valence
In affective psychology, the good-to-bad or happy-to-sad dimension of meaning; the dominant axis along which words and concepts are evaluated as positive or negative.
As defined in 181 | Peter Dodds on Quantifying the Shape of Stories
Where it comes up · 11
- 181 | Peter Dodds on Quantifying the Shape of Stories3 claims
- 292 | Jonathan Birch on Animal Sentience3 claims
- 247 - Constructing Minds2 claims
- 380 - The Roots Of Attention2 claims
- 446 - How To Do The Most Good2 claims
- Joscha Bach2 claims
- Joe Carlsmith — Preventing an AI takeover1 claim
- The Invisible Hierarchies that Rule Our World (with Toby Stuart)1 claim
and 3 more
Most important claims · 10 of 19Search all claims for “valence” →
- When someone is captured by an anxious thought, a positive (negatively-valenced) feedback loop forms: the thought kindles anxiety, the anxiety prolongs and invokes more thoughts of similar character, and this self-reinforcing spin can continue for hours, days, or weeks because the person never notices thoughts as thoughts or sees the mechanics linking thought to physiology.380 - The Roots Of Attention
- These states can be mapped on axes of agency/effort versus understanding/engagement: pity is feeling sorry for someone from a position of superiority with no action; sympathy is less than empathy—cognitively understanding pain and feeling for someone with no agency; empathy is taking on another's emotional state (with no fixed valence, including empathic joy or distressing shared pain); compassion takes on the emotional state but adds a strong motivational desire to alleviate the suffering.219 - The Power Of Compassion
- Across decades of psychological studies asking people to rate words on semantic differentials (hard-soft, good-bad, big-small), valence—essentially the good-to-bad or happy-to-sad spectrum—emerged as the dominant axis of meaning, which makes evolutionary sense because an organism needs a basic sense of what is helpful versus harmful to be attracted to one end and repelled from the other.181 | Peter Dodds on Quantifying the Shape of Stories
- Book blurbs carry no real information about quality because they only ever have positive valence--no one writes a negative blurb--so all a blurb actually conveys is whether you recognize the identity of the person who wrote it, which shifts what counts as a worthwhile book from its contents to how blurbed it is and who endorsed it.The Invisible Hierarchies that Rule Our World (with Toby Stuart)
- Psychological suffering is to some degree always a matter of being lost in thought; even with extreme physical pain, the unbearableness is largely an illusion of massive resistance and cognition about the pain, since the pain already arrived in the present moment has already been borne, and changing or removing the conceptual frame can dramatically alter the experience.158 - Understanding Humans In The Wild
- Because the brain constantly regulates the body and the body sends back sense data, the brain always computes affect—a vague sense of bodily state plus feeling pleasant/unpleasant and worked-up/calm—which scientists call affect and laypeople call mood; it is a property of consciousness present at all times, distinct from emotion, which is conjured only situationally.247 - Constructing Minds
- The deeper goal of mindfulness practice is to achieve equanimity in which the mind no longer reacts to the pleasant and unpleasant in the usual grasping ways, so that one's sense of well-being and happiness is no longer contingent upon the changing winds of experience but rests on the mind's native capacity to be open and unreactive.380 - The Roots Of Attention
- A feeling is a constant qualification of mental states as favorable or unfavorable to life—described by valence (positivity or negativity)—reflecting how a state is conducive to the continuation and quality of life; it occurs only in creatures with both nervous systems and minds and is not synonymous with emotion.44 | Antonio Damasio on Feelings, Thoughts, and the Evolution of Humanity
- Training AIs on the entirety of human thought may give us an 'intellectual descendant,' but Carlsmith doubts that mere inheritance of human concepts (literal paperclips are a human concept) is what we care about; rather, the morally relevant things that might come for free or commonly are structural features of mind like consciousness and pleasure—whose moral significance depends on whether they are fragile evolutionary hacks or robust functional roles present in many sophisticated minds.Joe Carlsmith — Preventing an AI takeover
- Reanalyzing large word-rating datasets (20,000 words rated on valence, arousal, and dominance) and rotating the dimensional space reveals that the two dominant axes of essential meaning are power-to-weak (winning/triumph versus emptiness/void) and danger-to-safe, forming a 'compass for basic meaning' that Dodds calls Ousiametry, with a third axis of structure/playfulness.181 | Peter Dodds on Quantifying the Shape of Stories