reverse causality
An error in which the assumed cause and effect are reversed, e.g. concluding diet soda causes weight gain when people who already gain weight easily choose diet soda.
As defined in Gary Taubes on the Case Against Sugar
Where it comes up · 4
- Morten Jerven on African Economic Growth3 claims
- Valerie Ramey on Stimulus and Multipliers 10/24/20111 claim
- Alberto Alesina on Fiscal Policy and Austerity1 claim
- Gary Taubes on the Case Against Sugar1 claim
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “reverse causality” →
- A central measurement problem in austerity research is reverse causality: a falling deficit-over-GDP ratio may reflect rising GDP (the denominator) rather than fiscal tightening (the numerator), so one cannot infer that deficit reduction caused growth without identifying actual policy decisions.Alberto Alesina on Fiscal Policy and Austerity
- Government spending decisions are simultaneous with monetary policy, tax policy, and regulation, and causation runs in both directions (a weak economy can prompt stimulus, and stimulus can be mistaken for the cause of a weak economy), so correlation between spending and output cannot be read as causation.Valerie Ramey on Stimulus and Multipliers 10/24/2011
- The subtraction approach puts rich countries on one side and poor countries on the other and concludes poorer countries are poor because they have different institutions, embedding a massive reversal of causality and a Marxian assumption that a rich country's present is the poor country's future; if history and institutions truly matter, this implies many different paths, so the cross-country correlation literature should be abandoned in favor of deeper contextual studies.Morten Jerven on African Economic Growth
- Many growth correlations fail the basic test that cause must precede effect: high aid dependence is a phenomenon of the 1990s, so it cannot plausibly have caused slow growth in the 1960s-1980s, and the causality may run the other way, with slow-growing troubled countries needing and therefore receiving more aid.Morten Jerven on African Economic Growth
- The finding that low governance quality correlates with slow growth is undermined because the governance ratings were subjective surveys of businessmen taken in selected countries in the 1980s, long after those economies had already experienced growth distress, so low institutional quality is more plausibly an effect of economic decline than its cause.Morten Jerven on African Economic Growth
- Epidemiological studies finding lean people eat more sugar than obese people are confounded by reverse causality: lean people drink sugary Coke because they can, while those who gain weight easily switch to Diet Coke, so when the diet-soda drinkers gain weight anyway, the observed correlation between low sugar intake and weight gain is misleading.Gary Taubes on the Case Against Sugar