triage
Prioritizing limited resources toward where they do the most good, deprioritizing problems too small to matter.
As defined in Bryan Caplan
Other definitions
In Schmachtenberger's usage, immediate harm reduction actions working within existing systems (as opposed to long-term systemic transformation), such as removing perverse subsidies or lobbying for policy changes that reduce the worst ecological damage while systemic solutions develop.
Daniel Schmachtenberger l An introduction to the Metacrisis l Stockholm Impact/Week 2023
Where it comes up · 9
- Daniel Schmachtenberger l An introduction to the Metacrisis l Stockholm Impact/Week 20232 claims
- How to Think So Clearly People Assume You’re A Genius2 claims
- Leo Katz on Why the Law is So Perverse2 claims
- Susan Mayer on What Money Can't Buy2 claims
- Making Sense of Markets in a Post Election World | Grant Wiliams and Ben Hunt1 claim
- Bryan Caplan1 claim
- Paul Robinson on Cooperation, Punishment and the Criminal Justice System1 claim
- Trump 2.0, DOGE, and America's Global Decline with Sam Harris and Jonah Goldberg1 claim
and 1 more
Most important claims · 10 of 13Search all claims for “triage” →
- Because people need different things depending on which kind of poor they are, the poor should be triaged: for those who fall into temporary poverty the best help is probably just giving money, whereas a family poor for five years needs a much more intensive social-worker model to get out of poverty.Susan Mayer on What Money Can't Buy
- If everyone had a college education we would still have great variation in earnings and wages, because other characteristics related to productivity would become the new triage criteria—so increasing the number of people going to college does not by itself reduce inequality; the marginal college-goer differs from the inframarginal one.Susan Mayer on What Money Can't Buy
- In the Andes plane crash chronicled in 'Alive,' survivors counterintuitively spent scarce resources caring for a near-death injured man rather than abandoning him by triage logic, and that man ultimately walked out of the mountains to bring rescue and save the group.Paul Robinson on Cooperation, Punishment and the Criminal Justice System
- Effective altruism — trying to obtain actual measures of how much good is being done and using science to do the most good — is underrated because most charity is driven by feelings and the 'warm glow' rather than impact, and because most people and major philanthropic societies have never heard of it; it also reframes the impact-focused person as someone who cares more, not a cold Vulcan.Bryan Caplan
- Overwhelm is not a capacity problem but a triage problem—the feeling arises not from insufficient mental capacity but from uncertainty about what to prioritize and work on first.How to Think So Clearly People Assume You’re A Genius
- A practical immediate action is to lobby for removal of perverse subsidies on toxic agriculture and replacement with subsidies for regenerative agriculture, which would change market topology without changing underlying market logic, creating conditions for market-based competition.Daniel Schmachtenberger l An introduction to the Metacrisis l Stockholm Impact/Week 2023
- Schmachtenberger categorizes necessary work into three time horizons: triage (immediate work using existing market/government structures to reduce harm), transitional (reshaping existing systems to be less pathological through changed incentives and monitoring), and long-term (fundamental redesign of governance, economic, education and meaning systems adequate for stewardship of advanced technology).Daniel Schmachtenberger l An introduction to the Metacrisis l Stockholm Impact/Week 2023
- The charitable interpretation of Trump's Ukraine policy—that the US cannot fight multiple wars simultaneously and must triage commitments to focus on China—is intellectually defensible in the abstract but does not describe what Trump is actually doing, which is not aimed at making NATO stronger but rather sees the EU as created specifically to screw America.Trump 2.0, DOGE, and America's Global Decline with Sam Harris and Jonah Goldberg
- In an emergency room with three patients of differing injury severity (Al's two-leg, Bea's one-leg, Chloe's finger), every candidate for treatment can be displaced by another with a superior claim—Bea outranks Chloe by severity, Al outranks Bea by severity, but Al and Chloe's mutually preferred bargain outranks both—producing a genuine cycle in which whoever is chosen, someone else seems to have a better claim.Leo Katz on Why the Law is So Perverse
- The triage dilemma arises in part because there are no property rights and no prices: the most seriously injured patient does not acquire transferable 'dibs' he could sell or give away, and we explicitly rule out allocating treatment to whoever pays most, unlike many other markets.Leo Katz on Why the Law is So Perverse