What this covers

This is a short interview-style talk, about seven minutes, in which clinician Frank Yeomans describes what it is like to live inside malignant narcissism. Yeomans practices Transference-Focused Psychotherapy and was mentored by Otto Kernberg. The questions come from the BorderlinerNotes channel, and the speaker is not named in the transcript. The framing questions are what the experience is like, whether the narcissistic defense actually relieves the person's internal emptiness, and why such a person would ever enter therapy. The answers are offered cautiously. Yeomans says it is hard to fully enter the subjective experience of someone with this condition, so much of what he says is informed speculation. He suggests the defense may gratify when self-deception works well, but it is unclear whether it truly spares the person the sense of emptiness or only does so some of the time.

The range is narrow but varied. One strand concerns the fragile wish for connection. Yeomans argues that malignant narcissists doubt they have anything to offer, so they inflate themselves and seek admiration where they might better seek love. Another strand is the substance-abuse link: when the grandiose narrative cracks and doubt enters, substances wash it away. Those whose grandiosity stays intact may not develop addiction. He also says the more a person escapes inadequacy, the less they are in touch with reality, and that extreme narcissism borders on psychosis. From this he argues that substance-abuse treatment would improve if it assessed for personality disorders.

The most pointed turn is the contrast with the sociopath, whom he treats as roughly synonymous with the psychopath. A sociopath has no concern for anyone, so there is no conflict to work with. Yeomans also sorts families around a malignant narcissist into two kinds. In one, a partner with a masochistic streak absorbs the behavior until the children can leave. In the other, relationships rest on mutual exploitation and power. He doubts that a family organized around adoring the narcissist could hold together, since the aggression would tear at it.

Sharpest takeaway

Malignant narcissism differs fundamentally from sociopathy in that narcissists retain an internal conflict between desire for connection and aggressive defenses, whereas sociopaths lack any desire for emotional connection, making narcissists amenable to therapy while sociopaths are not.

  • Malignant narcissists experience internal conflict between wish to connect and aggressive drives; sociopaths have only aggression without relational desire
  • This internal conflict in narcissists creates therapeutic leverage, whereas sociopaths' lack of conflict means exploitation causes them no distress
  • Narcissists may seek therapy due to ego-dystonicity (discomfort with their condition) or family pressure, showing awareness that their behavior impedes life success

The claims · ranked36 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.75

The desire for connection in malignant narcissists is very fragile because they don't think they have anything to offer, so they don't expect relations are going to work out very well, which causes them to puff themselves up and seek admiration where one might better seek love

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Malignant Narcissist's Internal World | FRANK YEOMANS [-AeWDcJaENc]

“that desire for connection is very fragile because since they don't think they have anything to offer they don't expect that relations are going to work out very well therefore they puff themselves up and seek admiration where one might better seek love”

0.75

Some malignant narcissists who maintain intact grandiosity without fault lines threatening the system do not develop substance abuse, in contrast to those whose narcissistic defenses have breaches

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Malignant Narcissist's Internal World | FRANK YEOMANS [-AeWDcJaENc]

“in contrast to somebody who manages to keep the grandiosity intact and doesn't have those fault lines that are threatening to the whole system”

0.75

In a significant number of people with substance abuse, underlying personality disorder issues are not adequately addressed, and including assessments for personality disorders would improve outcomes with the substance abuse population

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Malignant Narcissist's Internal World | FRANK YEOMANS [-AeWDcJaENc]

“in a significant number of people with substance abuse these personality disorder issues are not adequately addressed and if we're to do better with our substance abuse population we should include assessments for underlying personality disorders”

0.75

Malignant narcissists, even though caught up in defense of grandiosity, usually can care about another person—relations can matter to them and they do seem to have some urge and desire for connection to others

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Malignant Narcissist's Internal World | FRANK YEOMANS [-AeWDcJaENc]

“malignant narcissists even though they are caught up in this defense of grandiosity they usually can care about another person putting it differently relations can matter they do seem to have some urge some desire for connection to others”

0.75

In the malignant narcissist there is internal conflict between the wish to connect and opposing aggressive drives, whereas in the sociopath there is aggression and exploitativeness but it doesn't seem to be combined with any desire to have emotional connection with anybody else, so there is no conflict

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Malignant Narcissist's Internal World | FRANK YEOMANS [-AeWDcJaENc]

“at least in the malignant narcissist there's some internal conflict between that wish to connect and the opposing aggressive drives that's why there's hope in therapy for the malignant narcissist you have a conflict to deal with in the sociopath there's the aggression there's the exploitativeness but it doesn't seem to be combined with any desire to have any kind of emotional connection with anybody else so you don't have a conflict”

