truth-seeking exercise
A legitimate process in which independent adjudicators hear competing experts, explain their reasoning, follow ethical rules, and allow appeals—society's substitute for trusting individuals.
As defined in 69 | Cory Doctorow on Technology, Monopoly, and the Future of the Internet
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 3 of 3Search all claims for “truth-seeking exercise” →
- The fragmentation of what we believe is overrated compared to the fragmentation of our epistemology—how we know what to believe; in a complex technical society we long ago replaced asking a trusted person with trusting processes (independent adjudicators hearing competing experts, explaining reasoning, bound by ethics, with appeal mechanisms), because no individual can personally evaluate questions like food safety, drug safety, or structural engineering.69 | Cory Doctorow on Technology, Monopoly, and the Future of the Internet
- Vaccine skeptics are wrong, but their story—that the pharmaceutical industry is concentrated, run by financialized elites indifferent to killing customers, and protected by captured regulators—is right in shape, because the opioid epidemic was a real conspiracy in which the NIH and FDA let tainted evidence (notably Dr. Jick's five-sentence 1980s letter, not a study, cited as the most consequential lines the NEJM ever published) produce false safety guidance; the alleged vaccine conspiracy has the shape of a real conspiracy.69 | Cory Doctorow on Technology, Monopoly, and the Future of the Internet
- The ability of truth-seeking processes to find truth is now constrained by the extent to which the truth 'gores a billionaire's ox,' turning truth-seeking into an auction; this stems from monopoly concentration that captures regulators (the Boeing 737 MAX self-regulation, FCC chairs drawn from Comcast and Verizon), casting people into an epistemological void where they can die because they cannot know what is true.69 | Cory Doctorow on Technology, Monopoly, and the Future of the Internet