street epistemology
A stepwise conversation method, originating among atheists/agnostics, that explores a person's reasoning and the quality of their epistemology rather than arguing facts, aiming to build robust critical thinking.
As defined in David McRaney on How Minds Change
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “street epistemology” →
- Street epistemology practitioners aim not to change a specific belief but to get people to adopt more robust, critical epistemologies—how they vet what they think and feel—because changing a person's epistemological approach to the world is a deeper and more powerful form of mind change than flipping any single belief, attitude, or value.David McRaney on How Minds Change
- Numerous independently developed conversation techniques—deep canvasing, street epistemology, smart politics, motivational interviewing, cognitive behavioral therapy—were created by groups unaware of each other and largely unaware of the supporting science, yet converged on nearly the same step-by-step technique, because brains resist persuasion for universal reasons just as airplanes must look like airplanes because physics is constant.David McRaney on How Minds Change
- By asking someone why they didn't rate their certainty higher (e.g. 'how come not an eight or nine?'), you prompt them to generate their own counter-arguments against their position; because the counter-arguments are theirs and not yours, no reactance is triggered, and these fresh self-generated counter-arguments durably affect how they see the issue going forward.David McRaney on How Minds Change
- Asking someone to rate their certainty on a scale from zero to ten (or one to 100) is a 'magic' move common to street epistemology and motivational interviewing: it pulls the person out of the binary right/wrong debate frame, prompts a metacognitive pause, and sets up the follow-up question of why that number—encouraging them to examine their own reasoning.David McRaney on How Minds Change
- A core rule across all the persuasion techniques is to stay in the other person's head, not yours: repeat their claim back in their own words and use their definitions for terms, because they may mean something entirely different by a word like 'the government' than you would assume from a civics textbook.David McRaney on How Minds Change
- These rapport-based techniques are poorly suited to increasing intolerance; for that, fear-based techniques and the demagogue's toolkit work better, because street epistemology is neutral and tends to give people a more complex, nuanced view—often revealing their position rests on received wisdom—which more often weakens than strengthens prejudice.David McRaney on How Minds Change
- The greatest value of these mind-changing techniques is not as a proselytizing or political-change tool but as a form of human interaction—building rapport, retracting claims rather than doubling down, and Venn-diagramming our viewpoints to combine what's right in each—which matters especially in an era of trying to save democracy.David McRaney on How Minds Change