verifiability principle
The core thesis of logical positivism that a statement's meaning is determined by the method of its empirical verification, and that statements not verifiable (in principle or practice) are meaningless—used to eliminate metaphysical discourse.
As defined in A History of Philosophy | 76 Logical Positivism
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “verifiability principle” →
- A second major criticism is that the verifiability principle itself is not a factual statement amenable to verification or falsification by empirical procedures, nor is it an analytic statement—therefore it cannot meet its own criterion of meaning, creating a self-refuting problemA History of Philosophy | 76 Logical Positivism
- Empirical generalizations are not verifiable even in principle because any universal statement about all members of an extensive class has always more possible cases that remain inaccessible, making such statements lack factual meaning by the verifiability principle.A History of Philosophy | 76 Logical Positivism
- The verifiability principle disallows metaphysical statements about a reality-in-itself (in the Hegelian/F.H. Bradley sense) that is distinct from all appearances, but permits statements about various appearances themselves, since appearances are empirically accessible.A History of Philosophy | 76 Logical Positivism
- Ayer eventually concedes that the verifiability principle is not a factual statement but rather a methodological stipulation—a rule that positivists adopt for their own methodological purposes, not a universal truth about meaningA History of Philosophy | 76 Logical Positivism
- Developments in philosophy of science from the 1940s onward revealed that the empirical sciences do not operate on the verifiability principle—observation is theory-laden, paradigms shape interpretation, tacit and personal dimensions infuse knowledge, and the analytic-synthetic distinction breaks down—contradicting the positivist assumption that their principle describes how science actually works.A History of Philosophy | 76 Logical Positivism
- Ayer began his philosophical work with 'summary trial and execution of metaphysics' using the verifiability principle as an axe, arguing that if philosophy was to make an independent contribution to knowledge, it could consist only in the practice of analysis—specifically analysis of the meaning of language to clear up puzzles and confusions in traditional philosophy, particularly metaphysics.A History of Philosophy | 76 Logical Positivism