self-reflexive observer
A representational construct in the mind that observes itself, imposing coherence on its environment; Bach's functional account of consciousness.
As defined in Joscha Bach
Where it comes up · 1
- Joscha Bach3 claims
Most important claims · 3 of 3Search all claims for “self-reflexive observer” →
- Whether current models are conscious is genuinely complicated; the model has read much text about consciousness and emulates it, but while running 100-step functions emulating adjacent brain states it could create a model of a self-reflexive observer reflecting in real time — and since our own consciousness is itself virtual (a representation of a self-reflexive observer existing only in patterns of cellular interaction, not a physical object in base reality), the question becomes one of degree of virtuality and causal power, with the LLM's consciousness more like that of a character in a novel because there is no causal need for it to be conscious to stay coherent.Joscha Bach
- Consciousness emerges at the beginning of mental development, not at a high level, and is part of a training mechanism biological nervous systems must discover to become trainable, since you cannot do stochastic backpropagation over a hundred layers of biological neurons; a part of the mind forms a self-reflexive observer that imposes coherence on its environment, spreading to the boundary of the mind.Joscha Bach
- Personal continuity is a fiction projected from your present self — you are not the same person you were last year or ten years ago — maintained for practical purposes like learning and responsibility; consciousness itself has no identity but is a law-like, unifiable principle of self-reflexive agency, so your consciousness is functionally not different from anyone else's, just running a different story.Joscha Bach