What this covers

Michael Huemer, a University of Colorado philosopher, sits down with Dwarkesh Patel to defend anarcho-capitalism as both a moral ideal and a practical political destination. The conversation proceeds from a narrow philosophical claim—that the state possesses no special moral authority justifying actions ordinary individuals cannot perform—toward a sweeping argument about how societies transform. Huemer's core contention is that taxation without consent, war, and the enforcement of arbitrary law are indistinguishable from crimes when committed by private actors, yet governments escape moral condemnation for identical conduct. If common-sense ethics truly binds everyone equally, then either the state must justify its exemption or abandon the claim to legitimacy. No such justification, Huemer argues, has ever withstood scrutiny.

The episode traces how moral progress occurs despite this apparent acceptance of state authority, attributing real historical change—abolition of slavery, elimination of gladiatorial combat—to small reformist minorities who held views their contemporaries rejected. Huemer situates this partly as a psychological phenomenon: people instinctively defer to power, a mechanism with evolutionary roots akin to Stockholm syndrome. The conversation then turns practical: if anarcho-capitalism is desirable, how could it be achieved without immediate chaos? Huemer's answer emphasizes gradualism, describing a transition where democracies slowly privatize policing and courts while shrinking state infrastructure. The exchange also engages objections head-on, addressing whether anarchism would increase violence, whether it is hypocritical to work for governments, and what assumptions—traced to thinkers like Burke—undergird skepticism toward radical institutional change. Throughout, Huemer defends both the possibility of moral knowledge and the claim that small-scale persuasion, modeling rationality in conversation, remains a legitimate path to cultural transformation.

Sharpest takeaway

Huemer argues that the state has no special moral authority distinct from ordinary individuals, that moral progress is real but driven by a small minority of morally serious people, and that a gradual, privatized transition from democracy to anarcho-capitalism is both desirable and achievable.

  • Common-sense ethics forbids ordinary people from coercion (taxation = extortion), and no good explanation grants the state an exemption.
  • Moral progress is empirically demonstrable (abolition of slavery, gladiatorial combat) and driven by a small reformist minority.
  • Anarcho-capitalism can be reached safely only by gradually privatizing police and courts from an advanced democracy, not by sudden collapse.

The claims · ranked43 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.54

The basic moral point of anarchism is simple and not hard to apprehend: the government isn't special—they are people like you and me with no reason to be allowed to do things considered immoral if anyone else did them—directly analogous to the now-obvious point that you don't have different rights because of your skin color.

normativecontestednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Michael Huemer

“the government isn't special like they're people like you and me there's no reason why they should get to do a whole bunch of stuff that that you consider to be immoral if anyone else does them”

0.54

When a private individual forcibly collects money from others to give to the poor it is called extortion and condemned, but when the government does the identical act it is called taxation for social welfare and approved—revealing an unexplained double standard that demands justification.

normativecontestednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Michael Huemer

“if i do this this is called extortion and uh you know i'm going to wind up in jail... but when the government does this this is called taxation”

0.54

Just as killing one man is a capital crime, war is the greatest crime of all yet is praised by rulers; this shows the rulers of the world cannot distinguish right from wrong, scaling moral judgments inconsistently when the perpetrator is the state.

normativecontestednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Michael Huemer

“to kill one man is a capital crime and to kill ten men is to multiply the crime by tenfold... but when it comes to the greatest crime of all making war on another state they praise it”

0.54

The government is generally thought to have a special moral status that entitles it to issue commands and force obedience in situations where no ordinary person would be permitted to, and to create moral obligations to obey merely because it is the law.

definitionestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Huemer

“the government is entitled to um give other people commands and force them to obey in situations where you nobody else would be entitled to give command to force people to obey”

0.50

People instinctively take the side of those who have power over them, a broader phenomenon related to Stockholm syndrome with an evolutionary basis: forming emotional bonds with the powerful was a survival mechanism, which explains why citizens defer to the state.

causalcontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Michael Huemer

“people will instinctively take the side of those who are who have power over them and there's an evolutionary explanation for why this would be”

0.50

Primitive tribal warfare—men attacking other tribes to murder the men and capture wives—makes evolutionary sense despite high mortality risk: if a man with fewer than two wives faces, say, a 45% death chance but a 55% chance of gaining an extra wife, his expected reproductive success rises, which is why humans evolved emotions that drive inter-tribal violence.

causalcontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Michael Huemer

“say there's a 45 chance that you die by starting this fight but a 55 chance that you survive and you capture one extra wife... then your reproductive success goes up”

0.50

What unifies libertarianism is skepticism about authority: applying the same moral standards to the state that one applies to ordinary people, so that state killing is called murder rather than excused as conventional political views do.

definitioncontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Michael Huemer

“what differentiates libertarians from everyone else is skepticism about authority that is that is the basic libertarian view”

0.50

Most people initially believe the state has authority but also believe this authority requires an explanation; since every proposed explanation fails, we should resolve the contradiction in favor of common-sense morality rather than common-sense political philosophy.

normativecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Michael Huemer

“most people can see that it needs an explanation right and so then they will try to give an explanation then it will just turn out that none of the explanations are any good”

0.50

Moral progress is driven by a small number of reformers who see the flaws in the status quo and slowly push society toward moral truth; because such reformers always exist, their constant small force accumulates over many generations into large progress.

causalcontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Michael Huemer

“there are always reformers who are trying to improve society it's a constant um it's a constant small force so over the course of many generations it accumulates to a lot of progress”

0.50

Hobbes's explanation for human violence—that everyone is selfish and attacks preemptively for fear of being attacked—makes no sense, because in a multi-person world the unprovoked attacker becomes the biggest target; the better strategy is to mind your own business.

causalcontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Michael Huemer

“if there's more than one other person who is worried about being attacked and you go around attacking people without provocation then everyone else is going to know that you're the biggest threat”

0.50

Academic peer review is probably overrated as a quality-control mechanism because reviewers are unpaid and have no stake, so editors must go down a list to whoever will do it (including graduate students or even the very person being criticized), resulting in careless reviews; the editor, by contrast, has a reputational stake in the journal's quality while the anonymous reviewer faces no accountability.

factualcontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Michael Huemer

“you don't get paid for doing these reviews right which means that not that many people want to do it... you have things where graduate students are reviewing papers and then you have situations where like the person who's being criticized by the paper is reviewing the paper”

0.49

Status quo bias explains why people in different societies with different customs each believe their own customs are superior—providing independent psychological evidence that people are biased in favor of the state.

causalestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Huemer

“this explains why people in different societies um with very different customs tend to think that their customs are superior to those of other societies”

0.49

Children have comparable rights against malicious coercion but paternalistic coercion of children is justified because they lack the knowledge to make their own decisions; the threshold of autonomy increases gradually with age and maturity, making 18 a reasonable but rough general rule, and similar guardianship reasoning applies to adults incapable of running their own lives—though that never licenses treating them as slaves.

normativeestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Huemer

“they have comparable rights against malicious coercion... but um you know about paternalistic coercion like that seems justified to me”

0.49

All progress must eventually slow down because there is a maximum point in everything, and economic growth illustrates this: poorer countries grow faster because when you are doing badly it is easier to improve, while an already-efficient economy like the US finds it harder to improve—a diminishing-returns dynamic that should also apply to moral progress as we approach moral truth.

causalestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Huemer

“poorer countries have a faster rate of growth right they're poorer overall but they're growing faster... if you're already doing pretty badly it's easier to improve”

0.49

On a small scale, the way to improve the world is to model rationality—interacting reasonably, listening and genuinely understanding others' points before asserting your own—in the hope that enough people doing so improves the culture.

normativeestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Huemer

“my idea is to model rationality right like interact with people in a way that is reasonable and rational and like part of part of that part of the reasonableness is like you listen to them and try to actually understand what their point is before saying your thing”

0.45

From a purely consequentialist standpoint factory farming has been a huge moral regression, because roughly 74 billion animals are tortured and killed each year while only ~110 billion humans have ever existed, meaning two years of factory farming inflicts more suffering than the total number of humans who have ever lived.

factualcontestednovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Michael Huemer

“the number of animals that we're torturing and killing each year are something like 74 billion right and they've only ever been 110 billion humans so like two years of factory farming we tortured and killed more creatures than the total number of us who have ever existed”

0.44

Anarchy may fail if attempted from a primitive society but could work if transitioned from an advanced society, because an advanced economy permits private security agencies that primitive tribes lacked—so the path is democracy to anarchy to anarcho-capitalism.

causalfringenovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Michael Huemer

“it might be that indeed anarchy doesn't work starting from primitive society right but it might still work if you transition from an advanced society”

0.44

The transition to anarcho-capitalism must occur gradually—the government progressively outsourcing policing to private security companies and courts to private arbitrators while shrinking—so that the private organizations grow as the state shrinks; a sudden government collapse would produce chaos and immediate re-establishment of a state.

normativefringenovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Michael Huemer

“the transition would have to go by the government progressively privatizing its functions so the government would outsource policing to private security companies”

0.44

Good ideas tend to be more persuasive than bad ideas, so when all information comes out and everyone shares arguments, this generally favors correct views; the truth tends to win in the end, though this is a tendency rather than a guarantee because of systematic biases in the human mind.

normativecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Huemer

“generally speaking like good ideas tend to be more persuasive than bad ideas... if you hear all of the arguments usually that favors the correct views”

0.44

Social change tends to flow from the top down—if you convince the elites, society follows—and it is much harder to change the minds of people who have held beliefs for decades, so targeting young future elites is more effective.

causalcontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Huemer

“i kind of think that it goes from the top down so to speak that is if you convince the elites then the western society will go along”

0.44

Constructive criticism of society—offering a specific better alternative that can be compared to the status quo—is legitimate, whereas the destructive criticism Huemer attributes to current left-wing ideology (attacking America as fundamentally evil) aims merely to undermine confidence without promoting something good, eroding valuable norms of respectful discourse.

normativecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Huemer

“have an alternative that you're saying we should do like don't just attack but say here's something we should be doing instead”

0.44

The ethical intuitions against theft, threatening violence, and imprisoning people for money are uncontroversial across political affiliations, whereas the intuition that the state has authority is genuinely controversial—evidenced by libertarians who lack it entirely.

factualcontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Huemer

“these are not controversial intuitions right like these are intuitive reactions that any normal person would have regardless of whether they're democrats or republicans or libertarians”

0.44

There is a real and non-outlandish chance the government will kill all of us, since states have come close to nuclear war several times; maintaining the status quo carries its own catastrophic risks, and people are now working on cheaper, more destructive weapons such as biological and nanotech weapons.

forecastcontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Huemer

“there's a pretty good chance that the government is going to kill all of us right like i don't think that's a outlandish possibility... there are a few times when we were pretty close to a nuclear war”

0.44

As people become wealthier their fertility falls below replacement rate in wealthy countries, raising a worry that the human species may dwindle or go extinct just as moral progress reaches a point where human existence becomes net positive.

forecastcontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Huemer

“as people become wealthier and their living standard goes up you know their fertility goes down and like it's at the point now where in the wealthy countries like the fertility of well-off people is below replacement rate”

0.43

The Burkean objection that we shouldn't try untested systems fails because radical fundamental progress (like democracy itself, once unprecedented) shouldn't be ruled out by excessive conservatism; the right safeguard against unexpected consequences is to move gradually, and critics should identify at what specific point in a gradual privatization the predicted disaster would occur.

normativecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Michael Huemer

“you can imagine somebody saying this back when the us was founded right they could have said this democracy thing it never worked”

0.43

Every weapon of mass destruction so far—including nuclear weapons, the only technology plausibly capable of killing everyone—has been created and used only by governments, because states wage war and maintain standing armies that constantly seek bigger weapons, making government a pro-destruction technology lobby that accelerates the arrival of world-destroying technology.

causalcontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Michael Huemer

“so far there's one technology that would plausibly be capable of killing everyone that's nuclear weapons and it was created by the government and has only ever been used by the government”

0.43

Intellectuals and entrepreneurs both shape society, but their influence is intertwined: philosophers like Peter Singer convince a small percentage of morally-motivated people, a few of whom become entrepreneurs (e.g., synthetic-meat and plant-based companies) who make the big societal difference—so the entrepreneur's impact depends on the philosopher, while the philosopher's direct influence on ordinary people is much smaller because it's very hard to convince people to change against their self-interest.

causalcontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Michael Huemer

“i think peter singer is kind of the reason why people are doing that like i think those people uh like the entrepreneurs i think are um animal welfare advocates... largely because of peter singer”

0.43

There has been enormous moral progress over history, evidenced by the abolition of practices like gladiatorial combat in ancient Rome and chattel slavery based on skin color just 200 years ago.

factualestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Huemer

“back in ancient rome you know gladiatorial combat they were like forcing slaves to fight to the death for fun... just 200 years ago in america we were enslaving just like enslaving people just because they had darker skin”

0.43

The secret to happiness is, first, building solid meaningful relationships—cutting out non-beneficial people rather than trying to change them—and second, doing meaningful work that also pays enough, because work that feels meaningless leads to later-life regret despite money.

normativeestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Huemer

“the secret to happiness is first of all having um solid meaningful relationships... then the other thing is um meaningful work right”

0.40

An alternative to a single central monitoring authority for catastrophic technology is distributed monitoring—everyone watching everyone else rather than one organization watching everyone—as a way to guard against world-destroying weapons without concentrating power.

normativefringenovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Michael Huemer

“you might want sort of um distributed monitoring like people monitoring each other just regular people monitoring each other all the time rather than like a single central authority monitoring everyone else”

