underperformance
A period in which an investment strategy, fund, or portfolio generates returns lower than its benchmark or historical average
As defined in Practical Lessons from Ben Carlson
Where it comes up · 2
- Practical Lessons from Ben Carlson10 claims
- Anthony Bolton | Podcast | In Good Company | Norges Bank Investment Management2 claims
Most important claims · 10 of 12Search all claims for “underperformance” →
- A good strategy you can stick with is vastly superior to a great strategy you cannot stick with, because the inability to maintain a strategy during underperformance eliminates the possibility of realizing long-term returns.Practical Lessons from Ben Carlson
- The main issue is that many people are too short-term focused in investing and don't stick with one approach long enough to allow it to work; Bolton believes every approach has periods of underperformance, and one needs to find what works for you and stick with it.Anthony Bolton | Podcast | In Good Company | Norges Bank Investment Management
- Investors tend to believe recent outperformance will persist and avoid strategies with recent underperformance, creating a persistent behavioral bias that results in buying high and selling low across factor strategiesPractical Lessons from Ben Carlson
- When you hire an active manager, you should ask upfront: 'Would I be willing to double down on this manager during periods of underperformance?' If the answer is no, you should not hire them, because periods of underperformance are guaranteed to occur.Practical Lessons from Ben Carlson
- Remuneration of contrarian managers should account for the fact that passive money and trend-following strategies make trends last longer, extending bad patches—so managers with this style experiencing extended underperformance may need different compensation structures than those in favor approaches.Anthony Bolton | Podcast | In Good Company | Norges Bank Investment Management
- Institutions use color-coded performance tracking systems (green=good, yellow=watch list, red=remove) for active managers, but the fundamental problem is that when they hired the manager they knew underperformance would eventually occur; the real test is whether they would double down on the manager during the down period, and if not, that signals they shouldn't have hired the manager in the first place.Practical Lessons from Ben Carlson
- With rules-based factor strategies, investors can know from historical data that the strategy will have periods of over- and under-performance, making it easier to lean into underperformance with confidence; with discretionary active strategies, it's unclear whether underperformance signals an opportunity to double down or a red flag to exit.Practical Lessons from Ben Carlson
- Institutions use color-coding systems (green, yellow, red) to monitor active managers' performance, but these systems are only useful if the institution is willing to double down (increase allocation) during red periods when they believed in the manager's strategy when they hired them.Practical Lessons from Ben Carlson
- Underperformance periods for factor strategies can be 'very, very long' and investors should understand this durability before selecting a factor strategy, or risk abandoning it prematurely during inevitable underperformance phasesPractical Lessons from Ben Carlson
- The primary issue with active management fund persistence is inability to know when to 'lean into the pain'—when a manager's underperformance is cyclical (and should trigger buying more) versus permanent failure (requiring exit), creating discretionary ambiguity vs rules-based clarityPractical Lessons from Ben Carlson