sentience candidate
Jonathan Birch's term for an entity for which there is a realistic scientific possibility of sentience that ought to be taken seriously in policy and ethics.
As defined in AMA | November 2024
Where it comes up · 2
- 292 | Jonathan Birch on Animal Sentience5 claims
- AMA | November 20241 claim
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “sentience candidate” →
- Birch's team, commissioned to review evidence of sentience in cephalopod mollusks and decapod crustaceans, successfully recommended that the UK's Animal Welfare (Sentience) Act of 2022 — which creates a duty for policymakers to consider animal welfare impacts — be amended to extend its scope beyond vertebrates to those invertebrate groups, and the government implemented that central recommendation.292 | Jonathan Birch on Animal Sentience
- The question of when a human fetus becomes a 'sentience candidate' (in Jonathan Birch's framing) is potentially relevant to the highly charged debate over late-stage abortion policy and deserves consideration.AMA | November 2024
- Rather than asking the unanswerable question 'is the animal sentient', we should ask whether it is a 'sentience candidate' — defined as a case where at least one credible view within the zone of reasonable disagreement establishes a realistic possibility of sentience, and the evidence base is rich enough to identify welfare risks and assess precautions.292 | Jonathan Birch on Animal Sentience
- There is enough evidence to compel taking the realistic possibility of sentience seriously in all vertebrates, cephalopod mollusks (octopuses, squid, cuttlefish), decapod crustaceans, and insects; whether sentience arose once in a common ancestor over 560 million years ago or evolved three times independently is uncertain, with Birch leaning toward three independent origins.292 | Jonathan Birch on Animal Sentience
- If a project succeeded in completely recreating in software everything a mouse's brain does (as imagined extending OpenWorm to 'open mouse'), the resulting emulation would be a sentience candidate; moreover such emulation work deserves more funding because it could replace much animal research by allowing precise intervention without injuring living animals.292 | Jonathan Birch on Animal Sentience
- Single-celled organisms and plants are neither sentience candidates nor investigation priorities, because there is no evidence of the relevant brain mechanisms (cortical or midbrain) on any credible theory of sentience, in sharp contrast to many invertebrates for which such evidence exists.292 | Jonathan Birch on Animal Sentience