sibling studies
Studies that compare siblings raised by the same mother where one was treated (e.g., breastfed) and another was not, holding maternal characteristics constant to reduce bias
As defined in Emily Oster on Cribsheet
Where it comes up · 1
- Emily Oster on Cribsheet3 claims
Most important claims · 3 of 3Search all claims for “sibling studies” →
- Observational studies comparing breastfed to non-breastfed children are heavily biased because mothers who breastfeed differ systematically—more educated, richer, more stable family structures (in the US)—and these traits independently drive better child outcomes, so simple comparisons confound the effect of breastfeeding with the effect of family characteristics.Emily Oster on Cribsheet
- Sibling studies of breastfeeding hold the mother constant but are not randomized—the reason one sibling is breastfed and another isn't is unknown and could itself bias the result, so even these better studies must be interrogated for likely sources of bias.Emily Oster on Cribsheet
- When you focus on randomized control trials (the Belarus study) and sibling studies (which hold the mother constant), breastfeeding's benefits are much more muted than public claims—statistically significant but small early-life reductions in gastrointestinal disease and rashes, with no support for claimed effects on IQ, obesity, eczema, or long-run allergies.Emily Oster on Cribsheet