stepping stones
Intermediate discoveries or steps on the path to an outcome, which often look nothing like the eventual result but are necessary prerequisites for it.
As defined in Kenneth Stanley - Greatness Without Goals - [Invest Like the Best, EP.283]
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 10 of 27Search all claims for “stepping stones” →
- Vacuum tubes were studied for their electrical properties from the 1700s onward by researchers who had no thought of computation, yet this work became an essential prerequisite for the first working computers in the 1940s.Kenneth Stanley - Greatness Without Goals - [Invest Like the Best, EP.283]
- Modest objectives such as improving a lap time or upgrading software are reasonable and can be pursued with metrics, because their stepping stones are known; the critique applies only to objectives where the path is unknown.Kenneth Stanley - Greatness Without Goals - [Invest Like the Best, EP.283]
- Major inventions happen only when the prerequisite technology becomes available, so launching computers in the 1840s or a space program in 1900 would have been insane, because the stepping stones were not yet in place.Kenneth Stanley - Greatness Without Goals - [Invest Like the Best, EP.283]
- Artificial general intelligence is too many unknown stepping stones away to be a principled investment objective, but AI-adjacent applications such as computers doing human-like computation are the nearer stepping stones worth pursuing.Kenneth Stanley - Greatness Without Goals - [Invest Like the Best, EP.283]
- Ambitious predictions made without the necessary stepping stones in place, such as 2016 claims about imminent self-driving cars, produce false visionary bets that lead to serious losses, including divisions being created and later sold off.Kenneth Stanley - Greatness Without Goals - [Invest Like the Best, EP.283]
- The only way the Picbreeder discoveries happened was that their discoverers were not trying to reach them; had they targeted the final product, they would not have selected the intermediate stepping stones.Kenneth Stanley - Greatness Without Goals - [Invest Like the Best, EP.283]
- Collecting stepping stones is not random, because the stepping stones that get archived are chosen for interestingness, and interesting things carry potential to lead to other interesting things.Kenneth Stanley - Greatness Without Goals - [Invest Like the Best, EP.283]
- If researchers working on vacuum tubes had been pulled into building computers, the stepping stone would have disappeared, so neither vacuum tubes nor computers would have resulted.Kenneth Stanley - Greatness Without Goals - [Invest Like the Best, EP.283]
- The objective paradox applies when the stepping stones are mysterious, especially when several of them must be crossed on the way to the goal, so objectives such as curing cancer, reaching AGI, or lowering inflation fall into the problematic category.Kenneth Stanley - Greatness Without Goals - [Invest Like the Best, EP.283]
- Setting an objective actually hurts one's ability to reach ambitious, hard-to-reach goals when the stepping stones along the path are unknown, because the objective-driven method does not work for discovery.Kenneth Stanley - Greatness Without Goals - [Invest Like the Best, EP.283]