vertebroplasty
A surgical procedure that injects cement into the spinal column to solidify and stabilize fractured vertebrae back to their original position.
As defined in The Top EconTalk Conversations of 2023 (with Russ Roberts)
Where it comes up · 4
- The Top EconTalk Conversations of 2023 (with Russ Roberts)2 claims
- Adam Cifu on Ending Medical Reversal1 claim
- Gary Greenberg on the Placebo Effect1 claim
- The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly of the Covid Vaccine (with Vinay Prasad)1 claim
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “vertebroplasty” →
- Clinical trials of vertebroplasty—injecting cement into vertebrae to treat back pain from osteoporosis—show no difference between actually injecting cement and a sham procedure of opening the cement so the patient can smell it and then injecting saline, and lower back pain is among the conditions most responsive to placebo treatment.Gary Greenberg on the Placebo Effect
- A rigorous trial randomized spinal-compression-fracture patients to real vertebroplasty (injecting medical cement) or a sham procedure (full prep, opening cement so patients could smell it, but injecting only saline), and found no difference in pain, quality of life, or activity scores over the first month—showing the procedure's apparent benefit was a placebo effect.Adam Cifu on Ending Medical Reversal
- Vertebroplasty—injecting cement into the spine to treat compression fractures—was tested against a placebo in which patients merely smelled an opened tube of cement without surgery, and the actual surgery performed no better than the placebo, suggesting the brain can fight the fracture pain on its own once the patient believes something was done.The Top EconTalk Conversations of 2023 (with Russ Roberts)
- Many of the most common and widely implemented medical procedures, which originally started with some supporting evidence, are found upon careful testing not to work—or even to be harmful—a phenomenon called medical reversal.The Top EconTalk Conversations of 2023 (with Russ Roberts)
- Two paired 2009 New England Journal studies showed that vertebroplasty—injecting cement into a fractured vertebra—was no better than a sham procedure where the cement was merely opened so the patient smelled it before saline injection; both groups felt better, demonstrating a powerful placebo effect, paralleling the historical internal mammary artery ligation that sham trials debunked.The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly of the Covid Vaccine (with Vinay Prasad)