simulation argument
The hypothesis, associated with Nick Bostrom, that we might be living inside a computer simulation.
As defined in 130 | Frank Wilczek on the Present and Future of Fundamental Physics
Where it comes up · 12
- 107 - Is Life Actually Worth Living2 claims
- 151 - Will We Destroy The Future2 claims
- 345 | Adam Elga on Being Rational in a Very Large Universe2 claims
- 75 | Max Tegmark on Reality, Simulation, and the Multiverse2 claims
- Oxford Genius: AI Will Become Earth’s Dominant Mind | Nick Bostrom2 claims
- The Past and Future of AI (with Dwarkesh Patel)1 claim
- 57 - An Evening With Richard Dawkins And Sam Harris 11 claim
- 389 - The Politics Of Risk1 claim
and 4 more
Most important claims · 10 of 17Search all claims for “simulation argument” →
- The simulation argument shows at least one of three propositions is true: (1) virtually all civilizations at our stage go extinct before technological maturity; (2) technologically mature civilizations almost all lose interest in creating ancestor simulations; or (3) we are almost certainly living in a computer simulation—because if the first two are false, simulated people with our experiences would vastly outnumber non-simulated ones.151 - Will We Destroy The Future
- The simulation and doomsday arguments fail because they require placing no evidentiary weight on our senses and assume we are typical observers; but we are not typical — we know specific facts about ourselves — and as good Bayesians we should use all data we already have, so the sound form of anthropic reasoning weights scenarios by the probability that someone exactly like me would appear, not by assuming I am average.AMA | February 2021
- Bostrom's simulation argument runs backwards from how Seth sees it: the possibility that we live in a simulation requires substrate independence to be true, an assumption Bostrom skates over; since substrate independence is not a safe assumption, the prior credence that we are in a simulation should be lower—indeed one could (weakly) argue that not wanting the simulation conclusion is a reason consciousness must be substrate-dependent.168 | Anil Seth on Emergence, Information, and Consciousness
- Our ordinary waking experience already has a dream-like, experience-machine quality: neurologically, the brain produces a controlled hallucination with limited real-world input, and as we connect brains directly to computers and virtual reality, a literal experience machine is coming whether we like it or not.107 - Is Life Actually Worth Living
- If the simulation argument were sound, the large majority of simulated beings should exist in the lowest-resolution simulations because those are the easiest and cheapest to make; yet empirically we observe a very high-resolution reality even though we ourselves can easily make crude simulations, so there is a logical flaw in expecting to find ourselves in a high-fidelity simulation.75 | Max Tegmark on Reality, Simulation, and the Multiverse
- People's recoil from the experience machine smuggles in associated concerns not intrinsic to it — chiefly being out of touch with reality and not being in genuine relationship with conscious others; once those confounds are removed (e.g., a machine populated by genuinely conscious AI), the recoil dissolves, supporting the view that consciousness is the reservoir of value.107 - Is Life Actually Worth Living
- Bostrom's simulation argument—that since we will build many simulated minds, we should expect to be one—is flawed at its final step, because if we are simulated then the same reasoning applies recursively within our simulation, implying we are simulated infinitely many times; moreover the argument only works if you know you are in basement reality, but concluding you are simulated violates that very assumption, leaving you unable to say anything probable about the basement reality you'd be simulated in.75 | Max Tegmark on Reality, Simulation, and the Multiverse
- The simulation argument logically demonstrates that at least one of three propositions must be true: (1) almost all civilizations at our current technological stage go extinct before reaching maturity, (2) technologically mature civilizations converge on losing interest in creating detailed simulations of their ancestors, or (3) we are living in a computer simulation created by an advanced civilization.Oxford Genius: AI Will Become Earth’s Dominant Mind | Nick Bostrom
- The simulation hypothesis is logically possible but discredited on examination because the observed laws don't look like a competently programmed simulation: they have hidden complexity not used for anything, and they are tightly constrained—local and unchanging in time and place—whereas a programmer would have no reason to obey those constraints (game designers trash them all), and the hypothesis also begs the question of what the simulating substrate is made of.130 | Frank Wilczek on the Present and Future of Fundamental Physics
- Peter Thiel is unusual within the river in being anti-probabilist: when asked how often he'd end up in his current position across a thousand simulated worlds, he objected that the question is poorly formulated because if the world is deterministic the answer is 100% and if probabilistic it depends on the perturbations inserted—reflecting a religious, contrarian, right-leaning worldview beneath his stated libertarianism.389 - The Politics Of Risk