security dilemma
A concept in political science describing how one state's defensive military measures are perceived by adversaries as offensive, prompting reciprocal buildups and escalatory spirals.
As defined in A Lively Debate on the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict (with Robert Wright)
Where it comes up · 3
- Russia Is Stockpiling Missiles For War With Nato. Europe Is Shockingly Unprepared Fabian Hoffmann2 claims
- The Truth About China That The West Gets Wrong1 claim
- A Lively Debate on the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict (with Robert Wright)1 claim
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “security dilemma” →
- The security dilemma is the tendency to interpret an adversary's defensive military development as offensive, or to treat even acknowledged-defensive capabilities as future threats, producing escalatory spirals where each side's defensive move is read by the other as offensive and answered with its own buildup.A Lively Debate on the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict (with Robert Wright)
- The security dilemma (Thucydides Trap) between rising China and declining US is not inevitable—China recognized it decades ago and built resiliency accordingly, while the US only recently began to view China as a threat; the outcome depends on whether US develops embedded optionalityThe Truth About China That The West Gets Wrong
- Russia is producing far more missiles than it launches at Ukraine—particularly higher-value cruise and ballistic missiles—and is therefore stockpiling them for other contingencies, the most significant of which is a confrontation with NATO, where ballistic missiles would be hardest for Europe to intercept.Russia Is Stockpiling Missiles For War With Nato. Europe Is Shockingly Unprepared Fabian Hoffmann
- Since one cannot read decision-makers' minds or predict the future, the responsible approach is to derive intent from observable Russian capabilities, production numbers, and stockpiling, and to prepare for the worst-case scenario of a NATO war.Russia Is Stockpiling Missiles For War With Nato. Europe Is Shockingly Unprepared Fabian Hoffmann