within-subject design
An experimental design in which each participant experiences multiple conditions and serves as their own control, reducing error and increasing statistical power.
As defined in Brian Nosek on the Reproducibility Project
Where it comes up · 2
- Brian Nosek on the Reproducibility Project2 claims
- 360 | Marc Berman on the Science of Touching Grass2 claims
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “within-subject design” →
- Findings in cognitive psychology—basic operations of the mind like perception, memory, and attention—replicated at roughly twice the rate of social psychology findings, possibly because social effects are context-dependent and replication necessarily changes context, or because cognitive research more often uses higher-powered within-subjects designs while social psychology relies on lower-powered between-subjects designs.Brian Nosek on the Reproducibility Project
- Within-subjects designs—where the same participant serves as their own control across multiple conditions—are higher powered because they reduce error variance, whereas between-subjects designs comparing different people across conditions are lower powered, which may partly explain why cognitive psychology (using within-subjects designs) replicated better than social psychology (using between-subjects designs).Brian Nosek on the Reproducibility Project
- In a within-subject design where each participant walked about 50 minutes in a natural and in an urban environment one week apart, participants showed about a 20 percent improvement on the backwards digit span task after the nature walk, roughly a digit and a half, while the urban walk produced no significant improvement.360 | Marc Berman on the Science of Touching Grass
- Berman is confident the nature-walk cognitive findings are robust because many other labs have replicated them, although the original study had only about 40 participants in a within-subjects design, equivalent to roughly 80 between-subjects participants.360 | Marc Berman on the Science of Touching Grass