0.75

There is a link between extreme narcissism and substance abuse because when the person cannot sustain their delusional grandiose narrative and doubt enters in, substance is needed to wash away the doubt and the anxiety that goes with it

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Malignant Narcissist's Internal World | FRANK YEOMANS [-AeWDcJaENc]

“there's also a link with substance abuse because the person can't sustain their delusional grandiose narrative and when the doubt enters in sometimes the substance is needed to sort of wash away the doubt and the anxiety that goes with it”

0.75

Clinical cases show two categories of families with malignant narcissists: first, families where the partner has a masochistic streak and tolerates the narcissist's behavior while children remain until they can leave, and second, families where everyone is in it for mutual exploitation with connections based on exploitation and power grabbing rather than love and concern

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Malignant Narcissist's Internal World | FRANK YEOMANS [-AeWDcJaENc]

“the only cases i've seen i would say would fall into two categories the people who've come to treatment sometimes come from marriages where the partner has a quite a masochistic streak and so we'll tolerate the kind of things i've been describing and the children may just have no choice but to stay in the family until they can leave and i'm happy to say i've seen progress in patients like that and the achievement of relative harmony in the family the other kind of family is one where everybody is in it for mutual exploitation where it just seems like the connections are based on exploitation and power grabbing not anything we would say looked like love and concern”

0.75

In malignant narcissists there is internal conflict between the wish to connect and opposing aggressive drives, whereas in sociopaths there is aggression and exploitativeness without any desire for emotional connection, which means sociopaths do not have the conflict that creates therapeutic leverage.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Malignant Narcissist's Internal World | FRANK YEOMANS [-AeWDcJaENc]

“at least in the malignant narcissist there's some internal conflict between that wish to connect and the opposing aggressive drives that's why there's hope in therapy for the malignant narcissist you have a conflict to deal with in the sociopath there's the aggression there's the exploitativeness but it doesn't seem to be combined with any desire to have any kind of emotional connection with anybody else so you don't have a conflict”

0.75

There is a link between malignant narcissism and substance abuse, because when the person cannot sustain their delusional grandiose narrative and doubt enters in, substances are used to wash away the doubt and anxiety that accompanies it.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Malignant Narcissist's Internal World | FRANK YEOMANS [-AeWDcJaENc]

“there's also a link with substance abuse because the person can't sustain their delusional grandiose narrative and when the doubt enters in sometimes the substance is needed to sort of wash away the doubt and the anxiety that goes with it”

0.75

A sociopath, which is pretty synonymous with the psychopath, literally has no concern about any other person on the planet, whereas malignant narcissists can care about another person and have some urge or desire for connection to others, even though it is very fragile.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Malignant Narcissist's Internal World | FRANK YEOMANS [-AeWDcJaENc]

“a sociopath which i think is pretty synonymous with the psychopath literally has no concern about any other person on the planet interestingly malignant narcissists even though they are caught up in this defense of grandiosity they usually can care about another person putting it differently relations can matter they do seem to have some urge some desire for connection to others”

0.71

The more malignant narcissists escape from anxiety and the sense of inadequacy, the less they are in touch with reality, and extreme narcissism borders on psychosis

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Malignant Narcissist's Internal World | FRANK YEOMANS [-AeWDcJaENc]

“the interesting thing is the more they escape from the anxiety and the sense of inadequacy the less they're in touch with reality extreme narcissism borders on psychosis”

0.71

It is unclear whether the defensive system and grandiose narrative of a malignant narcissist truly relieves them of the horror of internal emptiness, or if it only works some of the time, because it's difficult to fully understand the subjective experience of someone with this condition

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Malignant Narcissist's Internal World | FRANK YEOMANS [-AeWDcJaENc]

“it's never clear to me at least at the start with a patient if their defensive system their grandiose narrative truly relieves them of the horror of the internal emptiness or if it works some of the time it's hard to enter into like total contact with the subjective experience of somebody like that so we can only speculate”

0.71

Malignant narcissists do not think they have anything to offer others, so they don't expect relations to work out well; therefore they puff themselves up and seek admiration where they might better seek love.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Malignant Narcissist's Internal World | FRANK YEOMANS [-AeWDcJaENc]

“since they don't think they have anything to offer they don't expect that relations are going to work out very well therefore they puff themselves up and seek admiration where one might better seek love”

