subject to the jurisdiction
14th Amendment language granting citizenship to all born in the U.S. 'subject to the jurisdiction thereof'; debate centers on whether this requires mere territorial presence or some deeper allegiance/legal status
As defined in Trump’s Second Term: Neil Howe on Winners, Losers, and Constitutional Showdowns
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “subject to the jurisdiction” →
- The 14th Amendment's 'subject to the jurisdiction' clause has evolved through common law interpretation and legal systems across Americas and Europe, with US law being unusual in using jus soli (law of soil) rather than jus sanguinis (law of blood), reflecting America's identity as a colonist nation.Trump’s Second Term: Neil Howe on Winners, Losers, and Constitutional Showdowns
- The Wong Kim Arc precedent (1898) established that children born to alien parents on U.S. soil are birthright citizens under the 14th Amendment based on common law principles, and this 50,000-word decision thoroughly addressed 'subject to the jurisdiction' language.Trump’s Second Term: Neil Howe on Winners, Losers, and Constitutional Showdowns
- Trump issued an executive order disallowing birthright citizenship based on reinterpretation of the 14th Amendment's 'subject to the jurisdiction of the United States' clause, though this is 'by far the longest shot' and very unlikely to be overturned, though Trump camp argues it should mean legal residency rather than mere presence.Trump’s Second Term: Neil Howe on Winners, Losers, and Constitutional Showdowns
- The interpretation of 'subject to the jurisdiction' in the 14th Amendment is contested, with Trump camp arguing it means legal residency/binding to the US, not merely being subject to law, making constitutional reinterpretation difficultTrump’s Second Term: Neil Howe on Winners, Losers, and Constitutional Showdowns