0.40

Rich people don't use violence to steal because they can simply buy what they want, which is cheaper than coercion; since the amount poor people would pay to avoid being robbed roughly equals the value of what would be stolen, purchasing the asset directly avoids the violence and is the rational choice.

causalfringenovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Michael Huemer

“this is why rich people usually don't do this because they could just buy the thing that they want that's why they don't have to steal it”

0.40

What will ultimately end factory farming is technology—convincing plant-based substitute products and synthetic (cultured) meat that delivers meat without the cruelty—and this technological change is itself being driven by a small minority of animal welfare advocates.

forecastcontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Michael Huemer

“what's ultimately going to change the situation is um technology... they're going to make meat without the cruelty and that's probably what's ultimately going to end it”

0.40

Government provides only about five percent of the University of Colorado's budget, but universities in general are heavily subsidized through government-backed student loans and financial aid, which lets institutions overcharge; in a libertarian society this market distortion would shrink and there would be significantly fewer universities and professors.

factualcontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Michael Huemer

“the state provides something like five percent of our budget... most of them would not be paying if it weren't for financial aid which is provided by the government”

0.40

The government cannot be relied upon to ban factory farming because it actually subsidizes the meat industry and won't ban meat while most people want it; instead, progress will require the majority of people to first care about animal welfare, after which government will merely sweep up the remaining cruelty—illustrated by Cory Booker disclaiming any intent to make people vegetarian.

causalcontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Michael Huemer

“when we have the government what they actually do is they're actually supporting the meat industry... they're obviously not going to ban meat when most people want it”

0.37

Graduate training is valuable partly because it forces naturally lazy people to do unfun but necessary work—reading the existing literature, understanding objections, and engaging the strongest opposing views—which non-academic intellectuals often skip, causing them to reinvent the wheel and defend simplistic versions of views; though this may partly be a selection effect favoring patient people rather than purely a training effect.

causalcontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Huemer

“in order to do stuff that's really good and useful um it requires work and effort... you're just not going to do that unless you have like... somebody else who's telling them you have to do this and that's what happens when you're in graduate school”

0.37

Online education won't take over despite being a good way to learn, because most people don't actually want education—they want prestige—and most people don't realize that this is what they want; if people merely wanted knowledge, nearly all of it is freely available on the internet.

causalcontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Huemer

“most people so most people don't actually want the education they want the prestige but also most people don't realize that that's what most people want”

0.37

Ordinary people admire power rather than moral virtue; horrible people are often charismatic because their strength comes from crushing opposition and their confidence comes from not caring about others' opinions or the consequences of their actions—as seen in dictators who present policies with total confidence precisely because they do not care if those policies kill people.

causalspeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Michael Huemer

“ordinary average people don't admire moral virtue they admire power like they admire somebody who is who appears strong and confident”

0.35

For personal finance, Huemer advises buying a house if staying somewhere for a few years (a good investment) and investing in index funds rather than trying to beat the market, because you probably won't.

normativeestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Huemer

“invest in index funds you know like don't try to beat the market because you're probably not going to be right”

0.35

Rather than attitudes moving toward libertarianism, what changed historically is that people kept their belief in state authority but added concern for the poor; previously they believed in authority but didn't care about the poor, so welfare-state policies represent attitudinal moral progress (more caring) even as the policies themselves move further from what they should be.

causalspeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Michael Huemer

“it used to be that people believed in the authority of the state but they just didn't care about the poor... then you know later it developed to where they still believe in the authority of the state but they started caring about the poor”

0.34

Once an anarcho-capitalist order is set up as envisioned, it is self-stabilizing: because existing organizations are easy to maintain but hard to start, anyone trying to found a predatory state-like gang—without prior wealth or resources—would be arrested by everyone else's security agencies before getting established.

causalfringenovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Michael Huemer

“if you already have one of these organizations it's easy to keep it going but if you don't already have one it's hard to get it started”

0.34

Not everyone needs to learn to code; people who would be reasonably good at it should learn it, while those who would be terrible at it gain little useful benefit.

normativecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Michael Huemer

“i don't agree that everyone needs to learn to code... i think people who would be reasonably good at it should learn it right and some people would just be terrible at it so there's no point”

0.27

In-person education is a better experience than online, but not better enough to justify the roughly ten-thousand-dollar premium people pay for it.

normativecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Michael Huemer

“i do think the in-person education is better like it's a better experience right but the thing is like it's just not better enough that it would justify paying whatever ten thousand dollars”

0.24

Huemer endorses redirecting police funding to private security companies rather than abolishing security entirely, distinguishing his position from the 'defund the police' movement which seems to mean canceling police and having no security.

normativefringenovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Michael Huemer

“i would take that money and give it to private security companies i wouldn't take it and just not give it to any security”