sortition
The selection of officeholders or decision-makers by random lottery rather than election, used by the ancient Greeks for citizen government.
As defined in 189 | Brian Klaas on Power and the Temptation of Corruption
Where it comes up · 10
- 57 | Astra Taylor on the Promise and Challenge of Democracy5 claims
- Dwarkesh Patel Podcast - Why Leonardo was a saboteur, Gutenberg went broke, and Florence was weird – Ada Palmer2 claims
- Slavoj Zizek1 claim
- 189 | Brian Klaas on Power and the Temptation of Corruption1 claim
- 217 | Margaret Levi on Moral Political Economy1 claim
- AMA | August 20241 claim
- AMA | December 20211 claim
- AMA | December 20221 claim
and 2 more
Most important claims · 10 of 15Search all claims for “sortition” →
- Cosimo de' Medici effectively captured Florence's lottery system first by employing roughly a third of the city so that statistically about three of the nine randomly chosen councilors would be his men, giving him a controlling plurality in a consensus body with no majority; after a 1430s reversal in which bad luck got him arrested and he bribed his way out, he tightened his grip by bribing the people who actually ran the elections, illustrating that even sortition is corruptible like voting.Dwarkesh Patel Podcast - Why Leonardo was a saboteur, Gutenberg went broke, and Florence was weird – Ada Palmer
- Florence governed via sortition: eligible merchant-guild members (excluding the ill, insane, or deeply indebted) had their names drawn from a bag, with nine men chosen at random ruling by consensus for two-to-three months while locked in a tower to prevent bribery or kidnapping, then rotated out—a power-sharing design deliberately engineered to be tyrant-proof because any action required consensus of nine randomly selected men.Dwarkesh Patel Podcast - Why Leonardo was a saboteur, Gutenberg went broke, and Florence was weird – Ada Palmer
- More authentic democracy requires an element of chance or lottery to prevent rule by experts (which becomes tyranny)—as Kojin Karatani put it, the passage from bourgeois to proletarian democracy is the passage from voting to lottery, a principle reflected in the lottery-based selection systems of Ancient Greece and Venice that mixed checking against corruption with luck.Slavoj Zizek
- Sortition—selecting representatives by completely randomized lottery, not just for jury duty but for citizen assemblies and possibly even parliament or congress—is presented as a serious and defensible governance proposal rather than a joke.AMA | June 2026
- The jury system has genuine value despite the fact that jurors are deliberately chosen to be non-experts: it embodies civic participation (reminding citizens that judging guilt is not the domain of distant elites) and, like sortition, people put into deliberative roles usually take them seriously; there is no strong evidence that abolishing juries would yield a better system, since judges and lawyers can be flawed too.AMA | December 2021
- Representative democracy may be an experiment that has reached its limits for the complexities of today's world; rather than autocracy, alternatives worth experimenting with include legislatures chosen by lottery (sortition), participatory budgeting, and novel digital voting mechanisms, even if no clearly superior alternative has yet been found.217 | Margaret Levi on Moral Political Economy
- Rather than using sortition to govern directly (which fails because governing requires specialist knowledge), we should create randomly-selected shadow bodies — a shadow House of Representatives or shadow corporate board — with the same access to experts and information, producing non-binding decisions that expose the divergence between how actual power-holders behave (distorted by partisanship, lobbying, re-election, profit-motive) and how randomly-selected citizens would behave.189 | Brian Klaas on Power and the Temptation of Corruption
- National elections may select for fame and charisma rather than competency and values, so a form of sortition—where local communities nominate respected competent people without campaign activity or spending, and one nominee is randomly selected as president—could preserve local democracy while avoiding the national popularity contest.AMA | August 2024
- The Athenians considered elections aristocratic because the rich and well-born tend to win, and used sortition (random lottery selection of citizens) to run city affairs; as Aristotle held, 'elections are aristocratic, and selection is democratic,' making sortition a serious thought experiment for reducing the way elections reinforce privilege.57 | Astra Taylor on the Promise and Challenge of Democracy
- New movements in democratic practice like deliberative democracy, participatory budgeting, and sortition (random citizen selection into governance) depend on a more hopeful view of human nature; if people are assumed to be selfish and lazy, these approaches will not work and will produce the selfish behavior expected.Yuval Noah Harari & Rutger Bregman: YES Online Conversations