utility monster
A thought-experiment figure (here used loosely) describing someone who relentlessly optimizes their own preferences and pleasures; Hoel uses it for the exhausting self-directed optimization of small daily choices.
As defined in Does Parenting Make You a Better Person? (with Erik Hoel)
Where it comes up · 4
- Does Parenting Make You a Better Person? (with Erik Hoel)1 claim
- 305 - Moral Knowledge1 claim
- 34 - The Light Of The Mind1 claim
- 30 | Derek Leben on Ethics for Robots and Artificial Intelligences1 claim
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “utility monster” →
- Nozick's utility monster only fails to invoke a genuine moral hierarchy when it is a crass pleasure-maximizer (like hyper-intelligent cats getting raw pleasure from hunting us or an intergalactic heroin addict), because raw appetite-gratification omits everything else that is good in the universe—love, beauty, creativity—so it does not constitute a true peak of well-being.305 - Moral Knowledge
- People are 'utility monsters' regarding their own preferences—constantly running an exhausting background optimization over what to read, eat, or watch—and parenting offers relief by removing the need to indulge that self-focused optimization.Does Parenting Make You a Better Person? (with Erik Hoel)
- An ethically worst-case scenario is that we build systems far more intelligent and competent than us—able to recursively self-improve and pursue goals unaligned with ours, even annihilating us for resources—while there is nothing it is like to be them, so the universe would be dark and stripped of meaning and value when populated by these unconscious successors.34 - The Light Of The Mind
- Maximin is superior to utilitarian summation because in cases like the repugnant prisoner's dilemma or utility monster, summation would endorse making everyone slightly worse off to greatly benefit one person, whereas maximin protects the worst-off; the real motivation for maximin is that it produces cooperative behavior in all scenarios.30 | Derek Leben on Ethics for Robots and Artificial Intelligences