small-c constitution
A set of rules by which a group constitutes itself to make decisions—covering membership and how choices are made—as opposed to a specific capital-C document like the U.S. Constitution.
As defined in Michael Munger on Choosing in Groups
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 3 of 3Search all claims for “small-c constitution” →
- The collective will is consent to the constitution, not to particular outcomes; in the original homeowners' association agreement the will of the group is met because members agreed to the rules, but when the rules are changed mid-stream (e.g., suddenly restricting curtain colors) that is coercion that was never consented to.Michael Munger on Choosing in Groups
- There is a full-stop moral difference between a voluntary group constituted in advance with foreknowledge—such as a vegan-only neighborhood where buyers knowingly agree to be vegan—and a homeowners' association later taken over by a majority that adds new restrictions to its constitution; the former is consensual, the latter is coercion that was not consented to.Michael Munger on Choosing in Groups
- A small-c constitution has two main parts: a membership agreement by which individuals contractually become a group that chooses as a group and accepts outcomes, and a set of rules for making choices; crucially the membership part must include provisions for entry and exit, because without a way to exit the group one is not truly free.Michael Munger on Choosing in Groups