wonder weapon
A military technology or capability that rapidly or instantaneously disrupts the military balance without requiring corresponding advances in concepts, training, or force structure, in contrast to gradual military innovation
As defined in Artificial General Intelligence's Five Hard National Security Problems
Other definitions
A military capability that rapidly or instantaneously disrupts the military balance, as opposed to gradual military innovation requiring new concepts, training, and force structure; historically exemplified by nuclear weapons
Artificial General Intelligence's Five Hard National Security Problems
Where it comes up · 2
- Artificial General Intelligence's Five Hard National Security Problems5 claims
- Mick Ryan: This Is What The Next Great Power Conflict Will Look Like2 claims
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “wonder weapon” →
- There is no historical evidence for 'wonder weapons' or silver bullet solutions; over-relying on single systems is both intellectually lazy and morally perilous; success comes from integration of many technologies with many ideas and organizations led by well-trained, educated humans.Mick Ryan: This Is What The Next Great Power Conflict Will Look Like
- There is no historical evidence for the existence of a 'wonder weapon' or 'silver bullet' in warfare; relying on a single weapon system is both intellectually lazy and morally perilous, as success requires integration of multiple technologies, ideas, and organizations under well-led, well-trained, educated humans.Mick Ryan: This Is What The Next Great Power Conflict Will Look Like
- The first hard national security problem posed by AGI is the possibility of a wonder weapon—a capability that rapidly or instantaneously disrupts the military balance, distinct from gradual military innovation and comparable to historical examples like nuclear weapons, but potentially taking forms like offensive cyber capabilities, superhuman military strategists, or advanced autonomous weapons systems.Artificial General Intelligence's Five Hard National Security Problems
- The instability problem (problem five) is inherent to competition in developing AI capabilities, but the first two problems—wonder weapons and systemic power shifts—appear to align incentives toward competitive dynamics, while problems three and four—WMD proliferation and loss of control—create incentives for United States and China cooperation, since neither nation benefits from non-state actors wielding bioweapons or uncontrolled AI agents.Artificial General Intelligence's Five Hard National Security Problems
- A wonder weapon is distinguished from gradual military innovation by the fact that it instantly or rapidly disrupts the military balance without requiring concurrent advances in concepts, training, or force structure, and historical examples include nuclear weapons, though the specific form a wonder weapon would take in the AGI context is unclear—it could be a splendid offensive cyber capability, a military strategist exceeding human performance, or an advanced autonomous weapon system that scales core structure.Artificial General Intelligence's Five Hard National Security Problems
- Using the five-problem framework, incentives for cooperation and competition can be mapped: problems 1 (wonder weapon) and 2 (systemic power shift) have misaligned incentives favoring competition; problems 3 (WMD proliferation) and 4 (loss of control) have aligned incentives for U.S.-China cooperation; problem 5 (instability) has aligned incentives for maintaining some stability.Artificial General Intelligence's Five Hard National Security Problems
- The second hard national security problem posed by AGI is a systemic shift in the instruments of power that alters military or economic balance more gradually than a wonder weapon, analogous to the Industrial Revolution, occurring over years rather than overnight or across generations.Artificial General Intelligence's Five Hard National Security Problems