weak emergence
Emergence where macroscopic behavior, while described in higher-level terms, could in principle be fully derived by simulating the lower-level laws; the term comes from philosopher Mark Bedau.
As defined in AMA | April 2022
Where it comes up · 13
- 168 | Anil Seth on Emergence, Information, and Consciousness6 claims
- 25 | David Chalmers on Consciousness, the Hard Problem, and Living in a Simulation3 claims
- AMA | December 20212 claims
- AMA | June 20222 claims
- AMA | September 20222 claims
- 100 | Solo | Life and Its Meaning1 claim
- 107 | Russ Shafer-Landau on the Reality of Morality1 claim
- 295 | Solo: Emergence and Layers of Reality1 claim
and 5 more
Most important claims · 10 of 23Search all claims for “weak emergence” →
- Weak emergence is the appearance of a useful, real pattern based on incomplete information: a coarse-grained higher-level description (like a gas as a fluid, or the Earth as a center-of-mass point) captures real structure with far less data than the full microscopic specification, and it is objective rather than merely subjective.100 | Solo | Life and Its Meaning
- In the physicist's sense (weak emergence), higher-level descriptions speak different vocabularies but remain compatible with lower levels because they exploit patterns implicit in the microscopic dynamics; the center-of-mass example shows that throwing away almost all microscopic information still yields good predictions only because the retained information is extraordinarily special—keeping random information would predict nothing—making emergence a wonderful, non-trivial feature of nature rather than the strong emergence where macro behavior cannot be derived from micro at all.AMA | September 2021
- In the Barnett-Seth approach, a candidate weakly emergent macroscopic variable must be dynamically independent from its microscopic underpinnings, meaning that knowing what is going on at the microscopic level does not help you predict the macroscopic variable's evolution; this enables data-driven discovery of candidate emergent coarse-grainings even when the emergent property does not visibly leap out to an observer.168 | Anil Seth on Emergence, Information, and Consciousness
- Weak emergence preserves the intuition that the whole is more than the sum of its parts while remaining physically explicable; following Mark Bedau, a weakly emergent property is one for which an explanation exists in terms of microscopic components but is incompressible—you can only determine the global property by exhaustively simulating the microscopic interactions, with no shortcut.168 | Anil Seth on Emergence, Information, and Consciousness
- Whether strong emergence (collective behavior not predictable from simulating lower-level laws) occurs at all depends on what your two levels are: it does not happen when the lower level is simple, local fundamental physics like quantum field theory, but there may be a useful sense in which strong emergence occurs when connecting one complex level of analysis to another complex level, such as a nation emerging from its citizens.AMA | April 2022
- Emergence in the dynamical-independence sense is best understood as a way to enrich our descriptions of physical systems in ways that might be relevant to consciousness—since conscious experiences are unified, global, and seem more than the sum of their parts—rather than as a proof that consciousness is an emergent property; it is an empirical question whether weakly emergent properties dissolve when people lose consciousness under anesthesia or sleep.168 | Anil Seth on Emergence, Information, and Consciousness
- Weak emergence (per Bedau) means higher-level properties arise from lower-level dynamics in principle—operationalized as being predictable by putting the microscopic state and laws on a computer—whereas strong emergence (per Chalmers) means higher-level properties are fundamentally new and not deducible even in principle from the lower level.295 | Solo: Emergence and Layers of Reality
- Nominal emergence is a property that by definition can only apply to a whole and never to a part (e.g., a circle is nominally emergent from its constituent points); combining nominal emergence with a sufficiently rich version of weak emergence gives you everything you need without violating the causal closure of the physical world.168 | Anil Seth on Emergence, Information, and Consciousness
- Entropy and weak emergence are related concepts because emergence exploits the compressibility of the microscopic theory — there are many microscopic states that map to the same macroscopic state (e.g. the 10^50 particles in Earth all giving the same center-of-mass motion), and the logarithm of that number of microstates is an entropy; however the relationship is not exact, since some emergent phenomena (Earth orbiting the Sun) do not require increasing entropy, so our general theory of emergence remains primitive.AMA | December 2021
- A concrete near-term aim is to show that weakly emergent variables can be identified in conscious states but not in unconscious states, and then used to predict levels of consciousness in people with better accuracy than other measures of global brain dynamics—a starting point rather than a full solution to consciousness.168 | Anil Seth on Emergence, Information, and Consciousness