0.71

The more a malignant narcissist escapes from anxiety and the sense of inadequacy through their defenses, the less they are in touch with reality; extreme narcissism borders on psychosis.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Malignant Narcissist's Internal World | FRANK YEOMANS [-AeWDcJaENc]

“the more they escape from the anxiety and the sense of inadequacy the less they're in touch with reality extreme narcissism borders on psychosis”

0.69

A sociopath, which is pretty synonymous with a psychopath, literally has no concern about any other person on the planet

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Malignant Narcissist's Internal World | FRANK YEOMANS [-AeWDcJaENc]

“a sociopath which i think is pretty synonymous with the psychopath literally has no concern about any other person on the planet”

0.69

In a sociopath, there is no internal conflict because they have aggression and exploitativeness without any desire for emotional connection, making them totally fine with exploiting, hurting, damaging others and perhaps getting pleasure out of it

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Malignant Narcissist's Internal World | FRANK YEOMANS [-AeWDcJaENc]

“a person is totally fine exploiting hurting damaging others perhaps getting pleasure out of it”

0.69

Some malignant narcissists have at least some ego dystonicity about their condition—they are not totally happy with it and realize it's impeding their effort to have a more successful life, which creates an urge within the person to seek treatment

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Malignant Narcissist's Internal World | FRANK YEOMANS [-AeWDcJaENc]

“some people themselves realize let's put it this way in the professional parlance they have at least some ego dystonicity about their condition they're not totally happy with it they realize it's impeding their effort to have any kind of a more successful life so there is sometimes that urge within the person”

0.69

For a malignant narcissist, there can be some semblance of a family if the family is organized to worship and adore the narcissist, but this is difficult to imagine because the aggression that gets played out would tear at the family fabric

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Malignant Narcissist's Internal World | FRANK YEOMANS [-AeWDcJaENc]

“is there really such a thing as family for someone who's in malignant narcissism or well if the family is organized to worship and adore the militant narcissist there can be some semblance of a family but it's hard to imagine because the aggression that gets played out would so tear at the family fabric”

0.69

Progress and relative harmony have been achieved in families with malignant narcissists when the partner has masochistic traits and children can eventually leave the family

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Malignant Narcissist's Internal World | FRANK YEOMANS [-AeWDcJaENc]

“i'm happy to say i've seen progress in patients like that and the achievement of relative harmony in the family”

0.69

In a significant number of people with substance abuse disorder, underlying personality disorders including narcissism are not adequately assessed or addressed, and better treatment outcomes would result from including personality disorder assessments in substance abuse treatment protocols.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Malignant Narcissist's Internal World | FRANK YEOMANS [-AeWDcJaENc]

“in a significant number of people with substance abuse these personality disorder issues are not adequately addressed and if we're to do better with our substance abuse population we should include assessments for underlying personality disorders”

0.69

If a family is organized to worship and adore the malignant narcissist, there can be some semblance of a family, but it is hard to imagine this working because the aggression that gets played out would tear at the family fabric.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Malignant Narcissist's Internal World | FRANK YEOMANS [-AeWDcJaENc]

“if the family is organized to worship and adore the militant narcissist there can be some semblance of a family but it's hard to imagine because the aggression that gets played out would so tear at the family fabric”

0.69

Some people with malignant narcissism have at least some ego-dystonicity about their condition—they are not totally happy with it and realize it is impeding their effort to have a more successful life, which sometimes creates an urge within the person to seek help.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Malignant Narcissist's Internal World | FRANK YEOMANS [-AeWDcJaENc]

“in the professional parlance they have at least some ego dystonicity about their condition they're not totally happy with it they realize it's impeding their effort to have any kind of a more successful life so there is sometimes that urge within the person if it's not the family sending them”

0.66

It is hard to enter into total contact with the subjective experience of somebody with malignant narcissism, so we can only speculate about their internal state.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Malignant Narcissist's Internal World | FRANK YEOMANS [-AeWDcJaENc]

“it's hard to enter into like total contact with the subjective experience of somebody like that so we can only speculate”

0.65

Sometimes malignant narcissists give the impression of having a sense of satisfaction, which may be true, but most often one suspects that underneath they are plagued by doubt, insecurity, and anxiety

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Malignant Narcissist's Internal World | FRANK YEOMANS [-AeWDcJaENc]

“some of the times the person gives the impression of having a sense of satisfaction and that may be true most often one suspects that underneath they're plagued by doubt insecurity anxiety”

0.65

If a malignant narcissist is able to delude themselves adequately, their subjective experience may be gratifying to them, but they are almost or perhaps in a world of their own

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Malignant Narcissist's Internal World | FRANK YEOMANS [-AeWDcJaENc]

