative has taken place in record time.”
Broad market participation in gold remains minimal, with precious metals comprising less than 0.5% of total US savings and assets, well below the 2% four-decade mean, suggesting that if gold reverted to mean market share, demand would quadruple
“JP Morgan Chase said that the market share of precious metals relative to other asset classes in the United States was below 1/ half of 1%, which is to suggest that gold denominated assets comprise 1 half of 1% of the total savings and assets in the United States. The four decade mean market share was 2%. If gold reverted to mean that is to say went from one and a half from one half of 1% to 2% demand for this stuff would quadruple.”
A deeper recession would moderate oil demand and postpone the inevitable oil stock boom, so Rule is moderating his rate of adding to oil positions due to economic concerns
“It wouldn't surprise me if we enter into a deeper recession which will moderate demand for oil and which will postpone the oil stock boom that's inevitable. Uh, so I'm moderating the way I add to my oil and gas position because I'm a little afraid of the economy.”
The financing window for junior mining companies is currently very wide open, with marginal juniors able to raise $15 million after planning for only $5 million, indicating excessive capital chasing weak opportunities
“The financing windows for juniors isn't open, it's wide open. uh juniors with questionable values are going out to raise $5 million and coming back with 15.”
The interviewer (Andy) believes gold equities will perform well long-term but is uncomfortable with near-term sector frothiness and has been selling alongside Rule for the past 6-8 weeks, suggesting shared thesis and risk management approach.
“I just see it getting very it's very frothy and I'm very uncomfortable is what I would say...I'm not uncomfortable long term at all...Uh you mentioned before we went on the air that you're starting to get calls from people uh inquiring about gold...we've been selling and I still have a lot of gold stocks...I'm not negative by any means longer term on the sector I'm not even I would I would I don't even would say I'm negative short term. I just see it getting very it's very frothy and I'm very uncomfortable is what I would say.”
Mlette is deploying capital into oil and gas, and he finds deep value in the sector, making it the only sector he sees offering true deep value in an otherwise inflated asset environment.
“I see the best value and it I see it as really really almost deep value. Uh the only sector that I see currently again this is my own opinion is in the oil and gas um the oil and gas sector if you would. Um I love it in here.”
Gold mining equities will likely generate a 500% nominal return over the next 10 years, though this is a supposition and theory rather than fact, unlike the factual point that selling 25-30% of junior holdings recovers 100% of invested capital.
“I believe that the gold equities over 10 years likely, I'm not saying certainly because I don't know, likely generate a 500% nominal return over 10 years. Uh my supposition, my theory uh is not a fact. Uh the fact that I can sell 25 to 30% of my junior portfolio and recoup 100% of my invested capital is fact.”
The interviewer (Andy Mlette) has been a student of natural resources for 30 years and has worked hard to build expertise that he is now sharing with his audience.
“you've worked hard for 30 years as a student, and I'm delighted that you're sharing the benefits of that with your audience”
Rule's investment process has evolved from being 'afraid to be right' (per Sprott's feedback) to becoming more confident in his convictions, and his current strategy reflects greater willingness to maintain positions when thesis-level analysis is correct.
“I'm delighted to hear you express concern. Uh I think that uh the process of being concerned is what makes somebody a good investor.”
The interviewer (Andy) fully endorses Rule's educational products and has benefited immensely from them, having attended the conference and finding it 'life-changing,' and recommends them to all viewers and listeners.
“I fully endorse all of the above pro products and that is a recommendation that is coming from me. I've participated in all and I'm very and benefited immensely from all...It's life-changing, and I'm not exaggerating.”
In 40 years of selling financial education products with money-back guarantees, Rule has had to refund approximately one-tenth of 1% of tuitions charged, suggesting high customer satisfaction with his offerings.
