technological determinism
The view that technology autonomously drives social and cultural change; used by a Twitter critic to accuse Russ of attributing too much causal power to technology.
As defined in et_871
Other definitions
The belief that technological change follows an inevitable trajectory and determines social, political, and cultural outcomes, with no real alternatives to the path set by the technology
Daniel Kahneman & Yuval Noah Harari in conversation
Where it comes up · 5
- 46 | Kate Darling on Our Connections with Robots2 claims
- Daniel Kahneman & Yuval Noah Harari in conversation1 claim
- Jill Lepore on Nationalism, Populism, and the State of America1 claim
- Kevin Kelly on Advice, AI, and Technology1 claim
- 283 | Daron Acemoglu on Technology, Inequality, and Power1 claim
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “technological determinism” →
- Technology itself is not deterministic; the same 20th-century technology enabled both Nazi Germany and democratic U.S. under Roosevelt, and today North Korea and South Korea differ not in technology but in political choices; those claiming 'technology mandates X outcome' are often powerful actors selling a fiction to justify power consolidation.Daniel Kahneman & Yuval Noah Harari in conversation
- AI is technologically inevitable—it will arrive in some form and no amount of regulation can stop its coming—but society retains an enormous choice over its character, ownership, and regulation.Kevin Kelly on Advice, AI, and Technology
- History is not driven primarily by technology or markets, as the public's technologically-deterministic model and an economist's deterministic model would suggest; social movements are where most historical animation occurs, though the honest historian must weave together economic, technological, legal, religious, and social explanations rather than privilege a single disciplinary model.Jill Lepore on Nationalism, Populism, and the State of America
- Technology is just a reflection of our collective knowledge that can be applied in many different ways; there is no predetermined path of technological progress, as illustrated by nuclear physics, which could be used to build reactors for energy or to make weapons—so with digital and AI knowledge we likewise have a choice between eliminating workers or making them more productive.283 | Daron Acemoglu on Technology, Inequality, and Power
- Robots are moving out from behind factory walls into homes, workplaces, transportation, hospitals and the military, and—even if it sounds like technological determinism—this is coming and cannot be stopped, so rather than trying to educate anthropomorphism out of people we should roll with it, watch for harms, and lean into positive effects.46 | Kate Darling on Our Connections with Robots
- It is boring and misguided to build robots that merely replicate human tasks; roles relying heavily on human social factors (nannies, teachers, nurses) would be better done by humans, and apparent labor shortages in caretaking are often really problems of immigration policy and cultural identity better addressed by social conversation than by technological solutionism.46 | Kate Darling on Our Connections with Robots