“if the person is able to delude him or herself adequately maybe their subjective experience is gratifying to them but they're almost or perhaps are in a world of their own”

0.65

In sociopaths, aggression and exploitativeness seem to cause no distress because there is no conflicting desire for connection; a sociopath is totally fine exploiting, hurting, damaging others, and perhaps even gets pleasure out of it.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Malignant Narcissist's Internal World | FRANK YEOMANS [-AeWDcJaENc]

“a person is totally fine exploiting hurting damaging others perhaps getting pleasure out of it”

0.65

Sometimes a malignant narcissist gives the impression of having satisfaction with themselves, and that may be true, but most often one suspects that underneath they are plagued by doubt, insecurity, and anxiety.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Malignant Narcissist's Internal World | FRANK YEOMANS [-AeWDcJaENc]

“some of the times the person gives the impression of having a sense of satisfaction and that may be true most often one suspects that underneath they're plagued by doubt insecurity anxiety”

0.64

In cases where malignant narcissists come to therapy, they are often young adults whose concerned families bring them due to suicide attempts and self-harm behavior

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Malignant Narcissist's Internal World | FRANK YEOMANS [-AeWDcJaENc]

“in some cases it's the family most of the people i've treated with this disorder have been young adults and of course we have concerned families concerned about the suicide attempts the self-harm”

0.52

It is unclear at the beginning of treatment with a malignant narcissist whether their defensive grandiose narrative truly relieves them of the horror of internal emptiness or whether it works only some of the time.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Malignant Narcissist's Internal World | FRANK YEOMANS [-AeWDcJaENc]

“it's never clear to me at least at the start with a patient if their defensive system their grandiose narrative truly relieves them of the horror of the internal emptiness or if it works some of the time”

0.52

If a narcissist is able to delude themselves adequately through their grandiose narrative, their subjective experience may be gratifying to them, but they are almost or perhaps wholly in a world of their own, suggesting that defensive success comes at the cost of shared reality.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Malignant Narcissist's Internal World | FRANK YEOMANS [-AeWDcJaENc]

“if the person is able to delude him or herself adequately maybe their subjective experience is gratifying to them but they're almost or perhaps are in a world of their own”

0.49

Self-harm in this patient population (malignant narcissists) sometimes has a sadistic component directed toward others, not just toward the self.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Malignant Narcissist's Internal World | FRANK YEOMANS [-AeWDcJaENc]

“i don't mean to imply that all self-harm has a sadistic component towards others i'm talking about in this patient population”

0.46

Some people with narcissism manage to keep their grandiosity intact without fault lines that threaten the defensive system, in contrast to those who have substance abuse and personality disorder issues, suggesting that substance abuse often indicates failure to maintain narcissistic defenses.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Malignant Narcissist's Internal World | FRANK YEOMANS [-AeWDcJaENc]

“in contrast to somebody who manages to keep the grandiosity intact and doesn't have those fault lines that are threatening to the whole system”

0.45

A second kind of family with a malignant narcissist is one where everybody is in the family for mutual exploitation, with connections based on exploitation and power grabbing rather than love and concern.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Malignant Narcissist's Internal World | FRANK YEOMANS [-AeWDcJaENc]

“the other kind of family is one where everybody is in it for mutual exploitation where it just seems like the connections are based on exploitation and power grabbing not anything we would say looked like love and concern and being one big happy family”

0.44

Children in families with a malignant narcissistic parent have no choice but to stay in the family until they can leave, though the speaker reports having seen progress in such patients and achievement of relative family harmony in treatment.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Malignant Narcissist's Internal World | FRANK YEOMANS [-AeWDcJaENc]

“the children may just have no choice but to stay in the family until they can leave and i'm happy to say i've seen progress in patients like that and the achievement of relative harmony in the family”

0.42

Malignant narcissists who come to treatment sometimes come from marriages where the partner has a masochistic streak and tolerates the kind of aggression and exploitation that the narcissist produces.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Malignant Narcissist's Internal World | FRANK YEOMANS [-AeWDcJaENc]

“the people who've come to treatment sometimes come from marriages where the partner has a quite a masochistic streak and so we'll tolerate the kind of things i've been describing”

0.39

Most people with malignant narcissism disorder who come to therapy are young adults brought by concerned families who are worried about suicide attempts and self-harm.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — The Malignant Narcissist's Internal World | FRANK YEOMANS [-AeWDcJaENc]

“in some cases it's the family most of the people i've treated with this disorder have been young adults and of course we have concerned families concerned about the suicide attempts the self-harm”