restriction of range
The degree to which a situation narrows the set of behaviors that are socially permissible; high restriction indicates tightness.
As defined in Michele Gelfand on Rule Makers, Rule Breakers
Where it comes up · 2
- Wide or Deep?5 claims
- Michele Gelfand on Rule Makers, Rule Breakers2 claims
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “restriction of range” →
- In the general American population, height correlates positively with NBA-level points scored in some years, but within NBA players only the correlation turns negative, so a study restricted to NBA players would wrongly advise parents to have short children.Wide or Deep?
- Because tightness-looseness is not directly observable, validating it requires multiple measures—surveys of the permissible range of behavior across situations and countries, coding ethnographies of preindustrial societies, dictionaries, brain imaging, and computational models—seeing whether predictions are borne out homologously across levels.Michele Gelfand on Rule Makers, Rule Breakers
- Tightness can be operationalized as the range of behavior permissible in a situation: tight situations like libraries and symphonies restrict the range narrowly while loose situations like rock concerts permit a wide range; across 30 countries the rank order of situations is roughly universal, but tight cultures restrict the range across many more situations.Michele Gelfand on Rule Makers, Rule Breakers
- Grit research has mostly studied people pursuing very narrow goals over very short periods, such as surviving six-week orientation or advancing in a spelling bee, so the findings may not generalize to long-term performance in life.Wide or Deep?
- At West Point, the grit survey predicted who would complete Beast Barracks better than the whole candidate score used for admissions, although grit typically explains only about 1 to 6 percent of variance in the studies Epstein reviewed.Wide or Deep?
- The 10,000-hour rule rests on a study of 30 pre-screened violinists at a world-famous academy, which is restriction of range; the selection squashes variability, so the average practice-hours finding cannot support claims that practice alone determines elite performance.Wide or Deep?
- In the grit studies Epstein has reviewed, grit typically explains between about 1 and 6 percent of the variance in performance, far less than companies that test for it probably assume.Wide or Deep?