value capture
The process by which an externally imposed, simplified, quantified value system (such as a ranking or metric) replaces a person's own richer, plural values, so they outsource their value deliberation to an institution's measurable target.
As defined in 169 | C. Thi Nguyen on Games, Art, Values, and Agency
Where it comes up · 5
- #190 Henry Ford and Thomas Edison3 claims
- Reid Hoffman & Peter Thiel The Future of Revolutions3 claims
- 169 | C. Thi Nguyen on Games, Art, Values, and Agency2 claims
- Arm: The Silicon Blueprint1 claim
- Pulling the Thread1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 10Search all claims for “value capture” →
- Edison created enormous value through the incandescent bulb and generator systems, but he sold his interest to competitors who formed General Electric, which took the substantial profits, illustrating that producing value is not enough without a system to capture it.#190 Henry Ford and Thomas Edison
- When the US News rankings began ranking law schools, they forced every school toward the same values—because pursuing a distinctive mission like social justice that isn't counted lowers your rank—and prospective students stopped deliberating about their own values, instead simply assuming their goal was to attend the highest-ranked school, outsourcing their value deliberation to the ranking.169 | C. Thi Nguyen on Games, Art, Values, and Agency
- In a business model, creating value and capturing value are very different things, and most people focus only on creating value, yet many never actually create it, and even a product people want may earn no margin.Pulling the Thread
- Throughout history, inventors and creators have captured very little value from their innovations: the Wright Brothers made no money, aviation industry cumulative profits were near zero for 100 years, Industrial Revolution factory efficiency increased 7-10% annually for decades but aristocracy retained most wealth, and most innovation historically features y=0% value captureReid Hoffman & Peter Thiel The Future of Revolutions
- Large-scale institutions can only track things that can be input in a standardized way into a spreadsheet, so any value systems they emit are standardized across the institution and serve institutional interests; when we adopt those values (rankings, Fitbit step counts) we outsource our value deliberation and let a metric chosen for measurability dominate our goal system.169 | C. Thi Nguyen on Games, Art, Values, and Agency
- The microeconomics of clean tech ventures in the last decade were such that companies could not achieve even ephemeral monopoly status because they could not produce something decisively better than competitors, making value capture impossible and leading to business failure despite technological importance.Reid Hoffman & Peter Thiel The Future of Revolutions
- Ford became much wealthier than his hero Edison because he did not need to invent his market, only expand it, and because he stuck with one project, whereas Edison jumped between projects and had difficulty capturing the value of his many inventions.#190 Henry Ford and Thomas Edison
- Software is an exception to the historical pattern—unlike clean tech, aviation, and industrial manufacturing, software companies have achieved y>0% value capture, making it one of the very few innovation domains where inventors captured meaningful valueReid Hoffman & Peter Thiel The Future of Revolutions
- NVIDIA sells a system for around $100,000, of which Arm probably earns only a dollar or two, which implies substantial room for Arm to increase its share of value in the industry.Arm: The Silicon Blueprint
- Ford and Firestone judged that Edison was the world's greatest scientist but a poor businessman who thought creatively about invention but not about commerce, so the Vagabonds' friends saw a lack of attention to value capture as his core failing.#190 Henry Ford and Thomas Edison