self-sampling assumption (SSA)
An anthropic principle holding you should reason as if you were randomly sampled from your reference class, favoring worlds where observers with your evidence are a larger fraction of that class.
As defined in Joseph Carlsmith - Utopia, AI, & Infinite Ethics
Other definitions
The anthropic principle that gives a boost to possibilities in which a high fraction of observers are like you (frequencies), requiring a reference class defining who counts as sufficiently like you.
345 | Adam Elga on Being Rational in a Very Large Universe
Where it comes up · 2
- Joseph Carlsmith - Utopia, AI, & Infinite Ethics4 claims
- 345 | Adam Elga on Being Rational in a Very Large Universe1 claim
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “self-sampling assumption (SSA)” →
- SSA implies the absurd possibility of telekinetic influence: by pre-committing to create zillions of people (in a different epistemic state) only if a boulder fails to crush a puppy, SSA makes it more likely that the boulder will jump out of the way, and similarly lets you become extremely confident about an untossed fair coin's outcome — these are decisive problems for SSA.Joseph Carlsmith - Utopia, AI, & Infinite Ethics
- The Self-Sampling Assumption (SSA) holds you should think it more likely you exist in worlds where people with your evidence form a larger fraction of your reference class; this generates the Doomsday Argument, where being born in the 21st century updates you hard toward humanity going extinct soon, which matters greatly because long-termism depends on the future being large in expectation.Joseph Carlsmith - Utopia, AI, & Infinite Ethics
- The Self-Indication Assumption (SIA) holds you should think it more likely you exist in worlds with more people sharing your evidence; in the God's-coin-toss case it implies the coin most likely came up the way that creates a million people (one-in-a-million on heads), which Carlsmith argues is a better conclusion than the alternative SSA.Joseph Carlsmith - Utopia, AI, & Infinite Ethics
- Both SIA and SSA ultimately break when confronted with infinite universes: SIA naively becomes certain you live in an infinite-population universe and then cannot compare infinite universes, and SSA also struggles, so infinities break anthropic reasoning in ways analogous to how they break ethics.Joseph Carlsmith - Utopia, AI, & Infinite Ethics
- The two main anthropic views differ in what they boost: SIA (self-indication assumption) boosts possibilities with many copies of observers like you (absolute numbers), while SSA (self-sampling assumption) boosts possibilities in which a high fraction of observers are like you (frequencies), and SSA requires fixing a free parameter about what counts as sufficiently like you.345 | Adam Elga on Being Rational in a Very Large Universe