specific performance
A legal remedy compelling a breaching party to actually perform their contractual promise, rather than merely pay money damages for breaking it.
As defined in Leo Katz on Why the Law is So Perverse
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “specific performance” →
- A Kidney Club—where members agree that whoever is randomly designated by lottery must donate a kidney to a member in need—would be a rational, mutually beneficial insurance arrangement that competent people would want to join, yet the law almost certainly would not enforce it and even our moral intuitions balk at it, despite the absence of incompetence, duress, deception, or harm to third parties.Leo Katz on Why the Law is So Perverse
- When a party breaches a contract, the law generally will not 'specifically enforce' the promise (forcing performance at gunpoint or via the sheriff); it instead forces the breaching party to pay damages—a rule that holds even when the beneficiary explicitly prefers the inferior actual performance over money and the other party agreed in advance.Leo Katz on Why the Law is So Perverse
- In the 18th and 19th centuries, indentured servant contracts bringing domestic servants from the Old World to the New were specifically enforceable—a fleeing servant could be forced back—because servants lacked money for damages, making such enforcement necessary for the contracts to exist; these were later regarded as repugnant.Leo Katz on Why the Law is So Perverse
- Asking for specific performance is asking society to treat a mere promissory interest as if it were the strong interest we have in our own body or property in our possession—deserving self-help, deadly or proportionate force, and criminal protection—and the law refuses because, like Bea objecting to sacrificing her leg for Chloe's finger, others can object to treating a lesser promissory interest as equivalent to a graver one.Leo Katz on Why the Law is So Perverse