school vouchers
Government-funded certificates that let families choose where to spend public education money, including private schools—a Friedman proposal.
As defined in Robert Chitester on Milton Friedman and Free to Choose
Where it comes up · 4
- Angus Burgin on Hayek, Friedman, and the Great Persuasion3 claims
- Robert Chitester on Milton Friedman and Free to Choose2 claims
- Roland Fryer on Educational Reform2 claims
- Emily Oster on the Family Firm1 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “school vouchers” →
- A small average treatment effect can mask large effects in opposite directions for different subgroups—for example, private schools may show a small positive average test-score effect, but for kids with ADHD or on the autism spectrum public schools may be far better due to their legal responsibility to provide infrastructure, so slavish adherence to the average would badly mislead.Emily Oster on the Family Firm
- Many of the policy ideas Friedman proposed in Capitalism and Freedom in 1962—private/personal Social Security, flexible exchange rates, a volunteer army, eliminating agricultural price supports and corporate subsidies, and school vouchers—were viewed as ridiculous at the time but have since either happened or entered the mainstream intellectual debate.Robert Chitester on Milton Friedman and Free to Choose
- When told how many of his ideas had become mainstream, Friedman's surprising reaction was that he was mostly a failure—little real progress had been made on agricultural price supports, corporate subsidies, Social Security, personal responsibility, or vouchers, and the public school system remained very strong.Robert Chitester on Milton Friedman and Free to Choose
- Friedman's theory of political change was to lay out a stockpile of policy ideas—many seeming crazy at the time—through vehicles like his Newsweek column, which would lie in wait until a crisis made the existing system seem unworkable, at which point those ready-to-hand alternatives would suddenly seem viable; ideas don't drive change but become viable when political events reach a crisis point.Angus Burgin on Hayek, Friedman, and the Great Persuasion
- Friedman, though a utopian who would abolish public education and income redistribution in his ideal society, advocated incremental market-oriented compromises like school vouchers and the negative income tax because he judged it unlikely a crisis would lead people to abolish those systems, and these proposals made him seem practical and let him speak differently to centrist and libertarian audiences.Angus Burgin on Hayek, Friedman, and the Great Persuasion
- Making per-pupil expenditure portable to parents—giving inner-city families roughly $20,000 a year to spend on education as they see fit—would, unlike the current captive-audience public system, induce new institutions to develop to serve them, harnessing genuine competition that does not currently exist in public schooling.Roland Fryer on Educational Reform
- For three generations America failed inner-city kids with horrible schools, and almost no one defends the status quo, which is why Russ supports trying a wide range of alternatives—charter schools, vouchers, and creative experiments—rather than clinging to existing approaches.Roland Fryer on Educational Reform
- Roberts argues against incremental compromise policies like school vouchers and the earned income tax credit because once recipients receive the money they will use the political process to enlarge the scope of those programs, leading to bad outcomes—which he believes is what has happened.Angus Burgin on Hayek, Friedman, and the Great Persuasion