“every financial product I've ever sold, every financial education product I've sold over 40 years of selling them comes with an absolute money back guarantee... In 40 years of offering these money back guarantees, I've had to refund about onetenth of 1% of the tuitions charged”
John Hathaway is a dean among institutional investors in gold who has maintained a focus on the sector for 40 years, providing continuity of perspective and institutional discipline in the industry.
“We have John Hathaway who's been a dean among institutional investors in gold for 40 years. Not some Johnny come lately.”
Rule offers free portfolio ranking services through Rule Investment Media, where listeners can list their natural resource stocks and receive a 1-10 ranking (1 best, 10 worst) with commentary, covering about 800 companies in the database.
“any of your listeners who want can go to my website, Rule Investment Media, list their natural resource stocks, uh, and we'll rank them one to 10, one being best, 10 being worst, and we'll comment on individual issues if you think our comments have value... There's a team that does this. Uh, and that service is absolutely free. Please, no crypto. Please, no pot stocks. Please, no tech stocks. Just resource stocks. Rule investment media. List your natural resource portfolio.”
Rule offers a free Rule Classroom with over 200 hours of instructional content, a free weekly Q&A session, discussion groups, and a 'boot camp' program ($99 for 8 hours of intensive training, quarterly, with topics like uranium, silver, prospect generators, and single-asset producers).
“the rule classroom uh which is an educational service and basic membership there which is enjoyed now by 15,000 people is also free. There are over 200 hours of instructional programming including uh the introduction to natural resource investing... free. again, ironclad money back guarantee, discussion groups, interviews, free question and answer every week”
The upcoming boot camp on rest of the gold sector (single asset producers, junior producers, developers, explorers) features a faculty with combined 160+ years of experience including John Hathaway (40 years), Adrian Day (40 years), Jonathan Goodman (second generation gold investor), and Lobo Tigra (25 years junior experience).
“We have John Hathaway who's been a dean among institutional investors in gold for 40 years. Not some Johnny come lately. We have Adrien Day who's also been around for 40 years. Uh we have Jonathan Goodman who's in the space, second generation gold guy. His dad was one of my mentors, Ned Goodman. Uh we have Lobo Tigra covering the juniors. Somebody he's the newcomer. He's only got 25 years boots on the ground experience.”
Rule's annual conference in Boca Raton provides 45-48 hours of programming over 4 days, with over 700 attendees to the live event and only 2 refund requests, indicating strong perceived value.
“my annual conference in Boca Raton, Florida. uh you can attend live which I would prefer because there's lots of non-verbal communication takes place or you can take place you can participate from the comfort and convenience of your own home via liveream in either case we're going to work you for 4 days not one day uh you're going to endure between 45 and 48 hours of programming in 4 days... This year we had over 700 attendees to the live portion. We had two refund requests.”
Rule's past Boca Raton annual conference attracted over 700 live attendees with only 2 refund requests, demonstrating high participant satisfaction despite demanding (4 days, 45-48 hours) programming.
“By the way, this year we had over 700 attendees to the live portion. We had two refund requests. Uh that'll tell you that the audience believed despite the fact that we worked them like trolls, uh that they got their money's worth.”
Rule offers four levels of investor interaction: free portfolio rankings (800 companies tracked), free Rule Classroom with 200+ hours of instructional content, quarterly paid boot camps with 8 hours of expert instruction, and annual Boca Raton conference with 45-48 hours of programming
“There are at least three ways to interact with me. The first, the gateway drug, if you will, Andy, uh, is that any of your listeners who want can go to my website, Rule Investment Media, list their natural resource stocks, uh, and we'll rank them one to 10, one being best, 10 being worst, and we'll comment on individual issues if you think our comments have value.”
Andy has been working as a student for 30 years, learning investment principles, and is now sharing the benefits of that work with his audience through interviews and educational content
“Thank you, Andy, and thank you uh uh as a consequence of your efforts on behalf of your audience. You've worked hard for 30 years as a student, and I'm delighted that you're sharing sharing the benefits of that with your audience.”