violence potential
The capacity of an individual or group to use or threaten force; when dispersed across many groups it produces instability because shifting relative capacities trigger demands for changed rules.
As defined in Barry Weingast on Law
Where it comes up · 1
- Barry Weingast on Law6 claims
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “violence potential” →
- Most societies throughout history have been 'natural states' that limit access to organizations, restricting competition in politics and economics, distributing a set of privileges, and dispersing violence potential, producing chronic disputes and violence; these are by far the most prevalent and long-lived form of government in human civilization.Barry Weingast on Law
- Societies with dispersed violence potential struggle to sustain stable rules because adaptive efficiency requires adapting to changing circumstances, and when circumstances change the relative capacities of groups shift; for cooperation to persist each group with violence potential must consider itself better off under peace than violence, which credible-commitment problems and asymmetric information disrupt.Barry Weingast on Law
- In natural states, the opportunity to grow through savings or innovation is low because accumulation cannot be relied upon to persist; if you lack the violence potential to protect yourself, accumulating wealth makes you a target, so the natural state tends to be poor.Barry Weingast on Law
- Decentralized emergent legal orders are rare and observable precisely because there aren't hundreds of thousands of them; in most cases a local strongman or dictator arises producing a hierarchical, non-legal system, so the named historical examples are exceptional rather than typical.Barry Weingast on Law
- Aid organizations (World Bank, IMF, USAID) design legal systems based on a flawed conception of law as sovereign commands, leading them to transplant developed-world institutions (legislatures, constitutions, separation of powers) into natural states where dispersed violence potential makes such institutions fail, because they lack the necessary legal attributes and steward function and ignore that law is separate from enforcement.Barry Weingast on Law
- A rule for creating stability is that the political bargain should limit the stakes of power; if a society can limit how much is at stake in controlling government, it lowers the chance of disruptive coups, as illustrated by Chile in 1973 where a left government threatening property rights led large landowners to support a bloody military coup.Barry Weingast on Law