tall poppy syndrome
A social tendency to resent, criticize, or cut down people who are conspicuously successful or stand out from the group.
As defined in Paula Byrne
Other definitions
The tendency to cut down or attack people who stand out through success, named after tall poppies in a field being cut first.
#43 Ray Dalio: Principles: Life and Work
Where it comes up · 7
- #43 Ray Dalio: Principles: Life and Work2 claims
- 248 - Order Freedom2 claims
- Paula Byrne1 claim
- Michele Gelfand on Rule Makers, Rule Breakers1 claim
- 462 - More From Sam The Iran War American Amorality Addressing Hopelessness Tucker And More1 claim
- Marc Andreessen1 claim
- 62 | Michele Gelfand on Tight and Loose Societies and People1 claim
Most important claims · 9 of 9Search all claims for “tall poppy syndrome” →
- Every culture, however loose overall, contains some tight domains predicted by which values matter most: Israel is tight on large families, California is loose but tight on environmental regulation, and New Zealand is loose but enforces a strong egalitarian 'tall poppy' norm that knocks down those who stand out.Michele Gelfand on Rule Makers, Rule Breakers
- In Britain people derive status more from holding negative opinions than positive ones — a 'tall poppy syndrome' that avoids elevating others lest it diminish oneself — which is markedly different from American positivity, though that positivity can feel phony.Paula Byrne
- Even in loose cultures, domains that are highly important are guarded very tightly—the US has a puritan heritage making sexual conduct tight, privacy is tightly guarded, and in New Zealand egalitarianism (the 'tall poppy syndrome' of cutting down those who stand out) is a strongly tight domain despite the society being permissive overall.248 - Order Freedom
- New Zealand, though a famously loose culture, was able to pivot and tighten quickly under COVID because of strong leadership and a national agreement—rooted in its tall-poppy egalitarianism—that everyone had to follow the rules, demonstrating cultural ambidexterity that overcame the typical loose-culture slowness to tighten.248 - Order Freedom
- Getting a lot of attention for being successful is a bad position to be in, because public success draws mischaracterizations such as accusations that Bridgewater is a cult and produces negative externalities, which is why Dalio published his principles publicly first.#43 Ray Dalio: Principles: Life and Work
- Even within a generally loose culture, the domains that are most highly valued tend to be tightly regulated with strong norms—in loose Italy, food and fashion are tight (putting parmesan on fish draws strange looks), and in loose New Zealand and Australia egalitarianism is tight, expressed in the 'tall poppy' norm that punishes standing out.62 | Michele Gelfand on Tight and Loose Societies and People
- Australians call it the tall poppy syndrome because the tallest poppies are most likely to be cut down, and Dalio found public attention and the cult mischaracterizations of Bridgewater a harmful consequence of success.#43 Ray Dalio: Principles: Life and Work
- Over the past decade the US developed a form of 'soft authoritarianism' — not a military dictatorship, but a suppressive blanket of regulation, a vetocracy requiring ~40 sign-offs to get anything done, plus censorship regimes, debanking, and a demoralization campaign messaging that success and building are bad.Marc Andreessen
- Antisemitism is burgeoning on both left and right; alarmingly, Republicans from Trump down decline to clearly condemn figures like Fuentes, Carlson, and Owens—holding open the tent for white supremacy—apparently because they believe they need the antisemitic white-supremacist vote, even at the risk of alienating independents.462 - More From Sam The Iran War American Amorality Addressing Hopelessness Tucker And More