selection
Selection effect—the way the composition of a sample (here, who gets onto the show) biases observed outcomes; Cowen uses it to explain why less-famous guests are interesting.
As defined in Any Austin
Where it comes up · 6
- Claimify: Extracting high-quality claims from language model outputs5 claims
- Raj Chetty on Economic Mobility2 claims
- Zvi Mowshowitz on AI and the Dial of Progress2 claims
- Any Austin1 claim
- Larissa MacFarquhar1 claim
- The Economics of Scarcity and the UNC-Duke Basketball Game (with Michael Munger)1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 12Search all claims for “selection” →
- The severity of a voluntary initiation rite creates solidarity and belonging—the same mechanism used to train fighter pilots and elite military units—and at Duke this bonding produces tenters with higher average GPAs who are far more likely to donate large sums over long perids, potentially making the free ticket monetarily worthwhile in the long run.The Economics of Scarcity and the UNC-Duke Basketball Game (with Michael Munger)
- By creating entities more capable than us that optimize for whatever targets they're set, are copyable and configurable, operate more efficiently when humans are out of the loop, and exhibit unpredictable capabilities because they're smarter than us, the default outcome is that we lose control; even if we solve hard problems to make them behave recognizably, selection forces of economics, capitalism, and evolution leave us with a future optimizing for things we don't want, and in the medium term we likely don't survive unless many hard problems are solved.Zvi Mowshowitz on AI and the Dial of Progress
- Even if some AIs happened to evolve human-friendly norms, competition would select against them: any norm that makes an AI less competitive at getting its operator what they want will be selected out by the operator, so good norms won't emerge spontaneously and would have to be installed intentionally and carefully.Zvi Mowshowitz on AI and the Dial of Progress
- By comparing siblings of different ages within the same family who move from one neighborhood to another (e.g. a 7-year-old vs an 11-year-old), under a 'dosage' model where each extra year of exposure to a better environment helps, researchers find younger movers to high-mobility areas do better; this design neutralizes the confound of ambitious parents, since parental ambition would not create differential effects within the same family across siblings.Raj Chetty on Economic Mobility
- About 60% of the variation in outcomes across neighborhoods (at the Census tract level) is due to causal effects of place, and about 40% is due to selection—different types of people living in different places; so selection clearly matters, but there is an important causal component.Raj Chetty on Economic Mobility
- The data are consistent with Gilder's Sexual Suicide thesis: unmarried men earn less and are more likely to have social problems; although causality cannot be cleanly demonstrated and some of it is selection (women picking successful men), it would be odd if none of the relationship were causal.Larissa MacFarquhar
- In the selection stage of Claimify, sentences that do not contain verifiable claims are filtered out, such as opinion statements like 'companies should embrace AI.'Claimify: Extracting high-quality claims from language model outputs
- Claimify breaks down claim extraction into three parts: selection, disambiguation, and decomposition.Claimify: Extracting high-quality claims from language model outputs
- Claimify breaks down claim extraction into three distinct stages: selection (filtering sentences without verifiable claims), disambiguation (detecting and resolving ambiguity), and decomposition (breaking sentences into simple factual statements).Claimify: Extracting high-quality claims from language model outputs
- Across many interviews, Cowen has concluded the world is more meritocratic than he expected—people who are successful generally deserve their success—and the best interviews tend to be with people not in the public eye, both because they are more willing to say what they think and because of selection: a not-famous guest only gets on the show if they have something exceptional going for them.Any Austin