superforecaster
A person who, per Philip Tetlock's research, consistently makes more accurate probabilistic predictions than experts by using disciplined, Bayesian, process-driven methods.
As defined in cwt_nate-silver
Where it comes up · 3
- Superforecaster Will China Invade Taiwan How Will The Ukraine War End Nick Hare6 claims
- Philip E. Tetlock4 claims
- John O. Brennan1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 11Search all claims for “superforecaster” →
- Forecasting performance is not correlated with a person's knowledge or background regardless of the question being forecast; it is driven mainly by approach, so a good forecaster will be good on any topic and a russia expert is not necessarily better at forecasting russia.Superforecaster Will China Invade Taiwan How Will The Ukraine War End Nick Hare
- An aggregation algorithm built from forecasters' judgments outperformed 99.8 percent of the very forecasters from whom it was derived; Tetlock's own attempts to second-guess the composite where he thought it was excessively aggressive significantly degraded his accuracy, dropping him from the top fraction to the middle of the pack.Philip E. Tetlock
- Forecasting performance is highly persistent across time, with a correlation of about 0.65 between one year's performance and the next, meaning the best way to find a good forecaster this year is to find one who performed well last year.Superforecaster Will China Invade Taiwan How Will The Ukraine War End Nick Hare
- The forecasting technique you use dominates the information you have access to, such that superforecasters outperformed CIA analysts who had access to top secret classified information; all the information in the world with the wrong technique will not produce a good forecast.Superforecaster Will China Invade Taiwan How Will The Ukraine War End Nick Hare
- Quantitative forecasting approaches reliably work even on seemingly unprecedented one-off geopolitical questions with no obvious sample size—such as whether a country will leave the EU before Brexit ever happened—producing probabilities that turn out to be quite reliable.Superforecaster Will China Invade Taiwan How Will The Ukraine War End Nick Hare
- People who grow up with a second culture appear to have some forecasting advantage because accountability to conflicting audiences and value pluralism gives them a richer internal dialogue and stronger perspective-taking skills, which are important parts of superforecasting.Philip E. Tetlock
- Good intelligence forecasting is not 'prediction' but identifying the variables and factors that, if they evolve in a certain sequence, will interact to produce certain outcomes with certain implications; wisdom comes from absorbing information, seeing relationships, and intuitively applying past experience, and US policy choices are frequently determinative of future outcomes.John O. Brennan
- Given the overlap between superforecasting ability and intelligence, and between intelligence and professional success across many fields, superforecasting techniques almost certainly also help predict how successful people will be.Philip E. Tetlock
- There is substantial similarity in the cognitive ability and cognitive-style profiles of superforecasters and the staff of elite hedge funds like Goldman Sachs, so a contest between them would be a tight race rather than a clear win for either.Philip E. Tetlock
- A commodities trader who uses superforecasting methods but had no expert knowledge of Russia publicly predicted the Russian invasion for months with rising probabilities and acted on it, including buying a hotel in Prague to house the refugees he anticipated would arrive.Superforecaster Will China Invade Taiwan How Will The Ukraine War End Nick Hare