situated knowledge
Donna Haraway's concept that all knowledge is produced from a particular embodied location, context, and perspective rather than from a neutral 'view from nowhere.'
As defined in 156 | Catherine D'Ignazio on Data, Objectivity, and Bias
Where it comes up · 4
- Musa al-Gharbi1 claim
- Richard Prum1 claim
- 156 | Catherine D'Ignazio on Data, Objectivity, and Bias1 claim
- 269 | Sahar Heydari Fard on Complexity, Justice, and Social Dynamics1 claim
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “situated knowledge” →
- Chapter-based movements solve problems locally while communicating across chapters to share what worked and avoid reinventing the wheel, recognizing that a solution working in Columbus may not work in Baltimore or Arizona; by adjusting their communication structure they minimize the chance of mistakes and incorporate situated knowledge without assuming a single universal solution.269 | Sahar Heydari Fard on Complexity, Justice, and Social Dynamics
- Rather than abandoning objectivity or accepting relativism, feminist theory offers 'strong objectivity' / 'situated knowledge' (Haraway, Harding): since all knowledge is situated in a particular context and value system, we achieve more reliable knowledge by including more people from more places, recognizing our blind spots, and breaking down exclusionary norms—because the current conception of objectivity has itself been exclusive and 'imagined.'156 | Catherine D'Ignazio on Data, Objectivity, and Bias
- Prum's distinctive scientific style, rooted in childhood bird-watching, focuses on idiosyncratic instances rather than law-like generalizations—what Donna Haraway calls 'situated knowledge,' the view from a specific 'here' rather than a voice from nowhere—and he argues that many scientists go astray by pursuing what others deem important, producing uninspired incremental work, whereas he asks what is the coolest problem he could solve.Richard Prum
- While people with different life experiences genuinely perceive and reason about the world in nontrivially different ways, no subset of people (Muslims, mixed-race, etc.) has uniquely acute understanding of the social world; rather, all knowledge is partially situated, so combining diverse perspectives yields a more comprehensive understanding.Musa al-Gharbi