sentient
Having subjective conscious experience or feeling, as opposed to merely processing information.
As defined in Erik Hoel on the Threat to Humanity from AI
Where it comes up · 5
- Paul Bloom on Cruelty3 claims
- 342 - Animal Minds Moral Truths3 claims
- Do All Creatures, Great and Small, and Made From Silicon, Have Rights? (with Jeff Sebo)2 claims
- Erik Hoel on the Threat to Humanity from AI1 claim
- 58 | Seth MacFarlane on Using Science Fiction to Explore Humanity1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 10Search all claims for “sentient” →
- The mere fact that a being belongs to a different reproductively isolated species (like a Neanderthal) is not enough to strip away its intrinsic moral significance, because if it remains conscious, sentient, and agentic with the same capacities, interests, and vulnerabilities, you still have moral responsibilities to it.Do All Creatures, Great and Small, and Made From Silicon, Have Rights? (with Jeff Sebo)
- The cognitive differences between humans and animals matter morally for the wrongness of killing—because animals like squirrels and dogs lack our biographical sense of life and future plans—but those differences are far less significant for the wrongness of inflicting pain, and we are on shaky ground assuming birds and mammals have a lesser capacity for pain than humans.342 - Animal Minds Moral Truths
- Whether a sufficiently advanced silicon-based being (like a Westworld robot) can genuinely feel pleasure and pain is subject to real uncertainty on two axes: the ethics axis (what capacity—sentience, consciousness, or agency—is the basis for moral standing) and the science axis (whether silicon chips can actually realize those capacities), making it genuinely confusing how to treat such a being.Do All Creatures, Great and Small, and Made From Silicon, Have Rights? (with Jeff Sebo)
- What matters morally is the severity of pain or suffering, not the species of the being experiencing it; pain is pain whether felt by a human, cow, dog, or chimpanzee, so species membership does not allow one being's interests to override those of another sentient being.342 - Animal Minds Moral Truths
- Because morally relevant capacities (sentience, biographical continuity) do not track species boundaries, an anencephalic human infant who will never be conscious has, taken in itself, less moral significance than a dog, cow, or pig that can experience good or bad lives—exposing speciesism in cases like a hospital refusing to use such an infant as an organ donor while routinely experimenting on more conscious animals.342 - Animal Minds Moral Truths
- Humans also operate by a kind of effective autocompletion and our brains are likewise black boxes—Beethoven always knew what note should come next, much as ChatGPT does—so 'it's just autocomplete' doesn't prove the AI isn't smart, but neither does the brain's similarity prove the AI is a sentient brain.Erik Hoel on the Threat to Humanity from AI
- It is reasonable to assume artificial intelligence will eventually achieve consciousness, at which point it would be a person deserving moral consideration—meaning a sentient sex robot, for example, could not be morally created for that purpose.58 | Seth MacFarlane on Using Science Fiction to Explore Humanity
- The morally pressing issue with sentient beings—whether a dog, animals raised for food, or Westworld robots—is not so much killing as suffering: it is probably not wrong to painlessly put down a dog with cancer, but it is wrong to let it suffer in agony, and there is every indication the Westworld robots can suffer.Paul Bloom on Cruelty
- Robots of the sophistication and complexity depicted in Westworld are probably sentient—it beggars belief that they don't have feelings—and since most cognitive scientists hold that being made of flesh rather than silicon doesn't obviously matter, our best bet when something begs for mercy, converses, and has goals is to conclude there is somebody home and that we shouldn't treat them badly.Paul Bloom on Cruelty
- Perfectly duplicating a brain is one way to build a sentient robot, but it is not the only way; there may be many routes to constructing intelligence and consciousness, just as conscious beings could plausibly evolve on a very different planet through entirely different processes.Paul Bloom on Cruelty