scalar
A single number; Roberts uses the math concept to describe how economics reduces complex outcomes to one measure like an average or growth rate.
As defined in Dani Rodrik on Neoliberalism
Where it comes up · 4
- L.A. Paul on Vampires, Life Choices, and Transformation3 claims
- Michael Saylor2 claims
- Dani Rodrik on Neoliberalism1 claim
- Rob Wiblin and Russ Roberts on Charity, Science, and Utilitarianism1 claim
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “scalar” →
- Trying to measure satisfaction or happiness as a single number on a one-to-ten scale fails because what you are trying to capture—an experience as complex as parenthood—is not a scalar but a giant matrix of glorious highs and miserable lows that cannot be netted out, and survey honesty is itself doubtful.Rob Wiblin and Russ Roberts on Charity, Science, and Utilitarianism
- Inflation is not a single number but an n-dimensional vector tracking the change in price of every product, service, and asset across places and over time; treating it as a scalar (like the CPI) lets policymakers pick the one number that supports their agenda and ignore all other consequences.Michael Saylor
- The paradox of choosing suffering—where people can rightly say a life filled with suffering is more valuable for them—is very difficult to explain on a quantifiable, person-independent calculus, but becomes intelligible once we admit the value of first-person experience, authenticity, and aesthetic value that cannot be reduced to an individual-independent number.L.A. Paul on Vampires, Life Choices, and Transformation
- Economics' focus on measurability narrows attention to scalars like averages and growth rates, when what we actually care about is a matrix of outcomes including dignity, flourishing, pride, responsibility, and autonomy—things economists tend to ignore because they cannot be easily quantified—which has hampered the discipline's appeal to both the Left and the Right.Dani Rodrik on Neoliberalism
- The cruder a model in economics or psychology, the easier it is to weave whatever narrative one wants (inflation is good, inflation is bad), whereas taking an engineering approach with richer mathematics makes it increasingly difficult to escape a true, deep understanding of the system's dynamics.Michael Saylor
- Happiness is overrated as a goal for one's children or oneself; what matters is a rich life that includes meaning, satisfaction, and contentment, whereas the common notion of happiness as the highs and lows of momentary existence is in many ways unimportant.L.A. Paul on Vampires, Life Choices, and Transformation
- Reducing the multifaceted nature of an experience like being a parent or a vampire to a single number (a scalar) by weighting and combining its aspects is a fundamental violence to and misunderstanding of human reality; the attempt to build a science of happiness that quantifies such experiences is not merely premature but essentially unscientific.L.A. Paul on Vampires, Life Choices, and Transformation