structural realism
A philosophical position holding that what science reveals about reality is its structure or relations rather than the intrinsic nature of objects.
As defined in AMA | August 2024
Where it comes up · 7
- 33 | James Ladyman on Reality, Metaphysics, and Complexity4 claims
- John Mearsheimer3 claims
- 25 | David Chalmers on Consciousness, the Hard Problem, and Living in a Simulation2 claims
- Lex Fridman Podcast #428 - Sean Carroll1 claim
- 295 | Solo: Emergence and Layers of Reality1 claim
- AMA | August 20241 claim
- AMA | October 20211 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 13Search all claims for “structural realism” →
- Following structural realism (Ladyman and Ross) and Dennett's 'real patterns,' the patterns preserved as you move between higher and lower level theories are themselves real, so emergent higher-level entities like tables and chairs genuinely exist; a definition of reality not broad enough to include tables and chairs is the wrong definition.295 | Solo: Emergence and Layers of Reality
- Carroll claimed in a prior AMA that realism is generally more fruitful than instrumentalism, but a listener challenges whether there is significant evidence for this and questions the realist/instrumentalist dualism itself, citing Dennett's 'Real Patterns'.AMA | August 2024
- Even if we are in a simulation, it does not follow (contra Descartes and The Matrix) that the world is an illusion with no real tables, chairs, or matter; rather, we would have made a surprising discovery that those things are ultimately made of information and computational processes realized in the next universe up. Since physics describes only structure, the structure remains exactly real—electrons are real, just made of bits.25 | David Chalmers on Consciousness, the Hard Problem, and Living in a Simulation
- States are not inherently aggressive; rather, as long as they exist in anarchy they have no choice but to behave aggressively, because the structure of the system—not individual will to power—drives competition and war. In a hierarchic system with a higher authority, states would have no reason to fear the balance of power.John Mearsheimer
- Against the claim that spacetime is an illusion, structural realism holds that even though we don't know reality at the deepest level, the predictions a theory makes (e.g. when the sun rises) point to something true about our understanding regardless of changing fundamental ontology, so calling spacetime an illusion is simply wrong even if our best formulation is incomplete.Lex Fridman Podcast #428 - Sean Carroll
- Epistemic structural realism holds that across scientific revolutions we throw away the ontology (the fundamental stuff) but preserve and improve the structures of what relates to what, including the mapping between formalism and observation, so phenomena like the Earth orbiting the Sun survive even as classical mechanics gives way to relativity or quantum mechanics; the ontic version, claiming structures themselves exist without things, Carroll finds unintelligible.AMA | October 2021
- Because physics is purely structural/relational—it characterizes mass only by how mass-bearing particles interact, never by what mass is intrinsically—there is room for an intrinsic nature underlying the structure; the panpsychist proposal is that this intrinsic nature is consciousness (or proto-experience), so mind grounds the physical web without requiring any revision of physics, since the structure and laws stay exactly as they are while consciousness does the underlying causal work.25 | David Chalmers on Consciousness, the Hard Problem, and Living in a Simulation
- Structural realism is a form of scientific realism compatible with radical theory change: when we abandon theories, continuity with current theories is much easier to see at the mathematical or structural level than at the level of fundamental claims about reality, so what is preserved across revolutions are the real patterns at some level of approximation.33 | James Ladyman on Reality, Metaphysics, and Complexity
- On the real-patterns view the pattern is primary and the 'thing' is just a way of identifying or talking about the pattern; whenever we investigate actual things they turn out to be collections of relations among other things, so relations may go all the way down, and we should not assume otherwise.33 | James Ladyman on Reality, Metaphysics, and Complexity
- Contrary to the view that the Cold War was primarily an ideological contest of communism versus liberal democracy, the Soviets were realists to the core and ideology mattered little in Stalin's foreign policy; the US-China competition is different and more dangerous because the Chinese are realists par excellence while American leaders have a powerful liberal bent that prevents them from seeing the world in realist terms.John Mearsheimer