wicked learning environment
A learning setting with relatively free, shifting parameters requiring constant adaptation, where agents 'talk back' and feedback is unreliable—characteristic of the economic problem.
As defined in Who Won the Socialist Calculation Debate (with Peter Boettke)
Where it comes up · 4
- Wide or Deep?3 claims
- David Epstein on Mastery, Specialization, and Range2 claims
- Who Won the Socialist Calculation Debate (with Peter Boettke)1 claim
- Ryan Holiday: "The One Stoic Practice That Changed My Life" | Ancient Wisdom for Modern Success1 claim
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “wicked learning environment” →
- In 'wicked learning environments,' some information is hidden, feedback may be delayed, infrequent, or inaccurate, and the most wicked environments actively reinforce the wrong behavior—illustrated by the diagnostician whose tongue-palpation 'success' actually spread typhoid—so doing the activity does not reliably teach correct lessons.David Epstein on Mastery, Specialization, and Range
- Learning environments range from kind, where information is available, feedback is immediate and accurate, and the rules are clear, to wicked, where information is hidden, feedback is delayed or inaccurate, and most real-world problems fall toward the wicked end.Wide or Deep?
- Most real-world domains outside sports are wicked learning environments where information is hidden, feedback is delayed or inaccurate, and rules are unknown, so people are constantly playing Martian tennis, and feedback in such settings can teach exactly the wrong lesson.Wide or Deep?
- In wicked environments feedback can reinforce wrong lessons; a New York physician who predicted typhoid by palpating patients' tongues kept getting positive feedback while actually spreading the disease, so his feedback taught exactly the wrong thing.Wide or Deep?
- The economy is a wicked learning environment with relatively free parameters requiring constant adaptation, unlike chess which is a kind learning environment with fixed rules and finite positions solvable by churning through combinatorials; moreover, economic agents 'talk back' and resist instruction unlike chess pieces, so economics must be built to cope with wicked problems rather than forced into a kind-learning frame.Who Won the Socialist Calculation Debate (with Peter Boettke)
- The kinder a learning environment is—constrained situations, repeating patterns, abundant data—the more amenable it is both to human specialization and to being automated, which is why chess can be beaten by a phone app while open-ended problems like cancer research resist AI.David Epstein on Mastery, Specialization, and Range
- Successful entrepreneurs get there by not listening to odds, doubts, and critics, but this creates a wicked learning environment where people generalize 'never listen to feedback' when they should have listened selectively, using Elon Musk as the example of someone who ignored bad advice about SpaceX and Tesla but faced moments when conventional wisdom and investor advice should have been heeded.Ryan Holiday: "The One Stoic Practice That Changed My Life" | Ancient Wisdom for Modern Success